4 ms·
In fairness, the only valid complaint I've heard about Craigslist is that it diverted classified ad revenue away from reporters, destroying local newspapers, an
by hedora 4y ago
In fairness, the only valid complaint I've heard about Craigslist is that it diverted classified ad revenue away from reporters, destroying local newspapers, and then local elections.
With Craigslist, this always felt like an unintended consequence. With facebook, it seems like one of their top ten strategies for getting us to devolve into mineshaft dwelling mole people that live in the metaverse.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoBlaming technology for obviating business models is not a valid complaint. In this case, I would say the participants of the local society are responsible for paying for journalism and working to support local elections. But even then, you could come up with arguments such as so and so population was too poor and had to work two jobs and did not have time to attend city/county/state meetings, or were not sufficiently educated or literate to understand them, etc.
- lkrubner 4y agoYou write “Blaming technology” in response to a comment that does not mention any technologies. You might want to examine what your preconceptions are, that you would see “technology” in a comment that does not refer to technology. You were responding to a comment that describes two business strategies, perhaps you should respond to that.
- throwaway743 4y agoThey're either assuming printed local classifieds were overtaken by a website, or that CL is a site that performed better than the local classifieds website. Not hard to extract, nor worth getting heated about.
- lotsofpulp 4y agoI wrote technology on purpose, to cut through useless information. It is not relevant that “Craigslist” obviated classified ads. The root problem newspapers were solving was a seller being able to provide information to a wide audience of buyers. Technology brought about a better way of solving this problem, so the root problem newspapers were getting paid to solve with classifieds no longer exists. Not having local newspapers/journalism causing problems with the local civic process is a separate problem, that has nothing to do with technology enabling sellers and buyers to reach each other more easily.
- forgetfreeman 4y agoThis is an example of unintended consequences courtesy of paperclip-factory style optimization. Just because an effect is 2nd order doesn't give one leave to claim that it is a separate issue.
- logifail 4y ago> Technology brought about a better way of solving this problem Better for whom? The discoveries of fossil fuels brought about new ways of solving certain problems, with the benefit of hindsight they too were also not without fairly major negative consequences. "Technology" isn't just relentlessly positive.
- forgetfreeman 4y agoThis is a thing that happened in the world and the outcomes of it have been continuously documented for over 20 years now. Regardless of intent the results have been execrable. The complaint is absolutely valid.
- retcore 4y ago>Blaming technology for obviating business models is not a valid complaint. But where your value proposition is created by code your code defines your business model to a critical extent.
- throwaway0x7E6 4y ago>elections what?
- reaperducer 4y ago"Democracy dies in darkness." https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Dies_in_Darkness https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Democracy_Dies_in_Darkness It's sixth-grade Civics class: Without strong local and national press to hold politicians and public figures accountable, the country crumbles.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoThe Fourth Estate is probably a better place to start. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Estate https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fourth_Estate Sadly, it seems even the Fourth Estate doesn't know its name and/or role. Being a parrot and/or sock puppet doesn't qualify (as journalism).
- egberts1 4y agoJust so you know, fourth estate was originally by lawyers, and not printers.
- chiefalchemist 4y agoOriginally? Good to know. Thanks. But also not relevant in the context of the now. "The term Fourth Estate or fourth power refers to the press and news media both in explicit capacity of advocacy and implicit ability to frame political issues.[1]" My point is, we have "journalists" whining about "the democracy" and those same "journalists" aren't aware how badly their profession has already failed said institution / ideal. Imagine pulling up to a fire. Tossing on buckets of flammable liquids. And then with a straight face claim to be a firefighter. It's Orwellian. The lack of self-awareness is not only embarrassing, but it's become down right dangerous.
- 4y ago