4 ms·
> 1. Any malicious person savvy enough to pull off a crime of interest to the Feds is smart enough to provide a wiped or burner phone to DHS/ICE, and they have
by woodruffw 4y ago
> 1. Any malicious person savvy enough to pull off a crime of interest to the Feds is smart enough to provide a wiped or burner phone to DHS/ICE, and they have to know this. So, what is the point in doing this if not to target law abiding citizens.
This isn't even remotely true. See for example the recent Anom honeypot[1]. Criminals do more or less the same things that ordinary citizens do, and often have strictly worse security practices because they believe "ordinary" things are weaker. This makes them great targets for snake oil.
That being said, I agree with (2). It's simply an unnecessary risk to keep this much data around for this long.
[1]: https://www.vice.com/en/article/v7veg8/anom-app-source-code-operation-trojan-shield-an0m https://www.vice.com/en/article/v7veg8/anom-app-source-code-...
- roenxi 4y agoAlthough grandparent's logic is faulty, I think it does go to an important point. They don't need 15 years warrantless storage of phone data. On anyone, including foreigners. If it takes them 15 years to realise they shouldn't have let someone over the border it is around 14 to 14.995 years too late. The powers these agencies have is far in excesses of what they need to do their jobs, and it is going to be abused. These aren't particularly upstanding people, they're the sort who think DHS/ICE represents an ideal that they are OK with.
- woodruffw 4y agoI agree completely.
- hutzlibu 4y ago"If it takes them 15 years to realise they shouldn't have let someone over the border it is around 14 to 14.995 years too late." Well, hypothetically some old data could be combined with some new data, to not let a potentially terrorist in NOW (or let them in, but supervised). So more data to have is definitely useful for the agencies (if they can analyse it and do not drown in data). And a total surveillance state would be even more effective, but for some reasons people does not want it. Maybe because power abuse is a real thing.
- bushbaba 4y agoI just wish government agencies used data driven decision making vs feelings and intuition more of the time. If there’s data showing a 15 year retention rate is worthwhile. Great. But I have nothing in front of me which states this objectively
- gmadsen 4y agoif there is data suggesting it, it would be classified. the Government isn't in an equal information relationship with the population, nor can it be, to effectively use intel domestically and abroad. just a counter-argument. I am not in favor of this obvious overreach. But I don't need data to tell me that.
- adra 4y agoIf a group had infinite budgets to actually act on this data effectively and if you could actually ever prove that this data was used for said purpose, you're still violating the privacy of 99.999999 of the people who don't commit crimes. I'm all for collecting legitimate warranted wide access information about people with legitimate patterns of criminal behaviour. I'm all about collecting information about financial transactions as one form or another the proceeds of crime are traded into legitimacy in regulated channels (at least for now). I'm not ok collecting "whatever I feel like" for the reason "well because we legally can".
- JAlexoid 4y agoIt's called security theatre. And 15 years is corruption driven, because now you are spending X millions. of taxpayer money to store this data.
- thephyber 4y agoThere are a few reasons why government would want to keep data for that long. Educated guess: playing the odds that currently encrypted data could be broken in the near future. My primary argument isn’t security theater, although I do agree it applies. My argument is that no democracy / republic should assume that every resident/citizen is a potential criminal without some probable cause / particularized suspicion/ significant evidence. The larger the percentage of citizens who experience unjustified searches, the lower the institutional trust level falls. Eventually citizens stop trusting elections, courts, police, etc. then people start massive social panics on the assumption that everything government is corrupt.
- autoexec 4y ago> It's called security theatre. This isn't security theater. Security theater has to be in your face. Security theater is pageantry, but no substance. Security theater is has no impact on your safety, but makes people feel safer by providing the illusion of security. This is substantial, has been being done without most Americans being aware of it, and it doesn't make anyone feel safer, but it still has a huge impact on your safety. It makes you less safe. This is just a gross violation of our constitutional rights.
- wombatpm 4y agoAnd I'm sure they will treat your data with the same regard they do government personell files and applications for security clearance.
- loonster 4y agoNews of the compromise will cause criminals to be more cautious and reduce communication. The entire news article could be fake and it will still be effective.
- artificialLimbs 4y ago>> It's simply an unnecessary risk to keep this much data around for this long. Statement is 3 words too long.
- ROTMetro 4y agoAh, so criminals that get busted follow poor practices that lead to them getting busted. Not sure what this has to do with criminals at large, you know, the ones that do stuff like use a safe phone when traveling abroad.
- woodruffw 4y agoThis is unfalsifiable: are you saying that there's some unquantifiable number of perfectly competent criminals? How would we go about verifying that? On an individual level, I am positive that there are criminals that escape the (not particularly competent) techniques of DHS/CBP. But the GP's claim (that Federal criminals are, as a category, completely above and beyond this kind of enforcement) is just not true.
- gmadsen 4y agoits really not though. Look up estimates of dark net economies. Obviously there is plenty of criminals not getting caught
- woodruffw 4y agoOf course there are. I said that in the last comment. There are two points here: * Estimates of "darknet" economies (and "criminal" economies in general) strongly express preferences for the mostly unfalsifiable LEO hypothesis that there's lots of crime just floating around out there, and they could do so much more about it if we just put up with a little more surveillance, etc. * There's no particular evidence that there's a bimodal distribution between incompetent criminals who get caught and competent criminals who don't. There are probably lots of competent criminals who don't get caught, but there are also probably lots of incompetent ones who don't (and vice versa). The strongest predictor for successful interdiction (especially at borders) isn't competence, but sheer numbers: criminals have to succeed every time, cops only have to succeed once.
- gmadsen 4y agothere is without a doubt a correlation between the significance of criminal enterprise and the rate of getting caught. they may be catching some low level movers with these practices, but not much else above that. The evidence is that there is functioning enterprises in the first place. If captures at the border were a normal distribution of all criminal competency.. that would be destabilizing to a trillion dollar industry.
- nostrademons 4y agoCriminals who get caught do more or less the same things that ordinary citizens do, because the systems setup to catch them assume they'll act like a normal person, because you catch the greatest number of criminals that way. By definition, we have no information about what criminals who don't get caught do, because they're never identified as criminals. That's the point. Selection bias is the most powerful force in the universe.
- makr17 4y agoReminds me of the Stainless Steel Rat, where he is intentionally caught and sent to prison, hoping to further his criminal education. Only to find out he is now incarcerated with all the criminals that weren't smart enough to evade capture...
- godelski 4y agoThis is essentially Pareto resource efficiency for crime. Spending 20% of resources catches 80% of criminals. To catch the other 20% you have to spend exponentially more with exponentially diminishing returns. (This model is too simple though as the environment isn't static and criminals are able to learn and adopt strategies that make your efficiency decay over time)
- goodpoint 4y ago> Criminals do more or less the same things that ordinary citizens do, and often have strictly worse security practices because they believe "ordinary" things are weaker This is a "survivor" bias fallacy.
- woodruffw 4y agoThe null hypothesis is that criminals are humans like us, except that they make money through crime instead of legal employment. Fallacious reasoning here would require us to treat criminals as uniquely invisible or otherwise unlike other humans, which isn't really borne out.
- pessimizer 4y ago"Fallacious" reasoning here would require us to treat criminals as people who have more incentive to hide what they're doing.