4 ms·
> Peltier systems require more energy input than comparable compressor-based systems. However, while heat is emitted from Peltier systems, it is comparatively l
by londons_explore 4y ago
> Peltier systems require more energy input than comparable compressor-based systems. However, while heat is emitted from Peltier systems, it is comparatively less than in compressor-based systems. This means that there may be some savings in terms of air conditioning load in the area where the unit is housed, which could help offset the energy efficiency differential.
Either I am misunderstanding what is being said there, or the article author misunderstands how physics works.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- LoganDark 4y agoYeah, that also looks sus to me. According to my very limited understanding of how this works, compressor-based systems (actually more like phase-change systems) only have to pump heat energy from one place to another. Peltier systems have to do this while also fighting thermal conductivity from one side of the module to the other. Intuitively, the latter probably generates more waste heat...
- dtgriscom 4y agoBut, compressor-based systems have to deal with friction (both mechanical and fluid). I'd still bet on their efficiency over Peltiers, though, unless it's a really small system.
- Panzer04 4y agoPeltiers are less efficient. Ergo, in a closed room, they will generate more heat, regardless of any other factors in play.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- rsaxvc 4y agoThe compressor isn't located on the cooling chamber - it's on the other side of the insulation so the heat can be dumped to the room. The self heating (for better or for worse) of a peltier is generated at the cooling chamber edge.
- fuzzfactor 4y agoThe compressor motor converts a large portion of the electricity it consumes directly into waste heat which is why the motor warms up much more than from the friction. This is in excess of the heat being removed from the refrigerated area. Air conditioners have the warm-running compressor outdoors, but refrigerated indoor appliances release that heat into the room along with the heat transferred from inside the refrigerator. And then the AC encounters further inefficiency as it next removes this heat from the room. Even the motor of a ceiling fan warms up a room (gradually) if there is no AC and windows/doors are not open adequately to let that heat escape. Ceiling fans have big motors and are best outdoors like at a tiki bar.
- LoganDark 4y agoThis is true, compressor-based systems don't just magically move heat energy. But at least the hot/cold sides can be isolated much better than a Peltier.
- rsaxvc 4y agoAt least for peltier cooling, as delta temperature across the peltier increases, it takes progressively more power to counteract conduction inside the peltier. This requires progressively more power and results in joule heating. Works great at low deltaT though. https://www.meerstetter.ch/customer-center/compendium/71-peltier-element-efficiency https://www.meerstetter.ch/customer-center/compendium/71-pel... has some nice plots and explanation of how performance varies with deltaT. A constant current driver can also be important - PWM results in increased joule heating. For 50% maximum constant current joule heating is (V/2)^2/R but when duty-cycling with 50% PWM, it's V^2/(2*R). Moving the scaling factor out from under the ^2 makes the savings more pronounced at lower deltaT as well. But constant current is more complex, especially with larger peltiers. I cants really speak for Carnot cycle coolers, but they can often be effectively duty-cycled and can be placed remotely so the compressor waste heat can be vented into the room. Performance still degrades with dT though.