5 ms·
This is something I was blown away by too; for a 750 million dollar show, there sure are a lot of scenes where nothing happens. By far, my favorite example is
by smoldesu 4y ago
This is something I was blown away by too; for a 750 million dollar show, there sure are a lot of scenes where nothing happens.
By far, my favorite example is the scene where Elrond challenges a mountain dwarf to a rock-splitting competition. As viewers (even ones unfamiliar with LOTR), we know the outcome of this contest. The only thing they need to show us are these two characters after the competition, breaking down their relationships as begrudging friends. Instead, we spend more than a minute-and-a-half watching a rock splitting montage. Completely pointless from a storyboarding and writing perspective, especially considering that the outcome doesn't circumvent our expectations.
My second favorite example is even dumber; the third episode has another pointless 90-second scene of Galadriel riding a horse and smiling in slow-motion. I'm not joking, the entire scene looks like one of those HDR demo shots you'd see on a TV at Best Buy.
The show is genuinely difficult to watch, but don't take my word for it. Watch the first episode for yourself and take a shot every time you audibly sigh, you'll never want to watch an Amazon original again.
Edit: links to both scenes below
- Elrond & Durin: https://youtu.be/KT6ldSEVHCU https://youtu.be/KT6ldSEVHCU
- Galadriel Riding: https://youtu.be/4ZqMRAb3zKk https://youtu.be/4ZqMRAb3zKk
- zimpenfish 4y ago> there sure are a lot of scenes where nothing happens. "Look, we spent a lot of money on this filming and you will damn well sit through them!" (see also Thor: Love and Thunder for another thing that needed a stronger edit but presumably didn't for the same reason.)
- mcv 4y agoI actually liked Thor: Love and Thunder. It works for me because they're explicitly poking fun at themselves. It's not a serious movie, so it gets away with the stupid stuff because it's part of the joke. Rings of Power does not have that excuse.
- zimpenfish 4y agoYep, it's a good film[1] but it drags something terrible in places. Could have been done in 90 minutes without losing any of the important bits. [1] modulo the "blacker than a black hole" bits where it was impossible to see anything even on a UHD TV.
- iLoveOncall 4y agoIt's not a movie, it's a TV show that will have a run time of ~40 hours. The scenes where no story development happen also serve a purpose: allowing the viewer to not be drowned in over-information. The show is easy to follow because of that reason, even for someone who hasn't watched anything LOTR related before. All the comments about the development being too slow or some scenes being just for spectacle are nonsensical. The ones mentioning the budget as if it had been allocated to the first 4 episodes are even worse.
- smoldesu 4y ago> It's not a movie, it's a TV show that will have a run time of ~40 hours. Game of Thrones is 70+ hours start-to-finish, that wasn't an excuse to slow the pacing down or write impotent dialogue. It knows how to direct characters, and the showrunners understand that 60 seconds of horse riding doesn't make good television. Allegory is used sparingly, and the world is fleshed out through it's characters rather than CGI environments. It leads to a story that can be followed by bookworms and football dads alike. The Rings of Power doesn't build it's world in the same way. Instead we're whisked away to exotic locations that most viewers are unfamiliar with, and the following scenes do nothing to really characterize the world these characters inhabit. It's like the writing team and art directors never met to share notes. I'd argue that this lack of cohesion makes it decidedly harder to follow than other contemporary fantasy shows. > The ones mentioning the budget as if it had been allocated to the first 4 episodes are even worse. Okay, I'll be generous then. Why can't $125 million dollars buy better writers?
- nhinck2 4y ago> Why can't $125 million dollars buy better writers? I know this is really a rhetorical question but imagine just being able pay more for better writing. (The writing sucks because this is a commercial project first and foremost)
- klipt 4y ago> imagine just being able pay more for better writing. Is it that difficult? What if you ran a contest to write the best script, winner gets a million dollars and top billing in the credits? Seems there should be plenty of college students who can write better than e.g. last season of Game of Thrones.
- faangiq 4y agoAs viewers, we know the outcome of the entire story. Why bother making it at all? Unless …
- D-Coder 4y agoThe Titanic sinks???
- Smoosh 4y agoThe nerds get revenge?
- partomniscient 4y agoThe bad guy was the father?
- iancmceachern 4y agoThe storm was perfect?
- greenbit 4y agoThe Adventure was Excellent?
- vidarh 4y agoThis is one of very few series where I've watched each episode at least twice while waiting for the next. Yes, it's slow, but it's also stunning. I liked the scene with Galadriel riding. Until then she'd been shown as a hardened, argumentative and strident warrior except in the very start as a child. The scene shows a different side of her, which makes her happy; she's not entirely broken even after centuries searching for Sauron.
- _8j50 4y agoThanks for the alternate perspective. Haven't seen it yet but I always seem to contradict these bandwagon opinions on shows.
- p0nce 4y agosame here... I watch every episode thrice. It's _that_ good, to me, and way better than the films.
- keneda7 4y agoWhat do you like about the show more than the films so far?
- p0nce 4y agoThe films were really annoying to see end to end, the long version are unbearable. Music is better in RoP, every character and place has their theme, and they blend superbly like in Wagner or Monteverdi, unlike in the films. I also feel like dialogs are better in RoP, and the whole thing feels less "heavyweight" in everything... in a way, closer to the books. One thing distinctive in Tolkien universe is evil inside familiar things, and this is definately there in RoP, almost everywhere.
- magic_hamster 4y agoIf they skipped the rock splitting contest they would play exactly to your expectations. By showing the actual events you might believe Elrond has a plan or a way to win. I didn't know what would happen. And that made that scene better for me. The entire story of this show is well known in advance. If you know anything about LOTR you will know who Isildur is and what's going to happen. So should they just skip the entire show? It's the characters and their interactions, atop the beautiful visuals, that this show can establish itself with.
- giraffe_lady 4y ago> So should they just skip the entire show? This is a good question actually.
- mcv 4y agoYeah, I have no problem with the rock-splitting scene. For me it's the boat to Valinor. Just that one boat trip already has at least half a dozen things wrong with it. A few I could have ignored, but it just keeps getting worse and worse. There's still many great scenes too. I love Elrond's friendship with Durin, Durin & Disa's relationship, the Harfoots, the Orcs, how Numenor Looks, how everyone in Numenor looks, how their ships look. I even enjoy the spectacular action scenes with insane leaps by the elves. There's lots of good stuff in there, but it's all held together why really awkward plot twists that make no sense.
- m_mueller 4y agoTotally agreed. As a LotR fan who read all the other books as well, I have difficulty understanding what everyone’s problem is - either you know the story and enjoy the fantastic visuals of what you always had in your head or you don’t and you then you might also enjoy to learn some of the deep mythology behind LotR.
- johncoltrane 4y agoI have read all his books back to back several times since I was a teen, each reading contributing more details to my head cannon… where elves don't have pointy ears, dwarves are not humans afflicted with achondroplasia, Galadriel is not an impulsive warrior shorter than every human she meets, etc. Somehow, that cannon of mine has survived my RPG years AND decades of memes extracted from Peter Jackson's movies but woah… watching that show with my daughter is painful. She doesn't have the same kind of relationship I have with the original material, though, so she loves it so far.
- tarakat 4y agoI don't mind a slow pace. It's when the humans (unusually pale compared to the rest of the show's diversity) started complaining about elves taking their jobs that I checked out.
- lotsofspots 4y agoRight! When they unironically take the "Dey took 'er jerbs!!" line from South Park with zero awareness of how ridiculous it was in context. Why would the Men of Numenor be worried about elves stealing their jobs when no elf had set foot there for many, many years?
- spaced-out 4y agoAnother great example is the end of the third episode, start of the fourth. Arondir and the other elves make an escape attempt. They fail, Arondir is about to be killed, but for some reason he wasn't. They took him to their leader instead, who just lets him go with a "message". - Why did the orc leader wait until the escape attempt to send someone with a message to the humans? - Why would he believe an elf would relay his message, that humans could surrender and join him? Aren't the elves trying to prevent humans from being corrupted? - Why did he give him back his weapons? - Why are other orcs attacking him? Did Adar not even care if Arondir made back to the humans alive? It makes more sense if you consider that the plot was written that Arondir would get captured, meet the bad guy, save the kid, and go back to the woman he's in love with to face the bad guy with the humans. Once that was decided they just threw together some scenes to fill in the blanks. No consideration was given as to whether the characters decisions made sense in the moment, only that they move the plot to where it was supposed to go.
- smoldesu 4y agoThey killed too many people earlier in the episode, the ratings board wouldn't allow for that much dramatic tension at TV-14 :p
- mcv 4y agoExactly. Mind you, I like Arondir, I like his relation with Bronwyn, I love how they did the Orcs, and I can't help but enjoy those spectacular leaps the elves make. The individual parts are fine. It's just how they tie everything together, dragging characters by their hair to wherever the plot wants them to be, that makes the whole thing make no sense. And I don't see why any of this is necessary. Couldn't they have Arondir meet Adar before the escape attempt, make the escape attempt succeed, and when the Orcs pursue him, he manages to steal some weapons from the first Orcs he defeats with his bare hands. It wouldn't be the most inspired writing, but at least the decisions the characters make, would make more sense.
- hombre_fatal 4y ago
- addicted 4y agoI literally burst out laughing when the slow motion scene of the horse’s hooves came on TV.
- smoldesu 4y agoI don't want to sound hyperbolic, but I did too! It was the hardest I had laughed at something unintentionally bad in a while. It's particularly hard-hitting because it's preceded by some really pretty CGI vistas and camera sweeps in full-motion that almost bring you back to the immersion of the Peter Jackson movies. And then the steering wheel veers hard left, mixing in weird slow-mo shots that evokes images of stock footage and Getty Images watermarks.
- garren 4y agoI’ve never read The Silmarillion, and other than the hobbit cartoon back in the day, the LOTR movies are my only real connection with JRRT. I read the first book, but found it to be a forgettable slog largely due to a weird musical wizard that (thankfully) never showed up in the movies. Regarding the rock-splitting competition spoiler - I thought he was going to win. I’m only two eps in, but I’ve enjoyed the show so far. It’s much better than I expected, particularly given everything I’ve read about it being so poorly executed. I had much lower expectations. I’m not raving about it, but I’m not panning it either. I imagine that if you’re much closer to the source material, then there’s no way this show could have possibly met your expectations. On the other hand, if you want to catch a decent LOTR spin-off, and you’re neither a film student nor a die-hard JRRT fan, I’d say give it a shot.
- dean177 4y agoThe horse riding scene perfect. - There is no build up, nothing is at stake, they are just travelling to the setting for the next scene. - The gratuitous close ups of the horse. - Its one of the three ways people get places, why would the millennia old Galadriel be so ecstatic? There has been no hint that Galadriel is really into riding horses. - The music and slow motion are so comically over the top.