2 ms·
The number one problem with this language is that everything is inlined because they don't have the concept of macros or variables. They have some variables but
by renewiltord 4y ago
The number one problem with this language is that everything is inlined because they don't have the concept of macros or variables. They have some variables but they are all ad-hoc designed into the language. For instance: ad-valorem means something but it's all from history. Adding a new term is a huge effort in this language.
Secondarily, they don't have a concept of macros except in a very ad-hoc sense. This means that they are afraid of macro use because they do not know the concepts of macro hygiene.
This is likely due to intentional creating a moat around the industry.
tl;dr Legalese is impenetrable because it uses the equivalent of Forth but POSIWID
- HPsquared 4y agoI don't know about that, for example contracts usually define their terms as they go along. "Hereinafter referred to as...". That's basically a #define macro.
- renewiltord 4y agoIsn't that more akin to a constant? Because #define macros are quite powerful, they can also express constants.
- ben_w 4y agoNot sure (not a lawyer), but at the very least the "Hereinafter referred to as…" statement can point to the entire agreement containing that statement: https://s3.studylib.net/store/data/008711807_1-e257ae31713cf1a2e666ecb9e67c0102.png https://s3.studylib.net/store/data/008711807_1-e257ae31713cf... The advantage of natural languages is self-referential infinite recursion is basically fine. The downside is, no compile-time checks for logical inconsistencies.
- renewiltord 4y agoRight, in theory, but in practice they don't really use that functionality, right? I think the reason they don't is that they have macro hygiene issues with the language because while natural language has supreme flexibility, it does not have easy to use scoping constructs and so things inside the macro will leak to outside the macro.