46 ms·
You’re pointing out a contradiction that isn’t present: the argument against compelled speech does not rest on corporate personhood. In other words: there is n
by woodruffw 4y ago
You’re pointing out a contradiction that isn’t present: the argument against compelled speech does not rest on corporate personhood.
In other words: there is no investment in a corporation having rights added to it as if it were a legal person. The sole interest is that the people within the corporation do not have their rights subtracted by virtue of how they choose to organize.
You can see this in how people actually talk about moderation online: it simply doesn’t matter if it’s a corporation, nonprofit, union, or individual running a service.
- chabons 4y agoHonest question from someone with little context: How does this argument not also apply to Citizen's United, or corporate personhood more generally? Is the argument that compelling a corporation to do something compels the individuals within the organization (infringing on their rights), while not giving an organization a right does not infringe upon the individuals rights (which they can exercise individually instead)?
- woodruffw 4y agoYep, pretty much that. I think a good way to think about it is as a leaky abstraction: for many purposes, it makes sense (and is very convenient) to treat a corporation as a person. It saves us a lot of ink! But that corporate person is not a natural person, so it doesn't have natural rights. Instead, it has only the synthetic rights that are extended to it through law.