4 ms·
While I would agree that the fears are in many cases premature, 20 years is a long time in tech while being short enough to matter for careers. By 2042 we’re l
by ben_w 4y ago
While I would agree that the fears are in many cases premature, 20 years is a long time in tech while being short enough to matter for careers.
By 2042 we’re likely to have single-atom transistors in consumer devices, while people mid-career now are likely to be retiring or getting radical life extension to confuse all this even further, and newborns today will be just about to graduate from universities.
Will we have AI as general-purpose and flexible as a human, even if only limited to an IQ of 85? Dunno, but even limited to that IQ an AGI would render about 15% of the population permanently unemployable, which would be enough to cause all sorts of social and political problems by itself.
But I think the limit on AGI right now isn’t compute resources, it’s that we don’t know the right algorithms to make the AI we have as data-efficient as humans (or even, AFAICT, dogs, cats, or mice).
- bumby 4y ago>Will we have AI as general-purpose and flexible as a human, even if only limited to an IQ of 85? While I agree to a certain extent on this premise, there will still be some areas that AI won’t replace because humans also have an emotional value component. Consider if you’d rather have a massage from a robut or person. Or, if you are infirm and would prefer a caretaker who is human or machine. It’s not just a matter of processing data when humans are emotional creatures. If anything, AGI may free up humans to focus on human relational jobs which we’re much more evolved to be good at and value.
- ben_w 4y ago> Consider if you’d rather have a massage from a robut or person. Or, if you are infirm and would prefer a caretaker who is human or machine. Sure, I’m also implicitly assuming robotics will improve. At some point — don’t know when — we can’t tell the difference any more, and at that point, the humans indistinguishable from machines are likely to be made redundant by the machines.
- bumby 4y agoI’m saying there’s something innately different emotionally about interacting with a human. So if you know it’s a machine, it will inherently change the subjective interaction. If you’re saying that it wont matter because we will get to a point where humans and machines are indistinguishable, that’s implying robots will be emotional and no longer just processing data in the way we currently think of AGI. Essentially it means they will be conscious with subjective experience of their own or just philosophical zombies. Both are essentially fictitious thought experiments at this point.
- throwaway743 4y agoThat's what it seems like they're saying. At some point it's likely they will be indistinguishable from us on many levels, including emotions. There's a demand for it and a solution/peoduct will eventually be created to address that demand, once the means of doing so are technically and financially feasible/scalable. Currently, yes, there's an innate difference, but it's only fictitious that there won't be a difference until it's not. It's plausible speculation. Writing it off as fictitious as of now feels like an "ostrich in the sand" means of molding around a static perception of reality. Things will change, we're not special, labor as we know it will be replaced, machines will at some point acquire the same abilities as us, and we'll have to strive to figure out as a whole if we need to change the means required to carry on and/or individually adapt/overcome such sea changes in labor/income. It will probably cause many issues within our societies, but many will also see opportunities. It's going to be a lot of grey, likely more so than now.
- bumby 4y agoI agree that there’s hubris in thinking we’re somehow special. But pretending we will get there “someday” isn’t much different than saying one day we’ll time travel. Even if plausible, it’s so far from where we’re currently at it belongs more to philosophical thought experiments than serious technology inquiry
- ben_w 4y agoI'd agree that they would either be conscious or p-zombies, but I think humans are sufficiently easy to fool that the latter may well happen. I offer panpsychism and celebrity fandoms/parasocial relationships as examples of people's emotional sense of connection being misleading. I don't think anyone has a sufficiently concrete definition of consciousness to even tell either how far we are from that now, nor how to get there from here. https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/06/18/lamda-turing-test-sentience/ https://kitsunesoftware.wordpress.com/2022/06/18/lamda-turin...
- gnaritas99 4y agoNeither of those examples are a good illustration of your point as many and probably most will prefer the machine in both scenarios. I don't get a massage for an emotional experience with the masseuse; I'd prefer the likely much cheaper and higher quality and consistent machine massage. Ditto with a permanent caretaker as it'll allow you to feel far more independant; most of us don't want to feel like a burden on other people. However, you do have a valid point, just not good examples imho. AGI will make the vast majority unemployable, it'll be a disaster and those jobs won't simply be replaced by new ones: people who think this haven't thought through it very deeply at all.
- bumby 4y agoMaybe. My original example that came to mind was a caretaker for someone terminally ill, I.e., hospice. Having volunteered in that area, people want human contact, even if it’s not performing any pragmatic function. I tend to think automation would just make somebody feel more isolated. People yearn for connection, not automation. I believe the research shows there is a strong psychological component to massage that goes beyond the mechanical manipulation. I guess it would depend on whether somebody uses it for stress relieve or merely recovery.
- gnaritas99 4y agoOh, terminal, yea that's one where I agree, they want company more than anything; but even that will eventually fall prey to AGI. People will be best friends and family with AGI's; grow up with them, presuming we don't go down the Terminator route; people are very quick to anthropomorphize anything remotely reminiscent of human behavior.
- saulpw 4y agoI think I'd rather have a $20 hug from a real person than a $5 hug from a heated robot. Even if the robot had better AI conversational skills than the person.
- gnaritas99 4y ago