3 ms·
I don't understand that kind of thing. Shouldn't a company be allowed to be whomever they want however much they want? If not, why not? I know about the incenti
by Tichy 18y ago
I don't understand that kind of thing. Shouldn't a company be allowed to be whomever they want however much they want? If not, why not? I know about the incentives for risk taking, but what would be the point of creating a law about it? If banks figure out that a particular "bonus construct" is harmful in the long run, they can change it by themselves.
- michael_dorfman 18y agoThe problem is that it is not necessarily harmful to them, but harmful to others (and encourages behavior to that effect.)
- Tichy 18y agoBecause they only care about short term wins? But wouldn't that still damage the companies who employ them? And should it be illegal to seek short term wins?
- iuguy 18y agoThe market would find a way around it. Also bear in mind that a corporation's only purpose is to make money for its shareholders. By eliminating short term wins you're interfering with that area.
- Tichy 18y agoI don't think it should be illegal to seek short term wins. Unless perhaps they qualify as gambling, but even then I am not sure that gambling should be illegal (really don't know).
- michael_dorfman 18y agoHow about gambling with other people's money?
- Tichy 18y agoHow can you get away with gambling with other people's money? I think fraud should be illegal, that is telling people that their investments are 100% secure, when they are not, should be illegal. Other than that, if people invest into a risky company, it is them who are gambling.
- joshwa 18y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_asymmetry http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Information_asymmetry
- anamax 18y ago> The problem is that it is not necessarily harmful to them, but harmful to others (and encourages behavior to that effect.) It's only harmful to others who decide to make the same mistake. It's useful to (different) others who observe and conclude "wow, that's dumb in 3D". Someone else doing something different is a free (to you) learning opportunity. If it works, you can copy. If it doesn't work, you can avoid. There are CEOs who are worth $240M/year in specific circumstances. Laws are unlikely to make the right call but the market will, rewarding folks who get it right and punishing those who get it wrong. What can be better than that?
- michael_dorfman 18y agoBut do those who do it wrong get punished, or do they get to keep the $240M? I've seen a lot of incompetent CEOs walk away with substantial golden parachutes, while employees harmed by their actions got nothing but two week's noticw...
- davidw 18y agoWell, he says that the government shouldn't be setting these sorts of conditions, but that one way or another (shareholder pressure, hopefully), something like this ought to happen, to provide better incentives for management to take a long-term look at things, rather than just trying to jack up profits in the short term.
- sethg 18y agoI have mixed feelings about this issue. On the one hand, I generally feel that if a company's board of directors wants to shoot the company in the foot, then the shareholders, not the government, have the duty to wrestle away the gun. On the other hand, there's a real principal-agent problem here--there are so many layers between the shareholders and the compensation committee, and so many perverse incentives, that it's easy for the directors to make decisions that are not in the shareholders' best interest.