4 ms·
>This is one of the biggest scams in history. What's the deception here? Was the government going around saying how much money you could earn from a humanities
by gruez 4y ago
>This is one of the biggest scams in history.
What's the deception here? Was the government going around saying how much money you could earn from a humanities degree? Statistics about earning potential degrees of degrees were available for decades. Caveat emptor.
- Consultant32452 4y agoMy government school did have messaging to that effect. I knew it was bullshit, but lots of people believed them.
- gruez 4y agoWere they imploring people to get degrees with poor career prospects, or just degrees in general?
- Consultant32452 4y agoThey said something to the effect of "any" degree is valuable and can get you a good job.
- pxeboot 4y agoI don't know what you consider government, but the public schools I attended constantly told students that you had to go to college to be successful, no matter what degree you got.
- gruez 4y ago>but the public schools I attended constantly told students that you had to go to college to be successful, no matter what degree you got. I'm not sure what the exact messaging your school told, but I imagine it's something to the effect of "degree holders earn x% more than non-degree holders on average", which is a true statement. The "on average" part might not been stressed, but anyone with rudimentary knowledge of how the labor market works (ie. some jobs pay more than other jobs) should be able to figure out that earning potential by degree varies.
- bradleyjg 4y agoThe rudimentary knowledge in question (and the cognitive tools to work through the implications) are supposed to be provided by the very institutions deceiving students. The educational system utterly fails at equipping every graduate with the knowledge and skills to succeed in the modern economy in the 14 years they have already. Why are we giving them four more years of everyone’s life and hundreds of billions of dollars more money?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- pxeboot 4y ago> I'm not sure what the exact messaging your school told It's been a long time, but if I recall correctly, funding and rankings were partially determined by the number of high school graduates continuing on to college. There was constant pressure to take the right classes and participate in the right activities to meet college admissions requirements. The messaging came from administrators, teachers and counselors.
- aidenn0 4y agoTo a certain degree that's revealed itself to be true (if self-fulfilling). Many jobs that don't require a college degree hire college grads because they can get them and these days not having a college degree is, similar to not having a job currently, a red-flag.
- bradleyjg 4y agoExactly. We are in a trillion dollar signaling arms race funded by the federal taxpayer.
- aidenn0 4y agoIndeed, so my point was it's not wrong for high schools to tell you to take government money to keep up with the Joneses in the arms race. Unilaterally disarming is seldom the winning move.
- aortega 4y ago> Many jobs that don't require a college degree hire college grads because they can get them Exactly, that's the scam. Requiring a 'Tax' that you pay the college that is nothing but a useless piece of paper, that makes you lose years and enslave you in debt.
- rs999gti 4y ago> Was the government going around saying how much money you could earn from a humanities degree? Obama 2015: "the single most important way to get ahead is not just to get a high school education, you’ve got to get some higher education. That’s why all of you are here." "But you’re also here, now more than ever, because a college degree is the surest ticket to the middle class. It is the key to getting a good job that pays a good income -- and to provide you the security where even if you don't have the same job for 30 years, you're so adaptable and you have a skill set and the capacity to learn new skills, it ensures you're always employable." https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2015/01/09/remarks-president-americas-college-promise https://obamawhitehouse.archives.gov/the-press-office/2015/0...
- gruez 4y agoIsn't this mostly true? The net present value of a college degree is estimated to be around half a million dollars. He also stops short of saying that you get the aforementioned benefits with any degree.
- TigeriusKirk 4y ago> The net present value of a college degree is estimated to be around half a million dollars. Then why do people with college degrees need bailing out?
- woodruffw 4y agoBecause net and annual are different measurements. It's entirely possible to have an added net production of half a million dollars from a college degree and be swimming in immediately due debt from that degree.
- TigeriusKirk 4y agoThen restructure the debt. There's no need to provide further subsidies to citizens who are already half a million dollars ahead of other Americans.
- bloodyplonker22 4y agoThe deception is the government guaranteeing these loans and then the students defaulting on them, which results in the taxpayers paying. Furthermore, the colleges continuously raise prices because they know they will get the money, regardless, if the student defaults. This is why college is so expensive in America.
- gruez 4y ago>The deception is the government guaranteeing these loans and then the students defaulting on them, which results in the taxpayers paying Who got deceived here? If you were told that the government would be guaranteeing loans, then it follows that they're potentially on the hook if the loan goes bad. That's not something that's hidden, it's literally part of the definition of what guaranteeing loans mean. >Furthermore, the colleges continuously raise prices because they know they will get the money, regardless, if the student defaults. That sounds more like unintended consequences than deception.
- lb4r 4y agoI think it all depends on whether you expect the deception to involve some degree of malice. While there are certainly malicious individual actors and institutions that we can point to and blame, this is on a systematic level in which the system itself is the scam, and with little distinction between the deceivers and the deceived; perpetuated by belief, and strengthened by competition and demand. It favors only the very few who either lucked out, e.g. by choosing a profitable degree, or those who figured out how to game the system, the opportunists; neither of whom designed the scam nor run it. In fact, it was never designed to be a scam. It's simply an aged system that now must be run as one in order to stay relevant and survive. The deception is in the belief itself, and the government has a tremendous power to shatter it, yet they choose not to.
- i_am_toaster 4y agoI really like your wording and simplicity of response; I might abstract and repurpose it for my own use.
- lb4r 4y agoThank you! Do with it whatever you like. :)