10 ms·
> Respect is a two way street. Teachers routinely blame the parents for any failures in the classroom. > safety absolutely. > adequate resources I never le
by WalterBright 4y ago
> Respect
is a two way street. Teachers routinely blame the parents for any failures in the classroom.
> safety
absolutely.
> adequate resources
I never learned more than at Caltech where the material was taught with blackboard and chalk, and the students used pen and paper.
- WalterBright 4y agoThe best and most fun lecture I ever gave was with whiteboard and dry erase pens. The scheduled speaker had not shown up, and the organizer asked if anyone could fill in. I volunteered, and had done no prep and had no slides. What also made it fun was the interaction with the audience and I'd just go where those interactions led. I don't do this normally, because everyone expects slides, and the conference organizer provides no mechanism for blackboards. Also, blackboards are problematic for a larger venue, they work best in a normal sized classroom.
- mlyle 4y agoI lecture a whole lot at the whiteboard. I use slides a lot, too. And demonstrations. Or I make students come up and demonstrate. It should be a little unpredictable what class will be like each day.
- WalterBright 4y agoThat all sounds excellent.
- mlyle 4y ago> > Respect > is a two way street. Teachers routinely blame the parents for any failures in the classroom. I teach in a great environment, but my public school peers are frequently berated by parents of students that complete no work. Even in my environment, I am pretty constantly "talked down to" by parents-- there's the implicit assumption they're better than me. I have enough confidence from past successes in industry and life to shrug it off, but I could easily see it becoming demotivating. Someone with my skills can easily find more lucrative and less challenging work. > > adequate resources > I never learned more than at Caltech where the material was taught with blackboard and chalk, and the students used pen and paper. I teach computer engineering with pen and paper. I mean things like "a living wage", "time to prepare for your classes and go to the bathroom", "not sticking 40 middle school students, including many with severe behavioral problems, in one room", and "not having to buy pencils and other necessities for your students with your own money". There's also a whole lot of nice-to-haves that make a difference. The $15 set of refillable whiteboard pens that have a very wide nib and make huge dark lines are very useful, but ain't no public school teacher going to get those over worn-out Expo markers. Candy bribes and stickers used judiciously as prizes to fuel classroom competition make a difference. Etc, etc, etc.
- staticassertion 4y agoOut of curiosity, what was the transition from field work to teaching like? I always hated school (the school bits, I liked the socializing) and thought I might like to be a teacher one day for that reason. I have no idea what transitioning would even look like though, it's entirely foreign to me.
- mlyle 4y agoIt was an accidental process. I was volunteering running after-school robotics teams and my role steadily increased over a number of years. If you want to do this at a public school, you're going to need to go get a specialized master's degree and teaching credential. Of course, there's some value in what's taught in these programs (pedagogy, classroom management, practical experience, etc). I've studied rather intensely on my own.
- WalterBright 4y agoInterestingly, none of the college professors I had had any education whatsoever in teaching. Neither did my dad, who was a professor for 20 years. They just knew the material. Feynman, perhaps the greatest physics teacher ever, had 0 teaching credentials. I attended one of his lectures long ago, a privilege I didn't realize until much later.
- mlyle 4y agoThis works pretty well in an environment of highly motivated university students. But there are reasons why we expect teachers to be educated on how to teach in general. I highly respect you, and we seem to talk here a lot. But you have this habit of holding up various edge cases that don't quite directly relate to what we're talking about as "gotchas". I have 0 teaching credentials, too, and think I'm pretty great. The current systems we have for younger students require teaching credentials, and there's some good reasons to require some education-in-education before letting someone teach kids.