4 ms·
It took me a loooong time to intuitively understand how a ship can sail upwind. The diagrams and explanations made no sense to me. I finally figured it out, th
by WalterBright 4y ago
It took me a loooong time to intuitively understand how a ship can sail upwind. The diagrams and explanations made no sense to me.
I finally figured it out, though. Take a drafting triangle, which has 30-60-90 degree angles. Place the 30-90 side against a wall or something rigid. Take a block (wind) and press on the 30-60 side. The triangle will squeeze "upwind" in the direction perpendicular to the 30-90 side (in addition to a larger movement sideways towards the 60-90 side).
The keel of the boat plays the role of the 30-90 side against the wall, the sail the 30-60 side.
- bicx 4y agoI got into sailing for a bit (poor man’s sailing in a 16’ sailing kayak), and it took a lot of mental processing for me to realize how the keel (or a form of hull acting as a keel) is essential for sailing upwind. The physics are really interesting.
- Prcmaker 4y agoI used to sail and fairly quickly got the understanding for sailing up-wind. The thing that blew my mind, and continues to, is that the top speed you can reach is dependant upon the length of the boat and not the weight. This obviously excludes modern things like motorised craft, planing, foiling etc.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"The thing that blew my mind, and continues to, is that the top speed you can reach is dependant upon the length of the boat and not the weight" Is there a simple explanation for this to share?
- leetcrew 4y agoyou might find this video helpful: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URgSFglbl5g https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=URgSFglbl5g
- gerdesj 4y agoLonger => greater surface area in contact with the water. Friction and stiction due to area is a greater killer of speed than weight, which will only put you a bit lower in the water. It is obviously a lot more complicated than that. Enough weight will sink you and more length will slow your descent to the depths a bit. Greater weight will increase inertia so acceleration will take a hit. Depending on how the weight is distributed you risk turn over due to your meta centre being in the wrong place in relation to your centre of gravity.
- closewith 4y ago> Longer => greater surface area in contact with the water. >Friction and stiction due to area is a greater killer of speed than weight, which will only put you a bit lower in the water. The opposite is true. The longer a hull, the faster a displacement vessel can travel. Here's an MIT explanation: https://engineering.mit.edu/engage/ask-an-engineer/what-is-the-relationship-between-the-length-of-a-boat-and-its-maximum-speed/ https://engineering.mit.edu/engage/ask-an-engineer/what-is-t...
- mhandley 4y agoAs a boat moves through the water it creates a bow wave. The wavelength (ie crest to crest) of the bow wave increases with boat speed. Once the wavelength of the bow wave equals the hull length, the boat will start climbing the front of the bow wave and will be sailing up hill. Unless you've got a lot of power and can climb on top of the bow wave and plane, this is the maximum hull speed.
- sprkwd 4y agoBest explanation I have ever read for that.
- User23 4y ago> The thing that blew my mind, and continues to, is that the top speed you can reach is dependant upon the length of the boat and not the weight. This is true for any rigid body traveling through a fluid. It comes up in ballistics too.
- sopooneo 4y agoThe most mind blowing down “wind” sailing I’ve ever seen: https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=13&v=q2il8Fagbyk&feature=emb_logo https://m.youtube.com/watch?time_continue=13&v=q2il8Fagbyk&f...
- Kon-Peki 4y ago“Modern” things ;) It’s been 94 years since Uffa Fox built the (planing) Avenger and thoroughly destroyed his British competition on the Isle of Wight. And then took that little 14-footer across the channel to do the same to the French. All because the elitist snobs didn’t want him to join their club :)
- chrisweekly 4y agoWhen it comes to explaining how keels allow sailboats to point close to the wind, I always liked "squeeze a watermelon seed, it shoots forward" as a way to make it more intuitive.
- gerdesj 4y agoIf you look down on a bermuda rigged (big triangle) sail from above, it looks suspiciously like an aerofoil and those things fly. There is an angle away from the wind coming towards you which is as "close as you can get to the wind". At that point you are "close hauled", Try and go closer to the wind and your leading edge will collapse (luffing) and you will slow down rapidly and it gets a bit rubbish. As you move away from the wind your speed will increase because of several things: less of the wind vector is trying to blow you sideways and more is actually pushing you. The aerofoil lift thing is less important compared to being pushed. The sweet spot is at around 120 degrees off the wind - there is loads of push and loads of "lift" and a minimal amount of sideways force being counteracted by the hull. This is called a "broad reach". When the wind is behind you "running", there is a lot of push and no "lift" but instead you get drag due to the break up of laminar flow over the wing errr sail. However, in a run you send up spinnakers and "big boys" which are all basically bloody great bags to capture the wind and massively increase speed. Even a small yacht can "goosewing" by putting up two of the front sails - one on each side to increase sail area. I've done about 30mph on a wind surfer in a broadreach - my mum drove along a road parallel to the beach and the wind was just right to do a broad reach roughly parallel to the beach and road. A car speedo is usually 10% shy of reality. Sailing is great fun and can be really complicated but once you know your halyard from your sheet and all that stuff and get to the point where you can feel the wind and can see the conditions on the water and all the other things going on it is rather rewarding. The point of going from novice to supervised fun is quite quick - a weekend or so in a dinghy. A couple of weekends to be confident solo inland and a bit longer at sea. You do need to think safe. Get it wrong and it can be a right old downer!
- WalterBright 4y agoGet it wrong and glub glub goodbye cruel world!
- heavyset_go 4y agoThanks for this example, I had a hard time envisioning it, too.