8 ms·
>Asimov makes the case that rather than teaching old information, we should be forgetting more obsolete facts to make room for more modern and efficient materia
by dylan604 4y ago
>Asimov makes the case that rather than teaching old information, we should be forgetting more obsolete facts to make room for more modern and efficient material.
In high school (gawd, 30 years ago now), we had to memorize the opening of Canterbury Tales in Old English. I can still recite the first few lines. Why? What was the point of forcing students to do that? It's taking up precious space in the very limited memory banks. Instead, I can't remember if the arguments for the explode function has the string then the separator or the separator and then the string.
- johnchristopher 4y agoDevil's advocate: it's teaching you how to memorize something you don't want yet need to.
- dylan604 4y agoI don't want to need it ever
- BeFlatXIII 4y agoThe explode function is probably jumbled because the order is different in different languages you've encountered.
- dylan604 4y agoThanks for the gentle let off on the memory problem. Now, how to find similar explanations for all of the other things that can't be remembered ;)
- mlyle 4y ago> In high school (gawd, 30 years ago now), we had to memorize the opening of Canterbury Tales in Old English. I can still recite the first few lines. Why? What was the point of forcing students to do that? It's taking up precious space in the very limited memory banks. Some schooling focuses way too much on rote, memorization, etc. But........ IMO, we often get the main point of education wrong. It's not so much direct transfer of useful skills or a body of information-- though these are still important. Instead, I think the ability to be disciplined, systemic, and learning how to learn things and accept challenge should be the main goals. On a limited basis, practicing the skill of memorizing poetry and reciting it to a class can be a useful exercise. Now you know you can do that, how to do it, and about how long it's going to take. You were also forced to engage with that particular content in a deeper way than a casual, unmotivated reading by a high school student would have resulted in: the overall cadence and structure is cemented in your head as much as the very words. Education used to be very memorization and recitation heavy. Leaving a little bit in seems useful, even though it was the kind of thing I hated most as a kid.
- dylan604 4y agoI agree. I hated the podunk backwoods country town I grew up in, but after 30 years, I have to admit that my schooling was not so bad after all. Actually, it seems to be an outlier in how well it actually prepared me compared to other people's opinion of their schooling. The thing that I appreciate most about the teachers and the curriculums taught was that they taught me (I would say us refering to all students, but don't want to presume) was how to learn. I should say, the math/science classes did this. The history/literature classes were all rote memorization BS. I did not like those classes an did not do well in them. However, the other classes where I learned how to learn allowed me to become what has been labeled "a self-learner". I can read subject material a few times, experiment, and then "know" it well enough to function. Practice and continued use makes for much better retention than rote memorization. I used to ask teachers for anything that was still unclear, now it essentially is replaced with SO searches.
- WalterBright 4y agoI noticed an interesting effect in college that other graduates I talked with noticed, too. One learns how to learn. New material is learned faster and more accurately. One also learns what parts to focus on, and what parts can be dismissed, which helps learn more efficiently.
- mlyle 4y agoYes. Also, though, often you have a body of understanding that can be coerced to just handle the new task. Over in microeconomics... we draw budget curves, and all the operations on budget curves are a whole lot like operations on production possibility curves, so there's a lot of skill transfer. We spent 2 class periods on PPCs, and 10 minutes on budget curves. My students better understand how to learn economic concepts, and they have a closely related skill that they can adjust for the new task. Every lesson, we're accelerating.
- WalterBright 4y agoYes, the crossover effect is quite real. I remember my econ class, where the textbook spend a lot of time deriving derivative calculus. Except they never mentioned the words "derivative" or "calculus", because evidently that triggered math anxiety in econ students. So the book went around the horn doing it the hard way, using different terms like "marginal rate of return". Me, I had a good chuckle over that. I kept all my college textbooks except the econ one, which went in the trash.
- psychphysic 4y agoIt's not really the case that memorising those lines have taken up useful brain space. On the contrary from all we know it probably made you better at memorising. Similarly being able to write cursive gives you better fine motor control in your writing hand. I learnt cursive at school, as well as use of a slide rule and log tables. They were obsolete by many decades when I was learning to use them. But are my arithmetic skills worse than the average zoomer who has a smartphone practically cemented into their hand? No, I'm fact I'm probably more efficient at using the calculator app on their phone. In theory computer algebra systems have obsoleted junior maths courses let alone times tables (multiplication tables). But good luck using one if you didn't do the wax-on wax-off leg work of memorising seemingly useless data. In my current job I oversee trainees who have to sit 3 exams (at great cost totalling about 10k). The recommended reading for those those exams is about £25 question bank. Everyone who does it comes away feeling it was useless. The vast majority will pass and tell their more junior friends not to bother with it. And invariably the group that doesn't use it has more fails. There is bias here, those that are willing to work are more motivated and more likely to pass. But this always reminds me that 1) you don't even know what you're gaining when you do any kind of training 2) we rarely remember how we know something or why we came up with a particular idea. Usually the reason is some boring combination of seemingly unrelated grunt work.
- duifullg 4y agoYou can make the case than learning almost anything “useless” will help you with something else than everyone considers useful nowadays. Cursive helps with fine motor control. Chess helps you with memorization. Using an abacus might help with both. That’s not the point. The point is kids have a limited time. I don’t want my kids to learn cursive or the abacus because that will take time off from stuff that’s almost surely more relevant. Perhaps I’m wrong and learning with an abacus is the best use of their time. I hated cursive with a passion and some of my teachers forced me to use it at different points of my primary education. It was falling out of fashion then and only the hardcore old-timers thought it should be forced upon children. I wrote a perfectly legible print, but for them I just HAD to do it their way
- 4y ago
- ch4s3 4y agoI would argue that doing that kind of dive into foundational texts in the English literary cannon is more useful than you might expect. Things like the Canterbury Tales were often recited live by someone standing on a table, as you may remember from that lesson. The exercise of memorizing and orally reciting the couplets gives you a totally different intuitive understanding of the material. This also gives you a window through which you can better understand later works, like Shakespeare. Modern literature is also full of allusions and references to these foundational texts, so a passing familiarity gives you access to a deeper reading of newer works. Prior to Chaucer educated people in Europe considered English unsuitable for poetry. His work is part of the story of how English came to be an important global language. That's all to say that going deep on literary classics is valuable in a way that cursive is not.
- michaelgrafl 4y agoHuman memory doesn't work like that. Nothing gets pushed out when you learn something new. It probably works the other way around even. The more you know (and understand), the easier it gets to remember (and understand) new things.
- dylan604 4y ago>Human memory doesn't work like that. Probably right, but that's why we just need to be equiped with an M.2 port so we can upgrade our memory. Or maybe a bit of "better living through chemistry" will come up with a better swapping routine for memory
- bergenty 4y agoI used to be against memorization too but to be honest it’s immensely useful and an important skill that takes hard work to accomplish. There’s a special flow to speaking with someone that doesn’t need to stop to look things up on his phone multiple times in a complex conversation.
- ghaff 4y agoA nit: Canterbury Tales is Middle English and with the rhythm of the words and the many similarities to modern English, it's not that difficult and it's a good way to appreciate the language. I'd say the same thing about memorizing a Shakespearean soliloquy. Old English/Anglo-Saxon is the language of Beowulf and a modern English speaker would be effectively memorizing a northern European language like German. (It's pre-Norman invasion and therefore pre-Romance language influence.)
- dylan604 4y agoSee, other information that can't be recalled! Now that you said, I do kind maybe (memory is fuzzy) something about Middle English. It wasn't until being forced to read Canterbury Tales that I personally realized how Germanic English is. This is probably around the time I learned that Romantic languages had nothing to do with feelings and kisses.
- dsego 4y agoIn my secondary school we had teachers who dictated their lectures out of their notebooks and we had to write it all down & learn it line by line basically. And then during oral exam recite it back at them. I remember some kids would ask to go from the beginning when they lost track.
- SergeAx 4y agoOur memory banks are effectively infinite, we can remember a lot of details from very early parts of our lives, all by ourselves or with the help of hypnosis and other techniques. Oftentimes (much more often than we like to think) we do not remember the exact details (see research about witnesses). Lessons on memorization allows children to train their memory.
- hattmall 4y agoI feel the case could be made that knowing the explode syntax is obsolete because you should have code hints. That being said, in language the general theme follows English language sentence syntax with the verb abstracted to the function name. As in verb(subject, predicate, preposition) Think of it as a sentence, you would say "Separator exploded the string" The verb is exploded, so that's the function, Seperator would be first, then the string, and any modifiers which would be equivalent to prepositions, as in "Separator exploded the string at the first occurrence". Anyhow that's what used to be taught as best practice if you were developing a new language.
- coldtea 4y ago>Why? What was the point of forcing students to do that? Building a culture. Not all points are related to the raw utility of doing some task.
- ramblerman 4y ago> I can't remember if the arguments for the explode function has the string then the separator or the separator and then the string. On the flip side, having a conversation with someone who *only* memorized those kinds of things would be rather dull.
- reddiky 4y agoMe too! It's only been 14 years years for me but I can still make it through most of it, especially given a little help. It is one of the few things I can remember, even compared to poems I might want to memorize to make myself appear "cultured" I wonder why that is? Fear of failure produces a stronger memory response than simple desire?