2 ms·
> Plus, don't underestimate the impact of forcing people to acknowledge that there is exactly one right answer and that it can be proven. There's plenty of cla
by zozbot234 4y ago
> Plus, don't underestimate the impact of forcing people to acknowledge that there is exactly one right answer and that it can be proven.
There's plenty of classes in a civil engineering degree to instill that particular lesson. Why does it have to be calculus? It's just legacy - it used to be that limits and integrals could only be computed by hand, so any aspiring engineer would have to practice that skill a lot. Now computers can do the tricky algebra on their own (and I'm not even mentioning numerical approaches, which are more broadly useful but can be very tricky in their own way), yet the calculus courses have barely changed.
- roenxi 4y ago> Why does it have to be calculus? It doesn't, but it has to be something. So the proposal isn't 'get rid of calculus' as much as 'replace it with X which will be better at achieving the outcomes we think are important'. Like the original article did with statistics, which is a decent proposal. That being said if my civil engineer hadn't ever studied calculus I, personally, would prefer to find a different civil engineer. It makes sense to give the will-it-stay-up? job to someone unusually well educated and if they haven't studied those sort of mathematical basics it is pretty suspicious.
- zozbot234 4y agoThe mathematical foundations of "will it stay up" questions are a lot more challenging than what you'll find in any calculus course. I'm all for teaching less calculus, and more theory of structural engineering. (Setting statistics aside, which does require calculus but not of the pointless-algebra-tricks kind.)
- aoki 4y ago> statistics aside, which does require calculus but not of the pointless-algebra-tricks kind https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_integral https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Gaussian_integral