11 ms·
Does not trump the absurdity of heavily subsidizing an american EV company in order to buy their cars, then telling users not to charge them during the winter.
by seydor 4y ago
Does not trump the absurdity of heavily subsidizing an american EV company in order to buy their cars, then telling users not to charge them during the winter.
As an EU-country citizen I am concerned by the dominance of political appearances in all the workings of EU since before the pandemic. Insisting in formerly-popular CO2 deadlines in the face of long-lasting ukraine war is absurd. Phasing out ICE cars too early is absurd. Subsidizing buying EVs throughout europe, even though many countries clearly can't support the future EV load is absurd. Fining power production through coal is absurd, as is not having a nuclear strategy. Keeping the marginal pricing of wholesale energy during war, is absurd. Begging the dictator of azerbaijan for oil at the same time that they are attacking their neighbor, while also sanctioning russia for doing the same thing, is absurd.
Ursula VdL is a bad leader, and Charles Michel (president of the council) has recently publicly called her out for her bad leadership in energy. This EU that we see now is unrecognizable: inward-looking, woefully stuck in its own processes and populist obsessions, preoccupied with appearances (e.g. demanding gas and and even power cuts from countries that are NOT dependent on russia), and complete lack of vision. I am personally thankful to the US for taking initiative in nearly all fronts: arming ukraine, providing LNG to northern europe, coordinating sanctions and even Pelosi showing her support for democracy in the region.
- spoiler 4y ago
- smokel 4y agoYou make it sound as if it is possible to simply toggle some checkboxes to change policy. A lot of people are invested in previous policies, and change is not always easy. The path forward is a very complex one, starting with the problem that not everyone agrees on the direction of forward. So, at the surface things may seem absurd, but if you try to untangle the underlying problems, it is probably more absurd to expect change so easily. And it is perhaps not reasonable to hold leaders accountable for the mess that they are trying to clean up.
- koheripbal 4y agoThey toggled off their nuclear program, and even today the heads of those remaining nuclear plants are saying they can remain open. ...yet German re-committed to turn them off this year. There is some significant stupidity happening in Europe's energy policy.
- seydor 4y agoI 'm sorry what? Changing the marginal pricing which will do a lot to make prices more reasonable is doable today, spain and portugal already did it. Germany can use lignite this winter, and other countries too, under specific conditions, and even changing heating from gas to oil is doable, even now. Can take advantage of remote working to reduce consumption in many places. I mean the purpose of leadership is to find and show a direction when people disagree. But nobody is even proposing changes. And it's not like the EU needs to change its long-term policies, it can still support renewables (which will happen anyway now because it s cheaper), but in the face of war it should have already changed regulations temporarily and dust off some of those lignite plants. It is instead counterproductive to seek deals with awful countries like saudi or az or venezuela. It's been seven months since the war started, we can't pretend there is no time to react anymore
- karottenreibe 4y agoHow can you change heating from gas to oil without exchanging the central heating device and installing oil storage canisters in every das heated home? How is that achievable on short notice?
- mstipetic 4y agoRebuilding cities and dealing with hundreds of millions of migrating people is much more expensive than that
- Al-Khwarizmi 4y agoClimate change is the most dramatic problem facing humanity and we cannot delay already unambitious deadlines with the excuse of a war. And phasing out ICE cars "early" (IMO 2035 is way too late) is not only good for the environment but a strategic necessity for the EU, which, it's worth reminding, has pitiful amounts of oil and totally depends on external suppliers for it, including Russia and other countries we would prefer not to depend on. Seeing what's happening with gas, which is substitutable as an electricity source, it would be very unwise to depend on oil for transportation. It's a need for Europe to be the first to transition to EVs (and even with all the incentives, it's not even in the lead). I agree with you re: nuclear, marginal pricing (even without war), Azerbaijan, sanctions, and Van der Leyen being a bad leader, though.
- chaosbolt 4y agoWell who would've thought the value signaling politics of today would be absurd and lack any intelligence or foresight. There are also sacrifices to be made by everyone, if you want less immigration you'll have to get off your ass and do those "jobs you'll never lower yourself to" yourself, if you want sustainable energy you might want to start building nuclear plants with formally (as in mathematically) modeled, verified and tested components, and you might also use the same phone for 5 years and not have a phone, a tablet, a tv, a desktop and a laptop for every member of the family, 3 cars, always on AC, etc., might use blankets for heat or open your windows for cool air or you know just sweat and drink water, etc. when your only problem in life is whether you'll use a plastic bag or a paper bag when every single product you bought contains 10 smaller products individually wrapped in plastic and every electronics you own (mainly for entertainment since 1 laptop is enough) uses hundreds of materials all shipped across earth to a country that assembles them using almost slavery and ships them back. But no, you see the right advocating for X thing but not wanting to do anything about it, and the left is advocating for Y but also not wanting to do anything about it, and everyone is trying to convince everyone else that they're really contributing to X or Y cause. The first thing to do to cut on over consumption and thus energy use would be war, because if you're unable to stop yourself from attacking a country on the other side of the world, kill a million civilians, all for oil, aka murder to get cheaper oil, then you're probably unable to sacrifice personal comfort for a greater cause, and will settle for virtue signaling and larping as a good person. Now I don't think this problem can be solved, because we're first of all human, aka primates with greed, violence and lack of care for anyone or anything with a DNA too different from ours, and until we start to discuss these things as they are and not as we want them to be, then our decisions won't go anywhere. The other issue to solve this is democracy, people are always dissatisfied and will always vote for the person who serves them best, right now, that's why we allow the central bank to print money and lend it to our government for interest, to be paid by our grandkids through taxes, just so we can have better roads today, and that's why we'll vote for the person who'll make us more comfortable now even if it means the people who'll live a hundred years from now will live in a worse environment than the one we live in. Someone needs to invent a new protocol for politics, that would serve us now and in the future better than our current system does, but that's super hard and would make some other protocol like say bitcoin seem like a 3 year old's solution to a trivial problem. And I didn't even talk about how 100 IQ is the average that that means half the population is under that and can't even conceptualize of things more abstract than "do this now" => "experience consequences tomorrow", and wouldn't understand or care about sacrifice today for future generations, unless they're pushed towards it by social shame and other powerful human motivators, but then they won't understand anything deeply, and will spend an hour separating paper from glass for recycling because they genuinely think it's important, but then take 6 flights for holidays, drive huge card, order useless shit online, change electronics every year, because those are also pushed with powerful human motivators like social status etc. So yeah, there can be no simple solution like vote for Mr. A to get result B.
- rozab 4y ago>Insisting in formerly-popular CO2 deadlines in the face of long-lasting ukraine war is absurd I don't follow. How has the Ukraine conflict not increased the urgency of transitioning from fossil fuels?