7 ms·
Hoardiculture
- ggm 4y agoTrue story. This tendency is strong in my family. I know it because I have a bus ticket I kept for nearly 60 years and a vast collection of possibly useful empty cardboard boxes, stored in other cardboard boxes. My sister was name called into a UK "your life on the lawn" hoarder reality show by friends. By coincidence she did some minor tidying and was that day called by the show producers and the dialogue went like this: Them: Surprise! You've been recommended to us to be on a hoarder TV show. Her: Oh great! I've just been dusting the video tape pile Then Them: Oh, sorry, if you can still clean, you aren't amusing for us. Bye. Obviously at the extreme end, It's life threatening and has major issues for everyone involved. More casual semi obsessive "I cannot easily throw things away" is rife.
- zafka 4y agoI feel that with very little effort I could get on one of those shows. Recently I have been holding off the entropy a little- even throwing a few things away, but hey, someday I might be able to use those 1970 transistors from the old equipment in the back room.....
- sshine 4y ago> I have a bus ticket I kept for nearly 60 years I keep every drawing a kid ever made, and every single note someone ever wrote to me. Even ones where someone just wanted to tell me they were leaving while I was on a call.
- mapmap 4y agoA solution that worked for me: take a picture, save it to an album, throw away the paper.
- favourable 4y agoI have cultivated a habit of throwing away at least one possession per day, and this doesn't include generic household trash. I mean something that I deemed: 'One day this will come in handy' but they rarely do come in handy later on. It's a form of 'essentialism' where I trim away the excess and keep a curated and perfect set of tools to get things done.
- thfuran 4y agoWouldn't it be better to stop acquiring possessions rather than generating an endless stream of garbage?
- Wistar 4y agoBetter yet to stop endless streams of garbage at the point of their generation, no?
- ravi-delia 4y agoNot really, no. The average thing you keep around because "it might be useful someday" usually once really was useful! As it passes out of usefulness, if you don't have something coming in to replace it, you're down one useful thing.
- zafka 4y agoCaiero, I love your about statment. I was disapointed that you have no listed comments yet. A quite interesting list of submissions though! As a side note, it would be nice if folks put contact info in their about section. I think it would allow for some fortuitous connections to be made.
- schlowmo 4y agoMaybe I'm just rationalising my own hoarding tendency but I think society needs some hoarders to enable others to live there Kondō lifestyle. Sometimes friends who know my habit try (often successfully) to offload their stuff to me. Just to ask me years later if I happen to own exactly the item they offloaded because they need it.
- rzzzt 4y agoDoes keeping friends' items around bring you joy?
- culi 4y agoThere's lots of Library of Things projects around the country, but they're usually informal mutual aid type events. I think something much better organized and funded (maybe even some nice software to go along with it) could make a huge difference in our waste crisis Also, we should be charging people for their trash. Both companies and consumers imo. It's kinda ridiculous to offload so much waste as an economic externality. I live near a university and every year I get to watch a new set of students move into the student housing. Towards the start of the school year the dumpsters are filled with Ikea and Amazon boxes form all the new furniture. At move out time they have to bring these absolutely massive metal containers (like 3x the size of a shipping container) for the students to through out all their furniture (most of which has been used for less than a year). It's particularly bad with this university since a fifth are international students. 80% of the furniture in my house was "rescued". We used to hoard it and sell it on Craiglist and the like. We once sold a $200 marble table we got for free. Also have two pairs of working air pods and a bunch of $100+ shoes (including some Jordans and a pair of Yeezys) that we just haven't gotten around to selling yet. We also have a bench press and weights, 2 working grills, and too many office chairs. All this and we still save every glass jar and use them as our cups. Unfortunately, my housemates are not big fans of the mismatched furniture look, but I find it quite charming :( It's wild how much waste could be averted if all that furniture was simply stored on a plot of land over the summer until the next wave of students came in and then we let them pick through it. We used to pick up everything we could sell, but it just became too much of an effort because of the sheer volume of furniture
- ChrisMarshallNY 4y agoI have a whole bunch of “just in case” cables. These are things like old S-video, and FireWire 400 cables. It actually causes me psychic pain, to consider throwing them away. I have compromised, by throwing away “all but one.” At least, I was able to toss all my SCSI cables…
- Moru 4y agoLast year I actually had use for that s-video cable I was saving just in case. That makes it soo much harder to throw anything away.
- AussieWog93 4y agoJust for what it's worth, a quick search on AliExpress shows this S-Video cable at $3.01 + $1.00 shipping: https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002927307329.html https://www.aliexpress.com/item/1005002927307329.html For argument's sake, let's say 5% of your house's floor space is dedicated to storing crap that you might use one day in the future. At $1500/mo rent, that's effectively $75/mo you're spending to store crap, or $900/year. This doesn't include the additional stress that comes from the clutter and inability to find what you need. So if it makes things easier, just consider the hundreds to thousands of dollars per year you're spending on floor space with negative utility, all to avoid a couple of <$50 purchases.
- intrasight 4y agoClearly you don't understand the situation. I will buy that AliExpress S-Video even though I already have one - which I can't find. And of course I will enjoy buying another one.
- Nomentatus 4y agoHe understands the rational view of the situation, you understand the emotional situation, I'd say.
- WalterBright 4y agoA storage unit costs around $300/month. Storage units are full of stuff that in aggregate is not worth $300.
- troyvit 4y agoWe treat thrift stores as our "off-site storage unit" and the amazing thing is it's a distributed storage site. When we don't use a thing we drop it off at the nearest thrift store. If we need it back we just hit the thrift stores around town until we find something close to what we were looking for and for a nominal fee we get it back.
- dexwiz 4y agoSounds like you have an abundance of time.
- troyvit 4y agoWhen spending an extra few hours a month saves me $400/month then yeah I have an abundance of time.
- WalterBright 4y agoMy home theater is mostly pieced together from thrift store stuff.
- selfhoster11 4y ago> until we find something close to what we were looking for Must be nice to mostly deal with unspecialised objects, then.
- troyvit 4y agoIt is not just nice but fantastic to not care if a chair is black, white, adjustible, etc. and instead just buy a chair.
- 4y ago
- sshine 4y agoI don't understand why people have such a problem with hoarding. Clearly it is not a question of "too much stuff" but of "too little space". If you have enough space, and you have a good enough category system to find your things, who cares what the likeliness of needing something again is? I understand that the problem is that people live within limited space, such as apartments, and those apartments get stuffed very quickly. And life in such an apartment gets very crammed and dusty. And that isn't really a problem, even. The problem of hoarding too much stuff in a small living space is that you have to share that space with your family, and your family does not appreciate the things you hoard as much as you do. So their quality of life goes down at the cost of your quality of life going up. It seems to me that hoarding as a "disorder" is not sharing your limited space reasonably.
- dexwiz 4y agoThe author admits to feeling shame for his father as a child and pride as an adult. The only true difference is that he no longer lives with his father.
- sshine 4y agoYes, I’ve undergone the same shift, and I cherish my mom’s hoarding. I even named my holding company “<X> Hoarding” (since another family member has “<X> Holding”). This is with a degree of irony, but also an acknowledgement that desiring to gather things is a slippery slope when you don’t require things to be used with any real probability. I mostly hoard small, rare objects of similar kind to manage, but I’m afraid the definition of rarity is both subjective and sliding. For example, I found a piece of scratched up ornamental wood broken off a piece of furniture that looks like a snail while I was having a conversation with a friend, and when I see that piece of wood, it takes me back to walking on that street: the trees in the picture get greener and the red hair of my friend gets redder every time I think back. I don’t care if I don’t see the piece for years. It is very frustrating to share the space with a collector when you don’t share the dopamine rewards of acquiring the things, since the constant upkeep detracts every day.
- AussieWog93 4y ago
- mitchbob 4y agoArchived: https://archive.ph/n2RrC https://archive.ph/n2RrC
- dexwiz 4y agoI think this is a wonderfully empathic view of hoarding. It’s a scale like everything, and the view of the scale is subjective. However it’s very difficult to live with one.
- Jill_the_Pill 4y agoAn overlooked aspect: older or disabled people may not have the psychological situation of a hoarder, but getting rid of stuff can be physically demanding and some are just not up to it.
- Merrill 4y agoOlder people have the advantage that if they do discard something, they later won't remember that they had it.
- antisthenes 4y agoThat's pretty dismissive. Many older people retain a sharp mind well into their 70s/80s. Probably not old hoarders though.
- benj111 4y agoI think it was light hearted rather than dismissive. My grandparents go to the dog's name before getting to mine. My parents just gets me and my brother's names mixed up. My other nan, who actually had dementia, on the other hand, could still remember all the ins and outs of which great grand child was going out with who this week, until the end.
- lloeki 4y ago> I would place the room in which I’m writing this at level three on the CIR – a ‘standard’ amount of household clutter, according to Frost and Steketee. If level 3 refers to the CIR living room image at the top, well, this level being "standard" sounds weird to me. I mean, 3 to me is a mess already. I keep my house at what would be level 0, level 1 is already pushing it (acceptable temporarily, but these piles of newspaper? make me feel nervous), level 2 is when things get way out of hand (e.g because life is a thing and sometimes time/energy comes short). Most people I know would be the same, a few would need level -1 or -2 (that would be IKEA-like house, always clean and tidy in every way). I do know a couple of level 4/5 but while I'm empathetic, non-judgemental, and respectful that everyone is different, it blows past my "what is this I don't even" mental line, where it gets unsettling to me to physically be in such an environment. > But like Falkoff, who first became interested in what she calls ‘hoardiculture’ because both her grandmother and her father were compulsive hoarders, I grew up in a house that was somewhere between level five (hoarding that might require some ‘professional assistance’) and level seven (which poses significant safeguarding issues, requiring ‘a collaborative multi-agency approach with the involvement of a wide range of professionals’). Oh my looking at the pictures this sounds like the most horrifying experience to me.
- intrasight 4y agoAre there actual medically diagnosed levels for this disorder? I would think that for this disorder, you'd need at least ten levels. It would be instructive to see them spelled out with perhaps a dozen bullet points per level. I am of the opinion that photos would not help. They can only capture a snapshot and don't reflect something like a 200 day moving average. I would also be interested in knowing where I sit on that ten point scale.
- lloeki 4y ago> Are there actual medically diagnosed levels for this disorder? I don't really know, this CIR thing sounded like a medical diagnosis framework in the article. Being confused by what this "standard" means (is it what the average population does or what the typical hoarder does?) I just extrapolated with what my personal feelings are. The article also briefly mentions the aesthetics of it, which I kind of link to horror vacui. http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2014/11/11/horror_vacui/ http://ignorethecode.net/blog/2014/11/11/horror_vacui/
- cercatrova 4y agoIt's unfortunate that this post doesn't have images because they are much more impactful when you see what a hoarder's actual house looks like: https://i.imgur.com/Gw9pfd7.jpg https://i.imgur.com/Gw9pfd7.jpg See how there is a layer of trash on the floor such that you can't even see the bare floor. That's why this is not simply "having too much stuff" or "too little space." It is an actual medical and psychological condition that creates anxiety in people such that they cannot throw anything away, until they are left with a house overflowing with garbage.
- intrasight 4y ago"Hoarder" like "psychopath" has ceased to be a useful layperson's useful medical term. I think the medical community would do us some service by coming up with a new phrase. How about "obsessive physical retainer"? Also of interest is that societies view of "obsessive physical retainers" is so negative. We don't generally view mental hoarding as a disorder. And as far as the physical sort, imaging how many thousands of years behind we would now be if those monks hadn't hoarded those ancient manuscripts. They could hardly read let alone understand them but kept them anyway. We wouldn't know that Lucretius had theorized the atom among many other wonderful things. I have a acquaintance who society would probably consider a hoarder. Some of you may know him. Many will know people like him. He likes stuff. Definitely far along on the hoarder spectrum. He acquired an abandoned rail station to give a home to all his stuff. He has hundreds of cars. He has every game ever made. He has more knickknacks than any antique store I've ever seen. There is no garbage. There is no stench. So I'd claim that he doesn't suffer from "obsessive physical retainer" pathology.
- PuppyTailWags 4y agoCollecting is different from hoarding. Collecting a lot of stuff is fine. Hoarding is when you cannot let any of that stuff go, even if it's soiled, useless, or hazardous to your health. Hoarding is grabbing more things, without knowing even why you're grabbing them, like an emotional eater.
- hammyhavoc 4y agoI am about to clear my late uncle's belongings and I am extremely overwhelmed. Started out collecting (books, manga, vinyl, laser discs, tapes, CDs, DVDs, Blu-Ray, comic books etc), and descended into hoarding eventually. Has storage units too. Place is filthy, got a week and a half to clear it all before I need to hand the keys back. People don't understand what hoarding is like.