5 ms·
> According to the University of Cambridge, about 118.75 tWh (terrawatt hours). I stopped reading as soon as they quoted that silly inaccurate UoC website that
by latchkey 4y ago
> According to the University of Cambridge, about 118.75 tWh (terrawatt hours).
I stopped reading as soon as they quoted that silly inaccurate UoC website that gets quoted over and over again.
Why? Because they even admit, in their own methodology (https://ccaf.io/cbeci/mining_map/methodology https://ccaf.io/cbeci/mining_map/methodology), that it is an extrapolation from less than 50% of the total hash. Even worse, is the pools they extrapolate from have been Chinese based. Although, that's changed over time, which invalidates their numbers even more.
Even still, there is no way to know how that power is generated, how much it offsets other power generation, etc... there are just too many variables to simply quote UoC.
At the end of the day, read this: https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/
- ajross 4y ago> Even still, there is no way to know That seems unconvincing. In fact how much energy is required per hash is something that's really quite easy to measure accurately. At any given time there are no more than a few dozen hardware platforms in use (they get priced out rapidly, everyone is running the newest stuff in the BTC world). Just plug them in and measure them. All that's left from there is to come up with second order corrections about stuff like grid efficiency. But we absolutely know to quite high precision how many joules were spent to produce the coins we observe to have been created.
- bombcar 4y agoAnd the only way to hypothesize something different is if there's a ASIC or something that can mine much better than existing equipment (in which case the group that had it would suddenly shoot up in the blocks mined lists) or there's a weakness in the cryptographic protocol somewhere that we don't know about.
- sanxiyn 4y agoI must note that this in fact happened in the past (AsicBoost). Currently, I don't think there is AsicBoost-like secret information, but you can't be sure. https://arxiv.org/abs/1604.00575 https://arxiv.org/abs/1604.00575
- bombcar 4y agoLet’s assume you have AsicBoost 2.0 - what would be the most strategic way to deploy it? I assume it’d look like a hashpower increase to the rest of the world, which may or may not go noticed; but perhaps have them run “normal” and then fling it wide open just before? after? a havening?
- erikpukinskis 4y agoI’d guess the optimal strategy is “get that thing turned on as fast as possible and keep as much of the cluster running 24/7 as you possibly can before you get leapfrogged.”
- dashdot 4y ago> everyone is running the newest stuff in the BTC world That's not true. The profitability of a miner is not measured with their hardware generation but with the energy cost needed to operate them. If you have access to very cheap energy, they can still be very profitable. There is a reason the market price of old mining rigs is not 0.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- ajross 4y ago> There is a reason the market price of old mining rigs is not 0. Electrical costs vary by a factor of two or three around the world. Maybe five at the extreme outliers. Modern mining hardware is tens of thousands of times more efficient than the stuff used less than a decade ago. Also due to growth in the market, the rate of production has been increasing rapidly so the total number of old rigs is negligible anyway.[1] To rather accurate first approximation, all BTC mining is done with hardware less than two years old or so. [1] Also also, the recent crash has had the effect of depressing mining revenue and accelerating the retirement of the old junk.
- latchkey 4y agoOthers have mentioned it, but I'll say it too: what you know is an estimate of total network hashrate. that's it. but! total network hashrate moves around all the time, so it is really just an estimate. it has gotten better over time, but these machines don't operate perfectly 24/7 and older hardware is still in use. power outages happen too. stuff is just coming on and offline all the time. you don't know efficiency (watts to hash) of the equipment on a global scale. you can extrapolate, but it is impossible to know for sure. there are other losses, like stale and invalid shares. also impossible to know. you don't know how much is 'wasted' either... every single power supply on the planet is a snowflake. this would actually increase power usage estimates since it is effectively truly wasted energy. disclaimer: I've PoW mined since 2014. Even I, with many many megawatts of power, have a hard time calculating exactly how much power we use and that's having access to the raw data!
- jcranmer 4y agoIf you have access to the raw data, then you should be able to quite easily provide a good estimate for what the article is trying to assess--what's the actual operational cost of bitcoin mining. Estimating the energy consumption is only a vehicle to doing this because those of us who don't have any raw data to do this. What you should be able to do is: a) Open up your electricity bill and look at the total energy consumption for a given period. Admittedly, I'm not familiar with how electricity is invoiced, but I'd be surprised if there wasn't something that was at least coarsely indicating total energy consumption for a billing period. (Or you can skip several middlemen steps and just take the total cost of the electric bill.) b) Tot up all the bitcoin mining rewards you received in the same time period. c) Count how many bitcoin blocks were mined in the same time period. d) Divide b by c, now you know what fraction you are of the total bitcoin mining network. e) Divide a by d, now you have an estimate of total worldwide energy consumption of bitcoin. The only reason I can see that might make this hard is if you mine more than just bitcoin, in which case, replace "bitcoin" in the above steps with "sum over all of the cryptocurrencies you mine"--which is closer to what people want to know anyways. Even then, you can use crude weighting metrics to estimate what the consumption of just bitcoin is, which would at least let you know if the estimate is in the right ballpark or not. The exact number doesn't matter; it instead matters if the real number is closer to 14 TWh/yr, 140 TWh/yr or 1400 TWh/yr.
- betwixthewires 4y agoWell you should've continued reading. It's not about how much energy is used, it's about the fact that energy is used at all. The numbers can be extrapolated from a third of that value and still look bad.
- latchkey 4y agoWe all know bitcoin uses a lot of energy, there is no debate about that. But, on a global scale of all energy used, it is just a tiny tiny sliver of the pie (see my previous link). Just because something uses energy doesn't mean it is inherently bad. If you want to extrapolate and say that wasting energy on PoW is bad, then you also have to compare that against all of the other wasted energy. If you do, bitcoin doesn't look that bad either. Of course plenty of people here like to fixate on telling people what a good or not good use of energy is. Which is so ironic to me given that here we are using energy to have this debate and I'm sure someone out there thinks it is equally wasteful.
- betwixthewires 4y agoThe article is not about energy usage, it's about capital outflow in the form of energy expenditure. As long as mimers must pay someone to keep running, either capital outflow must match capital inflow, or the price will go down, and consequently mining will decrease and with it security. Either way, not a good store of value.
- latchkey 4y agoOk, so then this is the age old debate of what happens when mining ends? I guess I could have kept reading for some new insight there. Face palm.
- betwixthewires 4y agoThe age old debate about what happens when mining ends? When does mining end?
- cush 4y ago
- gjs278 4y ago
- Thorrez 4y agoI think it might actually be somewhat accurate. There are 6.25*6*24*365 new bitcoins created every year and given to miners. That's over $6B at current prices. So it sort of makes sense miners would spend $6B/year to acquire those $6B of new bitcoins. And that isn't factoring in transaction fees that miners also get, nor that this article was written in June when prices were a lot higher, meaning it would have been much more than $6B/year if I did those calculations then.
- andrewla 4y agoAnd that's the thing -- all the fancy gymnastics the article uses to derive the cost of running the network based on power utilization and power costs is irrelevant. The Bitcoin network pays 238,500 BTC annually for its maintenance, plus fees. This is the amount that will be paid regardless of network difficulty, price of bitcoin, mining capacity, cost of electricity, capital cost of mining equipment, etc.
- arcticbull 4y ago> I stopped reading as soon as they quoted that silly inaccurate UoC website that gets quoted over and over again. You stopped reading because you don't like what they had to say. Even mining groups who are incentivized to provide the rosiest picture are within the ballpark. Current hash rate is 245.32M TH/s. An AntMiner S19 Pro consumes 29.7 J/TH, so assuming they're all S19s (a big if) we'd be consuming 7226MJ/s or 2007.5kWh/s. That's 64TWh/yr. So your absolute best case is 1/2 of the Cambridge number. Which is exactly what they list as the "minimum" number. As soon as we start factoring in things inefficiency and losses along the way - and the fact not everyone has an S19 Pro - we start to get closer and closer to that flagship number. But let's make no mistake - even the minimum number is a staggering, mind-boggling disaster of unprecedented scale. > At the end of the day, read this: https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/ https://www.lynalden.com/bitcoin-energy/ Lyn is a zealot and a shill, and her arguments on basically any topic are trivially wrong. I would strongly recommend against trusting anything on that blog and instead look for different sources.
- latchkey 4y ago> You stopped reading because you don't like what they had to say. Yes, I literally said that. Glad we are in agreement. > Lyn is a zealot and a shill, and her arguments on basically any topic are trivially wrong. Yes, trust the guy on HN who is consistently negative about crypto about who to listen to. Sorry, but when people are so adamantly negative about something, I tend to run towards it because it often has a lot of interesting value. You have chosen the 'Chief Censor 451' role in life.
- arcticbull 4y ago> Yes, trust the guy on HN who is consistently negative about crypto about who to listen to. Sorry, but when people are so adamantly negative about something, I tend to run towards it because it often has a lot of interesting value. You have chosen the 'Chief Censor 451' role in life. I didn't tell you who to read, I suggested you dug around and found someone else who isn't a zealot and a shill. There's good authors out there, this isn't one. I follow a number of pro-crypto authors too, ones who I disagree with but respect. They're out there. Lyn is in my opinion only slightly above Pomp (who I know has retired to spend more time with his fiat) and Saylor (who was promoted to customer).
- TomSwirly 4y agoYou: "We can't know these things, so any form of estimation is wrong and bad!" Also, calling papers "silly" doesn't bolster your argument.
- latchkey 4y agoEstimation is fine. Basing a HN level of hatred on crypto because of inaccurate data... is... well... What would you prefer me to call it? The pure definition of silly is "having or showing a lack of common sense or judgment; absurd and foolish." Seems pretty accurate to me.
- zaptheimpaler 4y ago1. A poor estimate is better than none at all. No matter how uncertain it is, there has to be some range where we can say with 95% confidence, BTC energy consumption falls within this range. We all understand that any estimate will be very uncertain because of the scale and complexity of mining. 2. The arguments youre responding to about BTC being a waste of energy etc. aren't being made in this post. He's just using energy to estimate leak rate, not to assign any moral value to it.