22 ms·
The format claims to be "royalty-free" but standard itself is not free.
by userbinator 4y ago
The format claims to be "royalty-free" but standard itself is not free.
- blurred 4y agoAlso it seems it has unresolved patent issue: https://www.theregister.com/2022/02/17/microsoft_ans_patent/ https://www.theregister.com/2022/02/17/microsoft_ans_patent/
- defrost 4y agoShades of LizardTech v. ERM I hope not. That was a US filed in 1999, decided 2005 patent case over mid 90s use of discrete wavelet transforms in image storage, and the progressive loading of very large images rather than the prior full scanline by scanline loading of the dialup era ... [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LizardTech,_Inc._v._Earth_Resource_Mapping,_Inc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/LizardTech,_Inc._v._Earth_Reso.... Court cases over patents on mathematical techiques and their implemantations really pisses me off .. being called as an expert witness even more so - it's more excruciating than teaching first year engineering students linear algebra . . . (I'll let myself out).
- dataflow 4y agoCould someone ELI5 the following? 1. Weren't "ideas" not supposed to be patentable, but only actual implementations? Given that, how can an algorithm be patented? 2. Wasn't prior art supposed to invalidate a patent? If the algorithm was already used in JPEG-XL, then clearly Microsoft isn't the first to discover it, and hence should not be able to patent it, right? Or if the algorithm in JPEG-XL is considered different, then there's no infringement by definition, right? So what's the issue?
- blurred 4y agoOne is theory, second is practice. Here is some discussion about this patent: https://encode.su/threads/3863-RANS-Microsoft-wins-data-encoding-patent https://encode.su/threads/3863-RANS-Microsoft-wins-data-enco...
- Nokinside 4y ago1. In patent law an idea is a creation that has been imagined but not yet prototyped, produced, or manufactured and they can be patented. Products with usefulness are patentable. Including algorithms used in software, and process (act or method of doing something) 2. In the US prior 2013 that was often the case. In 2013 US switched from first-to-invent to first-to-file system to be more compatible with the rest of the world.
- derf_ 4y agoThat is a common misunderstanding of first-to-file. Under first-to-file, prior art is absolutely still a defense, and much easier to prove than under first-to-invent. If you publicly disclose something before someone who invented, but did not disclose, the same thing, your publication counts as prior art. It is much easier (read: cheaper) to demonstrate that "X document was published on Y website on Z date" than it is to start doing discovery to compare private lab notebooks or whatever to decide who really invented the thing first. First-to-file is mostly about simplifying the complicated litigation edge cases where two people claim to have invented, but not disclosed, the same thing during the (US-specific) one-year grace period they have to file a patent on it. Prior art may still not invalidate the patent, though. Usually the patent holder will argue that their patent differs from the prior art in some respect (you can often find these arguments in the patent's file wrapper at http://patentcenter.uspto.gov/ http://patentcenter.uspto.gov/). But that narrows the scope of the patent, and being your own prior art is a pretty good defense against infringement.
- ClumsyPilot 4y agoThis is a huge powergrab by our industry - it is the only industry in the world that gets both patent and copyright protection. Think about it, you can patent a car engine, but you cannot get copyright on it. You get copyright on a book, but you can't patent a book. Also that's mostly US. By contrast, in Europe, software is generally not patentable.
- jononor 4y agoThe schematics, engineering drawings, 3d models, CAD files, process documentation etc for making a car engine (or anything else) are all copyright protected. So how exactly is software special?
- ClumsyPilot 4y agothat's very different - does not stop me copying a car engine and selling my knockoff. I can buy a car engine, modify it and sell my modification. Supplimentary documentation, and schematics are a separate matter - but engine itself is not protected. Software itself is protected, you can do nothing..
- lifthrasiir 4y agoWhile the software patent is a spicy issue, Jon Sneyers once noted that Microsoft may be in a deep trouble if they actually exercise that patent because of both Google's and Cloudinary's defensive patents [1]. [1] https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1526598054685642753 https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1526598054685642753
- lifthrasiir 4y agoEditors wanted to make the standard freely available (one of them even wrote an open letter [1]) but for now it is paywalled. I personally worked with a recent community draft which was circulated in the JPEG XL discord. [1] https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1420765059739914243 https://twitter.com/jonsneyers/status/1420765059739914243
- iforgotpassword 4y ago"JPEG XL discord" - man I feel like I'm really getting old and falling out of the loop. Discord to me is that young people/gamers walled garden platform, for voice chat and sharing meme gifs.
- lifthrasiir 4y agoNowadays Discord is used for all sort of things. If you don't want to join the Discord server, you may reach editors and they are probably willing to hand out the most recent draft.
- jeroenhd 4y agoDiscord has replaced many forums, sadly. They're even rolling out a special forum feature right now that (obviously) can't be indexed by Google. Public post-based discussion is moving to quick chats in private servers. It started out with Slack spaces but has moved to Discord because of Slack's inferior UX/UI/business model. This makes taking part in a community a lot easier as you can actually talk to the people working on the stuff you're excited about, like you could with good ol' IRC except you don't need to log in at the exact right time to send them a message. Some open source projects opt to use Matrix rather than Discord or Slack, which is an open standard but the problems still remain. Especially, finding a solution to an obscure error message can be a real challenge if you don't want to join some random chat room full of existing conversations to ask the question yourself, even if ten or twenty people before you already did the same. I much prefer the forums for this type of stuff but most of the world seems to disagree.
- chungy 4y ago