4 ms·
I agree it would be great in theory... but in practice there's a HUGE problem that the author doesn't seem to have considered: many webpages have footers. I'm
by crazygringo 15y ago
I agree it would be great in theory... but in practice there's a HUGE problem that the author doesn't seem to have considered: many webpages have footers.
I'm talking about normally-positioned footers, not fixed-position ones.
You're not supposed to scroll beyond a footer. It would look terrible. And you don't want to put extra space between the content and the footer either, or have that space vary. (How would you even know)
So while this works great in word-processors, code editors, etc., unfortunately there's just no way to do it in browsers. Literally no way to implement it, even if the browser-makers wanted to.
An aside: it would be great if browsers somehow calculated fixed-position headers/footers and took them into account when calculating scroll distance for space-bar-scrolling...
- derefr 15y ago> You're not supposed to scroll beyond a footer. It would look terrible. Like this? http://i.imgur.com/kFZSo.png http://i.imgur.com/kFZSo.png
- dhbanes 15y agoI think he means like this: http://i.imgur.com/lWzkl.png http://i.imgur.com/lWzkl.png
- derefr 15y agoI was sort of making an implicit suggestion there—that maybe the over-scroll region, if implemented as Safari does it, doesn't look all that bad at all.
- pilgrim689 15y agoIt looks good! And the user won't mistakenly think that the web developer messed up on his footer design. The distinction between the website and what the browser is doing is clear by the relative depth positioning.
- crazygringo 15y agoThat's true. I was just imagining blank white space which would look terrible in many layouts... but with the depth and texture, that could be a solution. Related problem: shift+scrolling up... are we going to go above the top of the page?