4 ms·
They rely on the fact that "Antigua and Barbuda" is the name of a single territory, as is "Turks and Caicos". Humans are quite decent at parsing ambiguous text
by sph 4y ago
They rely on the fact that "Antigua and Barbuda" is the name of a single territory, as is "Turks and Caicos".
Humans are quite decent at parsing ambiguous text, you'll find.
- Closi 4y agoAgreed, and besides the broader point, considering this is a writing style guide, is to avoid ambiguous/awkward statements altogether. If this sentence was describing places you shouldn’t visit as an example, a bullet point list would probably be more appropriate. So in a more context-appropriate example this would probably be rephrased as This disease is found in the following areas: * Jamaica * Antigua and Barbuda * Turks and Caicos Now I’m not arguing if this particular style guide is a good idea or not - but I can see why you might want to avoid the original statement which was quite hard to parse with confidence.
- jeroenhd 4y agoHaving never heard of "Turks and Caicos" the sentence was quite difficult to parse in my opinion. I happen to have heard "Antigua and Barbuda" as a single place name at some point but even then I wasn't entirely sure until I saw your explainer. All confusion could be removed by a few commas, I don't see why you wouldn't add those.
- tester89 4y agoThe sentence already has the Oxford comma, and it appears it didn’t prevent your confusion. If the commas are not effective at their job, I don’t see why one would add them.
- addicted 4y agoBecause there is no guarantee that an Oxford comma would be used. If we were guaranteed that Oxford commas would always be used then there would be no confusion.
- shaky-carrousel 4y agoI never heard about Turks and Caicos and was able to parse it correctly. Maybe it is because we don't have Oxford comma in Spanish.
- euroderf 4y agoWon't anyone think of the neglected ampersand ?
- thenoblesunfish 4y agoPossibly there would be some confusion here, because my example had the name of 5 islands and three countries!