4 ms·

On the contrary, I find most of his videos to be deeply humanizing of their subjects, who would probably be ignored or brushed aside in a normal day-to-day inte

by _bohm 4y ago

On the contrary, I find most of his videos to be deeply humanizing of their subjects, who would probably be ignored or brushed aside in a normal day-to-day interaction by the typical viewer of the channel. Also, speaking personally as someone who has a family member who suffers from addiction, I have found it valuable to listen to people speak candidly about their struggles to someone uninvested in their lives, in a way that my family member could never speak to me.

busterarm 4y ago
Separate how viewing the content makes you feel from understanding the subject's ability to completely understand and consent to a contractual arrangement to have their story recorded, broadcast and sold. When an addict-relative sells all of your valuables, are they in a proper state of mind or is their addiction ruling their life? Do they fully comprehend the outcome of their actions? Most of these people are not in any proper state of mind to be able to sign on to appear on a show like this.
- _bohm 4y ago
  Ok, so what kinds of things should a person in that state be considered capable of consenting to? My experience is that treating addicts as ineligible to exercise their own agency only serves to further alienate them and fuel their abuse.
- Test0129 4y ago
  > Most of these people are not in any proper state of mind to be able to sign on to appear on a show like this. They are telling their story not making porn. You could gather the same information going to your local skid row and asking people to tell you how they got there. I don't know the details of the demonetization but I've watched the channel several times. It's enlightening and sad like all good documentaries should be. If you have information on the agreement they sign that no one else does here post it. Otherwise this seems like pure speculation and strawmanning of the motives of the guy who runs the channel.

by _bohm 4y ago

busterarm 4y ago

Separate how viewing the content makes you feel from understanding the subject's ability to completely understand and consent to a contractual arrangement to have their story recorded, broadcast and sold. When an addict-relative sells all of your valuables, are they in a proper state of mind or is their addiction ruling their life? Do they fully comprehend the outcome of their actions? Most of these people are not in any proper state of mind to be able to sign on to appear on a show like this.

_bohm 4y ago
Ok, so what kinds of things should a person in that state be considered capable of consenting to? My experience is that treating addicts as ineligible to exercise their own agency only serves to further alienate them and fuel their abuse.
Test0129 4y ago
> Most of these people are not in any proper state of mind to be able to sign on to appear on a show like this. They are telling their story not making porn. You could gather the same information going to your local skid row and asking people to tell you how they got there. I don't know the details of the demonetization but I've watched the channel several times. It's enlightening and sad like all good documentaries should be. If you have information on the agreement they sign that no one else does here post it. Otherwise this seems like pure speculation and strawmanning of the motives of the guy who runs the channel.