3 ms·
I think you're right, it's only the first one in dispute, and even that I think is a false dispute. The distinction, of course, is that common carriers are abo
by crazygringo 4y ago
I think you're right, it's only the first one in dispute, and even that I think is a false dispute.
The distinction, of course, is that common carriers are about 1-to-1 or 1-to-few communication (analagous to writing letters back in the 1700's, or holding a small private gathering) while internet communications are about 1-to-many communication (analagous to submitting an article to the city newspaper back in the 1700's, which they may or may not publish).
1-to-many communication necessarily requires organization, filtering, ranking, rejection, etc. in order not to become an unusable firehose. None of these can be applied objectively or neutrally, they are all editorial in their most fundamental quality, so the idea that any public community could be treated as a common carrier is ludicrous simply at a practical level. Hence why I call it a false dispute -- it's trying to argue for something that isn't even achievable.
- ryandrake 4y agoThis seems right, it's about reach but it's also about the actual mechanics of posting your message. You can't treat social media like the telephone. It's more like writing a letter to the editor of the newspaper. The newspaper receives the letter (post). The newspaper decides whether and how to print it (algorithm). The newspaper then prints it for all to see. That's how social media works. It's not like the telephone where the phone company sets up the circuit and then bows out of the relationship between the speaker and the audience.