4 ms·
You can't hope to understand first year physics without calculus. To be a reasonable civil engineer, don't you need to understand structural engineering, inclu
by hedora 4y ago
You can't hope to understand first year physics without calculus. To be a reasonable civil engineer, don't you need to understand structural engineering, including dynamics, which requires differential equations?
On the other hand, what do I know? The civil engineering plans for our place had glaring errors that the construction workers caught after doing half the earthmoving.
Even after it was fixed, the results lasted less than one rainstorm. When we went back and checked the contracts we signed, they made it clear they assume zero liability for incompetence. Hiring a lawyer is more expensive than renting an excavator, and fixing it ourselves.
Anyway, I'm not impressed with the corner of that field I interacted with, and would prefer they tighten the educational standards.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- __s 4y agoThe same argument could be made that what you interacted with was someone designing because their head is lost in the abstract porcelain tower of calculus proofs instead of the practical properties of the materials they were dealing with
- aperson_hello 4y agoThere's a big difference between applied calculus and theoretical calculus. Colleges teach theoretical and then wonder why students struggle to apply it.
- Schroedingersat 4y ago> You can't hope to understand first year physics without calculus. To be a reasonable civil engineer, don't you need to understand structural engineering, including dynamics, which requires differential equations? Yes, but memorizing a bag of tricks for hand solving integrals and ODEs that you will never see in symbolic form without more than a passing exposure to the underlying concepts doesn't help anyone understand anything. Learning mathematical thinking and getting into the groove of that style of problem solving is equally as important (although much less concrete in its applicability for an engineer). But conflating rote memorization of the 'trick' to integrate cos(x)sin(x) with either helps nobody. A first year physics course is a better venue for teaching actual understanding of what derivative means than a purely symbolic presentation of the chain and product rules followed by presentation of a 'quotient rule' as a separate thing to memorize rather than a trivial combination of the other two. As is implementing some simulations of simple dynamical systems. As is intro to epidemiology or ecology. As is playing cookie clicker. Get students to visualise things, and actually experience them rather than memorize symbols. Then formalize themand introduce the language so they can express what they've learnt
- mensetmanusman 4y agoThe connection between calculus and the quality of subcontractor work is dubious.