3 ms·
For a reported stolen car/felony stop, it seems pretty reasonable that they'd handcuff the driver before checking the driver's license and discovering it matche
by sokoloff 4y ago
For a reported stolen car/felony stop, it seems pretty reasonable that they'd handcuff the driver before checking the driver's license and discovering it matches the registration.
- DiggyJohnson 4y agoIf the driver is otherwise complying and saying “this is my vehicle, wtf are you doing?” then: no, I strongly disagree.
- kube-system 4y agoThieves don't usually say "you caught me!" when confronted by police. They frequently claim they own the stolen items.
- 2muchcoffeeman 4y agoSo what? If the person is non violent and cooperative why use cuffs?
- kube-system 4y agoCops generally determine the risk of a suspect by the severity of a crime. A felony crime is considered a significant crime. But regardless, cops put cuffs on everyone they arrest. The point being that they don’t know who is going to fight you to get away. People will fight to escape over the dumbest things. It’s not really a huge injustice to sit in cuffs for a couple minutes while cops verify wtf is going on. I’m the first to criticize the cops but this isn’t really that kind of situation. If I reported my car stolen, I would expect the cops to have a reasonable assumption that the person they find it with could be the thief.
- pcl 4y agoYears ago, I was pulled over while driving a rental car that had been reported stolen by an earlier renter a few weeks prior. I'm certainly glad that the officers in Atlanta approached the situation professionally and without any cuffs involved.
- elliekelly 4y agoWas it a Hertz car, by any chance? Because I believe they are currently being sued for doing that thousands of times.
- pcl 4y agoNo. And the rental agency seemed pretty blameless in the whole situation. A previous renter had reported the car stolen, but then found the car not long after. It turns out that anyone can report a car stolen, but only the owner can report it un-stolen, and I'm guessing the previous renter somehow forgot to mention the whole affair to the rental agency. The rental agency ended up giving me a free rental and a credit for another free day or something on a future rental.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoAfter reading the article but before reading the comments, I thought to myself, people will defend all manner of awful things, even when they’re this clear cut. Sure wish I’d been wrong. Being forcibly detained is traumatic. Especially when you know you’re being detained wrongly. I’m speaking from experience here, and as someone who has received a settlement in a wrongful arrest suit. There’s nothing reasonable about armed officers of the state putting someone in handcuffs without any prior effort to ascertain the appropriateness of that person being in handcuffs. Asking for license and registration is routine. If anything after that suggests they have actually stopped a car thief, the next appropriate action might be to forcibly detain them. It might also be more appropriate to question them further without force. Putting a car’s rightful owner in handcuffs because their car had been towed without their knowledge, and they understandably reported it stolen when it wasn’t where they’d left it, and then they had the temerity to drive their own car after it had been recovered, is cruel. All of the prior facts would already be unbelievably stressful for most people. And of course no random cop is gonna know all of those prior facts, but that’s why they should ask questions before acting. Let me reiterate: being forced into constraints by armed agents of the state who have broad authority, and get broad allowance, to use their monopoly on violence is terrifying. It’s even more terrifying when you know you’ve done nothing to warrant it, and especially when you’re being treated that way because of other wrongs done to you.
- sokoloff 4y agoOn the spectrum of police behavior, this is left of zero for sure, but pretty benign and easy to understand.
- eyelidlessness 4y agoAfter I posted my comment above, I had to calm myself because I had a spike of anxiety remembering the details of my own experiences with police aggression, and the memory takes me far away from my body into a place of distilled fear. I’m remembering more as I type this. I think the word you’re looking for is “comprehend”. I do comprehend why police act aggressively without cause or warning. I don’t think it’s benign. I do think you’re very fortunate not to know that.