3 ms·
Telephone companies become common carriers when they offer their service indiscriminately to everyone. If a company is reserving its right to deny service based
by jeffbee 4y ago
Telephone companies become common carriers when they offer their service indiscriminately to everyone. If a company is reserving its right to deny service based on its rules of conduct then it is by definition not a common carrier. You can’t just force common carrier status on a company when the facts don’t support that status.
- lokar 4y agoAnd they agreed to offer it to everyone (and common carrier status) when they accepted the use of the public (and compelled private) right of way.
- crazygringo 4y agoNo, you've actually got it backwards. Common carrier isn't a descriptive term that applies based on behavior. It's a legal category that forces the behavior. Telephone companies are common carriers because the law requires them not to discriminate between customers. They don't "become" common carriers. They are required to be whether they like it or not. It's legislatively imposed. And whether with railroads or telephone lines, this constricting regulation is generally accompanied with benefits, often involving access to land and lack of competition.
- jeffbee 4y agoWhile various bodies have purported to force common carrier status on various companies, the actual jurisprudence is much more nuanced than what you have suggested. The legislative imposition is that the FCC is empowered to declare certain entities common carriers if in the public interest. Thus the status is administrative rather than legislative. Furthermore, last-mile ISPs are "information services" not common carriers (Mozilla vs. FCC). It is complete nonsense if YouTube is a "common carrier" and Comcast is an "information service"! Finally, whether a firm presents itself as indiscriminate or not is the main way that it comes to fall under common carriage regulation. See Nat. Ass'n of Regulatory Utility Com'rs v. FCC. "Moreover, the characteristic of holding oneself out to serve indiscriminately appears to be an essential element, if one is to draw a coherent line between common and private carriers. The cases make clear both that common carriers need not serve the whole public, and that private carriers may serve a significant clientele, apart from the carrier himself. Since given private and common carriers may therefore be indistinguishable in terms of the clientele actually served, it is difficult to envision a sensible line between them which does not turn on the manner and terms by which they approach and deal with their customers. The common law requirement of holding oneself out to serve the public indiscriminately draws such a logical and sensible line between the two types of carriers."