Yeah, I have no problem with the rock-splitting scene. For me it's the boat to Valinor. Just that one boat trip already has at least half a dozen things wrong w

Yeah, I have no problem with the rock-splitting scene. For me it's the boat to Valinor. Just that one boat trip already has at least half a dozen things wrong with it. A few I could have ignored, but it just keeps getting worse and worse. There's still many great scenes too. I love Elrond's friendship with Durin, Durin & Disa's relationship, the Harfoots, the Orcs, how Numenor Looks, how everyone in Numenor looks, how their ships look. I even enjoy the spectacular action scenes with insane leaps by the elves. There's lots of good stuff in there, but it's all held together why really awkward plot twists that make no sense.