9 ms·
Arm execs: We respect RISC-V but it's not a rival in the datacenter
- armclowns 4y ago
- panick21_ 4y agoFunny how a few years ago they were saying how it wasn't a rival in the embedded space and all this other FUD they published. Sure its not a rival in some aspects yet, but the trend-line is pretty clear. Unlike ARM RISC-V gets to standardize the Serve Platform based on much of the work done for ARM but in RISC-V case when people will start to seriously develop these things the standard will be there already. You already have RISC-V massively in the 'AI' market and some of these companies are targeting the data center, the famous example are Jim Kellers Tenstorrent and David Dizel Esperanto Technologies. In addition the the AI accelerators both these companies are also building high performance CPU. In addition you have a lot going on in China as well, with large Chinese companies building on RISC-V instead.
- kramerger 4y agoIs riscv really a rival in the embedded space?
- zik 4y agoWhen you have companies like Espressif who do huge volumes using RISC-V, yes. It's definitely a rival. https://www.espressif.com/en/products/socs/esp32-c3 https://www.espressif.com/en/products/socs/esp32-c3
- kramerger 4y agoHow exactly do you define rival? There are tens maybe hundreds of embedded cpus for every human. While riscv products exist, they are still mostly a novelty. I dont think riscv has even 0.1% of the embedded market yet.
- brucehoult 4y agoThere was a lot of publicity in October 2021 that ARM had just passed 200 billion cumulative chips with their cores -- over 30 or 35 years. RISC-V International announced passing 10 billion cores back in July. Discounting the distinction between cores and chips, that's RISC-V at around 5% installed base already. That's a lot more than 0.1%. The current run rate will be closer than that. ARM is currently doing about 7 billion chips a quarter. RISC-V is probably around 1 billion -- let's say 15% market share.
- lttlrck 4y agoThe whole market isn't ARM + RISC-V is it?
- magicalhippo 4y agoTo be fair, Espressif didn't use ARM on their previous ESP designs, but Xtensa[1]. Looking at which chips currenly use ARM vs RISC-V isn't interesting, it's more interesting to look at which new designs are done using ARM vs RISC-V. I assume large players like ST, Microchip and Infineon (Cypress) have bought the ARM licenses and have the infrastructure that allow them to churn out more STM32[2], SAMD[3] and PSoC[4] variations (respectively) for a good while, for example, so there is a fair bit of inertia in this space. That said, browsing that RISC-V member list[5], we do find those same three players as strategic members, so they clearly haven't closed the door on RISC-V... [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensilica#Adoption https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tensilica#Adoption [2]: https://www.st.com/en/microcontrollers-microprocessors/stm32-32-bit-arm-cortex-mcus.html https://www.st.com/en/microcontrollers-microprocessors/stm32... [3]: https://www.microchip.com/en-us/products/microcontrollers-and-microprocessors/32-bit-mcus/sam-32-bit-mcus/sam-d https://www.microchip.com/en-us/products/microcontrollers-an... [4]: https://www.infineon.com/cms/en/product/microcontroller/32-bit-psoc-arm-cortex-microcontroller/ https://www.infineon.com/cms/en/product/microcontroller/32-b... [5]: https://riscv.org/members/ https://riscv.org/members/
- panick21_ 4y agoYeah, look at Andes Technology for example. They are very big IP company and are doing lots of RISC-V stuff. Of course ARM is still dominate but RISC-V is defiantly an option in that space that is growing.
- TD-Linux 4y agoOver the last couple of years, yes. The GD32 and CH32V are increasingly popular. This is not so much ARM's fault directly though, as it is the complete unavailablility of STM32s forcing many companies to look for a quick replacement.
- tyingq 4y agoIn some spaces it seems like it's gaining ground pretty fast. Western Digital, for example, seems pretty committed to replacing the ARM processors in their flash and SSD controllers with RiscV.
- gjvc 4y agoWhat else would one expect them to say? "History has shown that open source wins, and we've had a good run and it would come as no surprise were a new low-power architecture end up eating our lunch." ?
- willnonya 4y agoWhat history would that be?
- chmod775 4y agoLots of examples of open source replacing closed-source in recent history, hardly any for the other way around. Plenty of examples of proprietary becoming open-source as well. The only trend that runs counter to this is the emergence of SaaS, most of which rely heavily on open source themselves. It's hard to compete with established FOSS, which is why companies tend to embrace and build upon it, strengthening its position even further. The web stack is full of examples: Web servers*, OBS killing everything else, ActiveX, Flash, Mosaic, and also lots of smaller examples related to how we interact with various file formats/codecs. If you wanted to start developing a new closed-source web server, streaming software, alternative to ffmpeg, programming language, compiler, browser engine, or even mobile operating system, people would probably call you insane. Trying to beat the open-source incumbents with something closed-source and possibly paid looks impossible. * I am amazed Microsoft IIS is still barely hanging on.
- ma2rten 4y agoA lot of this is because large companies which make proprietary software, such as Google, invested in the software you listed. I am not sure if the same would happen in the case of hardware. There is more upfront investment. The culture is different, more secretive.
- GoblinSlayer 4y agoI guess, IIS integrates with greater ecosystem, while FOSS tends to be all standalone programs.
- mekster 4y agoThing isn't a rival until it isn't. It's like Intel's attitude.
- UltraViolence 4y agoNot yet at least anyway. RISC-V is eating their lunch. There will be a myriad of Chinese design houses and fabless manufacturers churning out cheap cores for use in almost everything. When you're making a CPU core for a microwave or cheap trinket even a few pennies saved by not having to pay for an ARM license matters. And the freedom to alter the design as you see fit is worth its weight in gold in a hyper-competitive market
- _hypx 4y agoRISC-V is to ARM as ARM is to x86.
- PebblesHD 4y agoA few years ago I would have agreed with this hierarchy but having recently replaced my relatively powerful i7 laptop with an ARM based one and experienced a significant improvement in my use cases, I’d say ARM most definitely poses a threat to x86 for the majority of consumer use cases.
- philosopher1234 4y agoI think that was actually their point. There will be a RISCV rampage
- fwsgonzo 4y agoThe vector extension in RISC-V is extremely powerful, and I think it will be very interesting to see what can be done with it in a desktop or server CPU down the road.
- brucehoult 4y agoIt is. SVE is very similar too. It's going to be interesting between then, because they are both coming out of the blocks at about the same time. The only consumers who have SVE now are owners of this year's phones with the Snapdragon 8 Gen 1 (Galaxy S22, Xiaomi 12, ...), where it is buried so deep few will be aware of or playing with it. No one at all has mass-production RISC-V vector extension 1.0 just yet. Two popular Chinese SBC makers have said in chat rooms that boards they will announce (maybe even ship) in December do (and with quad 2.5 GHz OoO cores!) I'm slightly dubious but we will see. In any case, some will be coming in 2023 -- and in laptops, not only SBCs. Quite a lot of people have bought cheap RISC-V SBCs using the Allwinner D1 SoC, which implements draft version 0.7.1 of the RISC-V vector extension. Most instructions are unchanged (in both mnemonics and binary encoding) between 0.7.1 and 1.0 but enough very important instructions have changed -- vsetvli and loads and stores, for example -- that code needs to be tweaked to move between them. But 0.7.1 is good practice, and boards start from $17 (1 GHz single core with 512 MB RAM, very similar to a Raspberry Pi Zero) which is a lot cheaper than a sacrificial Galaxy S22.
- lvass 4y agoI had no idea RISC-V was such a threat to them. Downplaying is done by those who fear, otherwise they'd just ignore.
- faisal_ksa 4y agoOkay, not yet. I don't think RISC-V rivals you in any market except micro-controllers. However, it's a matter of time before RISC-V dominates every market. Due to its openness and lack of fees.
- snvzz 4y ago>I don't think RISC-V rivals you in any market except micro-controllers. I used to think like this. Then I saw the sad state of mobile SoCs[0], and learned that Cortex-A55 is pretty much still the peak, with full awareness of U74[1] and U74-MC[2], which is considerably better (less area, faster, and more efficient to boot). Considering that P650[3] has existed for a while competing with ARM's performance-focused cores, and X280[4], basically an U74 with Vector, also exists today, I simply do not see a 2023 without a pack of new SoC based on these cores (particularly, I expect to see X280 pop up everywhere), and phones based on these SoCs. Android was already demonstrated on RISC-V years ago, and a lot of effort is being put in polishing and upstreaming this work. That's how immediate we're talking about. As for the ARM story we're discussing, it's clear to me: Softbank wants to sell ARM ASAP, and that's about the only thing they care about. They thought that doing this statement is helping them, but I am not sure it is. 0. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0ukXDnWlTY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=s0ukXDnWlTY 1. https://www.sifive.com/cores/u74 https://www.sifive.com/cores/u74 2. https://www.sifive.com/cores/u74-mc https://www.sifive.com/cores/u74-mc 3. https://www.sifive.com/cores/performance-p650 https://www.sifive.com/cores/performance-p650 4. https://www.sifive.com/cores/intelligence-x280 https://www.sifive.com/cores/intelligence-x280
- jlawer 4y agoHigh performance datacenter cores will likely remain a niche for the best chip design companies. Architecture mostly matters in that your workload / ecosystem is supported. I can't see this being a place where an open source RISC-V core wins. Even if you had the complete plans to a top of the range EPYC processor, you would struggle to Fab it, and by the time you were able to do so, it would likely not be valuable. The problem is DC CPUs are driven by power efficiency. Building the most efficient processors requires the latest manufacturing nodes and incredible optimisation. Generally your chips must be within the last 1-3 generations, the inefficiencies are very noticeable. Power efficiency impacts cooling and density, additionally driving the economics of DCs. The existing manufacturers have the teams to churn these out, for someone else to join the club it would be a massive investment (just look at home many failed Server Arm companies there have been). You can also see that even companies that have ARM server chips are mostly just tweaking cores provided from ARM, not developing their own from scratch. Given this I think your unlikely to see this unless the economics change. If one of the cloud giants decided that they aren't getting value with ARM, they might end up developing their own, potentially even using RISC-V as the architecture, but I can't imagine them wanting to share it. Unless you end up with a multi-cloud consortium deciding that its in all their interests to build a common processor in order to turn it into a commodity. In that case you might get an open source core out of it, but the fab problems still remain.
- friendzis 4y agoCompute power per square meter and per watt are only one half of the DC efficiency story. The product is still software. If you double the flops, but software is only half efficient in the end you move nowhere. You need performant compilers to go along chip/architecture. You also need user software. A "performant" CPU that does not run upstream versions of postgres/python/java/nginx/whatever is mostly useless for a DC. A chip design/architecture being a commodity is a good way to have user software and compiler tuning going.
- jjtheblunt 4y agoWhat does RISC-V do computationally better than the current ARM variants?
- sanxiyn 4y agoNone yet. There is RISC-V vector extension, which is certainly different, but whether it is better is unclear for now.
- legulere 4y agoArm has something a bit similar with scalable vector extension (SVE)
- zik 4y agoIt's an open architecture designed for extensibility. So if you're wanting to make an AI processor for instance it's much easier to add an AI extension to RISC-V than it is to ARM. And you don't have to pay ARM license fees either.
- legulere 4y agoRISC-V has better code density with its compressed instructions.
- farseer 4y agoYes but ARM processors are more powerful for now. They are also better designed compared to the RISC-V models currently available in the market. RISC-V can't yet take on ARM v8 or v9.
- brucehoult 4y agoARMv7 (32 bit) has slightly better code density than RISC-V 32 bit, although that will change with the next crop of RISC-V extensions (and already did to a certain extent with the B extension). ARMv8/v9 (by which I'm sure you mean A64 / Aarch64) is where RISC-V has the big code density advantage. And RISC-V right now has proven cores in mass-production up to the A55 level, with A72 level (e.g. Pi 4) having been around on developer boards for a year and hitting mass-production at around the end of this year. A76-level RISC-V will be demonstrated on a developer board within the next six weeks or so, and available to developers first half of next year. That's Intel "Horse Creek"(using SiFive P550 cores), and also there is something called "Dubhe" coming out of China which I think is related but they don't like to say so. M1-level RISC-V is on the drawing boards, probably out in 2025. RISC-V is behind, but can already take on a significant part of the ARMv8/v9 market.
- GoOnThenDoTell 4y agoARM not worried about RISCV in a market that ARM only just joined
- unethical_ban 4y agoIs there a two technical article on the differences between a riscv and arm core are? And why the former is less powerful currently?
- brucehoult 4y agoIt's purely about the money invested in each so far, and the fact that chips take at least three to four years from getting the funding until having something in mass production for sale to the general public. The really serious money started to move into RISC-V core design during 2021. Things available for purchase now were started back in 2018 or so, with much less money. The "frozen" RISC-V base spec was only published to the world from Berkeley University in 2015 (and ratified in 2019) and the first chip you could buy (F310 chip on the HiFive1 board) was in December 2016. That's barely two chip design cycles ago. The company that did it (SiFive) produced their first two chip and boards (one a Linux-capable 1.5 GHz 64 bit quad core) on their first $8m of funding. Now they have several hundred million of funding, but that's recent.
- kinafab 4y agoNot yet. Give Chinese devs 5 years and it will be. This is giving me IBM or Nokia vibes.
- gumby 4y agoApple started using ARM parts back with the Newton, but in the modern era have had ARM in ipod, time machine, and of course iPhone/iPod. Apple had Intel parts in various non-core devices long before Intel made it into macs. Apple now has RISC-V cores as bookkeeping devices in the M1 & M2. ARM can see the writing on the wall.
- dis-sys 4y ago> Apple now has RISC-V cores as bookkeeping devices in the M1 & M2. source please.
- dry_soup 4y agoI found this [1]. Looks like it's a rumor at this point. [1] https://www.techpowerup.com/298936/report-apple-to-move-a-part-of-its-embedded-cores-to-risc-v-stepping-away-from-arm-isa https://www.techpowerup.com/298936/report-apple-to-move-a-pa...
- dis-sys 4y agoThanks, very interesting. this is definitely the type of rumor that I'd like to follow.
- kergonath 4y agoI am not sure this has been proven (at least within the M1 or M2, I seem to remember RISC-V cores in other places but cannot find a reference right now, so I might be misremembering). I think the parent is overly enthusiastic. What we know is that Apple is hiring people with RISC-V experience. And it would be very off-character if they did not have at least a team somewhere working on it. You can bet that they would jump on it the moment it makes sense for them.
- antman 4y agoRelevant: Why Nokia is not afraid of the iPhone (2007) https://www.mobilementalism.com/2007/01/11/why-nokias-not-afraid-of-the-iphone/ https://www.mobilementalism.com/2007/01/11/why-nokias-not-af...
- pjmlp 4y agoTaking out the aspect of Symbian C++ tooling, Symbian was great as OS. Nokia's problem number 1 was the political internal wars between Symbian and Linux divisions that distracted management from what should be the main focus, and then Elop brought Windows into an ecosystem that was pretty much anti-MS to start with. It remains to be seen if ARM management is going to have this sort of decisions.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoI had a Sony P800 and it was a horrible phone. Adding apps was a pain, there were only very few good apps, the pen was a pain, UI was a pain (b/c desktop design moved to a mobile device). I bought the first iPhone, no comparison (same app problem but the ones supplied were excellent).
- pjmlp 4y agoThat is like complaing about Android from Oppo as experience from what targeting proper Android means.
- KingOfCoders 4y agoThe P800 was not a proper Symbian phone? I thought it was one of the flagship Symbian phones back then.
- pjmlp 4y agoIt was Sony-Ericson fork from Symbian. Latest Nokia versions were quite nice, https://www.phonemore.com/systems/symbian/3-nokia-belle/ https://www.phonemore.com/systems/symbian/3-nokia-belle/
- travisgriggs 4y ago> The architecture has proven good enough for NASA… The same NASA that has spent years circling the proverbial pork barrel strapping old school reusable shuttle boosters to a rocket as non-reusable kick boosters and struggling to fill said “old tech” without mishap (lessons already learned and documented again and again)? That NASA?? Frankly, invoking NASAs “buy in” as about like claiming that a revived BeOS has chosen it. Or that RIM plans to come out of receivership for their next gen “Blackberry V”. Or that Chrysler’s rerunning a limited re-edition of the PT Cruiser featuring RISC-V. Other than that, I like RISC-V. I’m excited to see it grow.
- jabl 4y agoWell, there's the NASA doing manned launches (or nowadays, working towards eventually being able to, to put it charitably) which, as you say, sadly seems co-opted by pork-barrel interests. But there's also the science side of NASA that does stuff like space probes, the Hubble and James Webb telescopes, and so on. And this side seems to have a better track record (well, post-Apollo at least) of actually delivering something valuable. And, AFAIU it's this side that has chosen the RISC-V based platform for their future work.
- beebeepka 4y agoFirst they ignore you, then they laugh at you, then they fight you, then you win. Something tells me things are going to look very different in a decade. Of course, if I know this, the ARM execs also know this but have to keep saying whatever is expected of them
- julienfr112 4y agoIntel exec: we respect Arm, but it's not a rival in the datacenter
- fancyfredbot 4y agoI'd argue that RISC-V is only really competing with ARM when it's possible to license a complete, competitive RISC-V core implementation and integrate it into a product. At the low end, I expect (and already see) that people can give away open source IP. But not sure this model works as well at the high end where things get a lot more difficult? While it's easy to imagine people creating high performance RISC-V cores, I think they would have to either sell processors or license the IP. That would be competition with ARM, and would be a good thing, but I don't think it is clear/obvious that using the RISC-V ISA would give any company doing that much of an advantage over ARM?
- Sirened 4y agoThis is something I'm excitedly watching as well. It's one thing to put out a free rv32i microcontroller and quite another to put out not just one but a regular stream of cores that keep raising the performance bar. The classic CPU industry is still squeezing out 10%+ performance gains per generation every year or two. Unless these large organizations start collaborating to make these chips faster (...doubtful unfortunately), I suspect they'll fall behind and stay behind.
- dkjaudyeqooe 4y agoAn obvious advantage is if you want to change the design of your cores you don't have to ask permission amd no-one can stop you. See ARM vs Qualcomm.
- Brian_K_White 4y agoIt's a forgone conclusion. Once the ratcheting process starts, it doesn't matter how far behind the open source option is behind the proprietary one, and doesn't matter how slowly it advances, it wins. By ratcheting process I mean how something open can never go backwards to un-existing. Once something exists at all, it's there for that maybe one other person maybe 5 years later to build on by adding maybe one weekends work, eventually it gets to a usable state for at least some applications, even if they are only small ones. The slick feature rich proprietary current industry standard can sneer at that every day for decades, and then it is surpassed.
- qwytw 4y agoEither you have an extremely broad interpretation of what open source is or you simply ignore all the cases where this didn’t happen or indeed the opposite occurred. Also I'm not quite sure how much of an advantage being open source is for RISC-V. Unless we’re taking about low cost chips with extremely narrow margins the licensing fee a manufacturer needs to pay ARM is insignificant. Even the price for an ARM architectural license is pocket change compared to the cost it would take to design a competitive core if you’re aiming for data-centers. A company like ARM (i.e. willing to license their designs and architecture to anyone for a small fee, it's basically behaving like a non-profit compared to many other tech companies) seems like the best case scenario for the industry. With RISC-V why would a company which designed a high-end CPU core license it to anyone instead of trying to maximize their profit/competitive advantage? With Arm at least there something to fallback to accessible for everyone.
- brucehoult 4y agoWhat is the price of an ARM architectural license? I don't think any of us know. What does it let you do? Not what Qualcomm thought it did, apparently. No exchanging notes with other holders of an ARM architectural license. Wow. Everyone is strictly on their own -- use ARM's cores, or use their own completely internal design, and nothing else. Assuming ARM wins in court, of course, which is not necessarily going to happen.
- 4y ago
- snvzz 4y agoJim Keller's team has a working 8-decode 10-issue RISC-V cpu in the labs. Another popular 8-decode is the M1. ARM is probably aware there'll be competitive server chips based on RISC-V as soon as next year. This is just damage control, they just want the company sold by now.
- brucehoult 4y agoI'm not sure it makes sense to describe (or implement) a RISC-V instruction decoder as "4-wide" or "8-wide". It makes more sense to talk about how many bytes of code are decoded per clock cycle. If it's 16 bytes (like current x86) then you get between 4 and 8 instructions depending on the percentage of "C" extension code. If it's 32 bytes (like M1) then you get between 8 and 16 instructions, with a typical average of 11 point something. Or, depending on decoder design, you might always get 16 instructions, but some of them are NOPs. That can be easier to deal with as later stages will be doing things such as turning MOV (and other things) into NOP and dropping all the NOPs (and also NOPs used for branch target alignment) before they reach the back end. It's a little harder to decode dual-length RISC-V code than fixed length Aarch64 code, but I've described designs here and Reddit (and elsewhere) that show at 16 or 32 byte wide decode it's not enough harder to matter. Going much wider on decode usually isn't useful because you start to very often get a taken branch somewhere in that much code.
- dark-star 4y agohey, not even ARM is a real rival in the datacenter (...yet)
- sylware 4y agoRISC-V won't be a rival until there are performant implementations in the different load profiles: - the soc for usb keyboard and mouse. - performant energy wise mobile soc. - desktop cpu. - server cpu. And for RISC-V, don't need C, you can go straight to assembly because its not locked by very few vendors and has no toxic IP tied to it (like mpeg and hdmi). who said risc-v assembly python implementation?
- oneplane 4y agoDidn't Intel say this about ARM a while back?
- littlestymaar 4y agoI don't think if they said it, but circa 2010 they definitely could have said that, and they would have been right for many years actually, until they weren't. The same thing could definitely happen to ARM.
- snvzz 4y agoMinus the many years. There's a difference. ARM isn't entrenched in the server rooms. With RISC-V's momentum, it is now likely it will never be.
- dcpit 4y agoyet.
- kyaghmour 4y agoThere is nothing precluding ARM from providing a RISC-V fetch and decode unit as an option with their IP. Like having a POSIX compatibility layer or Linux subsystem in Windows. There is a lot AXI-based IP blocks out there, even in the RISC-V ecosystem. Having a RISC-V from ARM would make the switch more or less painless and the ability to benefit from known-to-be-good IP. I'd conjecture that there are likely already toy projects at ARM to do just that, if nothing else as POCs by individual engineers eager to show colleagues how easily this could be done. Now, whether strategically ARM would do this is another question. I suspect they'd hold off as long as it was realistically possible. But the deal is that an ISA is only one part of a huge stack of IP. And in that arena, ARM has a huge lead, especially considering that the granularity of the increment in terms of potential open source contributions is gated by huge costs that individuals can rarely take on on their own and lots of often arcane domain-specific knowledge.
- klelatti 4y agoGenuine question. Why would Arm do this? Armv8 is a modern ISA built built based on decades of experience with huge software support. Adding a comparable but different ISA alongside it makes no sense. More likely is that they could loosen up some of the IP restrictions around the Arm ISA. Allowing extensions, maybe making simpler cores available for free.
- taylodl 4y agoRather than worrying about RISC-V vs. ARM let's focus on the big picture: Intel is no longer a relevant talking point in this discussion. That's a tectonic shift from how this industry has been operating for the past 40 years.
- snvzz 4y agoDo you mean x86 rather than Intel? Which is mostly AMD today, datacenter-wise. Intel doesn't have competitive products, only an inertia they have been losing at a worrying pace. Intel has shown an interest in RISC-V, and will likely be pivoting to that. They're well aware x86 is unsustainable, requiring several times the effort (=investment) to simply remain competitive with the RISC competitors.