3 ms·
> This is in a sense totally factual, and I challenge the blowhards here to like, name one substantive harm someone has experienced from ad ID tracking on an iP
by tsimionescu 4y ago
> This is in a sense totally factual, and I challenge the blowhards here to like, name one substantive harm someone has experienced from ad ID tracking on an iPhone.
You then give a perfect example right in the next paragraph:
> so that Johnny Programmer, watching YouTube videos on a weekend, would see a demo of his devops tool because Johnny searched "how to connect git to kubernetes" or whatever in the previous 10 days.
So now Johnny Programmer's work life is hounding him on weekends. Even worse, he is being influenced to buy a paid product to do something that could probably be easily achieved with open source tools as well.
- aidos 4y agoTo be fair, you should use different profiles for your work and personal digital lives. And if someone is likely to use an open source solution, they’re also unlikely to be influenced to switch to a paid product based on an ad instead.
- senorrib 4y agoIf you make the example abstract you might understand what the problem is.
- tsimionescu 4y agoAdvertising is actively working against this - trying to find ways to correlate your activity across as many devices and accounts as possible. Especially now that work from home, BYOD and ZeroTrust (which reduces the need for corporate VPNs) are all blurring the lines and giving new opportunities for correlation. > And if someone is likely to use an open source solution, they’re also unlikely to be influenced to switch to a paid product based on an ad instead. This is assuming that the ad isn't promising something too good to be true, or using deceptive pricing to make it seem cheap enough to be better than the OSS, or using psychological tricks to try to override your rational choice (which may not work for this particular example, but may well work for many others).
- kixiQu 4y agoWhy should I have to use a different "profile"?
- noizejoy 4y ago> To be fair, you should use different profiles for your work and personal digital lives. Isn’t that victim blaming?
- aidos 4y agoI mean, I don’t like it either and I’d rather we didn’t have to take personal measures against this stuff. But I still use a password manager to protect myself online. I also use different profiles to split my work and home digital lives.