4 ms·
We can’t do parallelism, only concurrency on a cognitive level. Think of your brain like the CPU, while your appendages can be thought of as some PCIe connected
by kaba0 4y ago
We can’t do parallelism, only concurrency on a cognitive level. Think of your brain like the CPU, while your appendages can be thought of as some PCIe connected device. The CPU can send tasks to those and given a well-known pattern it can execute them autonomously (e.g. you can walk without actively thinking about it. But if there is dog shit on the streets you want to avoid you will have to look up and allocate CPU time to the task)
- messe 4y ago> We can’t do parallelism, only concurrency on a cognitive level. While that might be through of conscious thought, but there's definitely at least anecdotal evidence to suggest that the brain performs tasks in the background. Think about how many times you've struggled to remember the name of an author, a movie, an actor; only to have it come to you hours later while you're working on something entirely unrelated.
- orev 4y agoA computer accomplishes tasks by coordinating many subsystems. Not everything is done in the CPU, and the brain is similar. The central unit can make requests of other components (e.g. storage controller), and they go off and do it while the central unit does something else. Only the real heavy thinking/processing happens in the CPU, and that’s always what discussions about human multitasking are talking about. Brains and computer systems work in similar ways.
- sudosysgen 4y agoEven the CPU itself has different processing units which it uses to delegate such tasks and achieve parallelism for tasks which don't have data dependencies
- interroboink 4y ago> Only the real heavy thinking/processing happens in the CPU... > Brains and computer systems work in similar ways. I think that this characterization is pretty simplistic. Perhaps it's useful as a model from time to time, but does not capture the massively complex reality, full of unknowns and poorly understood by science to this day. Where is this "CPU" in the brain, of which you speak? I suppose the pre-frontal cortex? That zone is generally associated with orchestration/planning, that you mention. But to say that those functions constitute "the real heavy thinking" is a bit of a reach, I think. It would be like saying the manager does the all the hard work (: I'm no neuroscientist, but anecdotally, a good portion of my important mental results come from an unknown place — maybe bubbling to the forefront of consciousness when I'm sitting on the toilet, or in a dream. Not when my "CPU is spinning", so to speak. YMMV.
- Fire-Dragon-DoL 4y agoDon't we breath while we do anything else? That must account for parallelism
- jrootabega 4y agoI think we can do some limited degree of parallelism. We can walk/run and talk at the same time. We can walk and operate a phone at the same time (albeit more poorly). Our two arms can work in parallel - rub your belly and pat your head. Or, for a better example, driving a manual transmission car -- you can shift gears, and modulate your steering and speed at the same time. In the mental world, you can also listen to a couple conversations at once with effort.
- jskulski 4y agoThis level of parallelism feels more like my brain is abstracting two tasks into one. It takes a little practice and then you gain that ability
- jrootabega 4y agoInteresting observation. Are you saying there IS a feeling of doing two things in parallel that you just don't feel for those tasks? Maybe that is what parallelism feels like. But on the other hand, would I say that walking is itself parallel because it uses two legs, two feet, and two arms all doing things at once? I guess not.
- jrootabega 4y agoAnother one: turning the handle on my popcorn cooker and hitting microwave buttons to melt butter. Steering with one hand and changing radio stations with the other. One that I feel I can't do at all: hit a keyboard key really fast with one hand and hit another one more slowly with another. Unless I treat it like playing drums in a specific rhythm, my fast hand has to stop briefly to let my slow hand hit its key.
- carapace 4y agoThe limits of what we can and can't do are not well-explored, nor well-bounded. For example, there was a fellow (his name escapes me at the moment) who had trained himself to be able to write a sentence with one hand while solving a mathematical equation with the other. There's a reason why our minds evolved a "unitary" identity or ego, it's evolutionarily advantageous (tautologically, sorry), but it's an illusion. You can "divide" your mind among several tasks (in other words, the brain is not like a CPU, it's more like "the cloud", yeah?) but it's not really as useful as it might seem. - - - - (FWIW, my first thought on reading the title was "This person doesn't cook." ;P )
- sudosysgen 4y agoI learnt to do that in elementary school for fun, I would personally do it by doing it concurrently fast enough that the bottleneck was my hand writing instead of the thought, so all I was actually doing in parallel was writing things I had already thought out, so I don't know how much this brings to the concurrency/parallelism conscious thought question.
- fnordpiglet 4y agoHuman twins are parallel processors, with two identical and independent cores.
- jayd16 4y agoWhat would you call walking and chewing gum?