3 ms·
> A map of Chicago violent crime is, roughly, a map of redlining. Maybe you should define what redlining means.
by lelanthran 4y ago
> A map of Chicago violent crime is, roughly, a map of redlining.
Maybe you should define what redlining means.
- tptacek 4y agoFor decades, Black families were explicitly forbidden to live in much of Chicago by means of covenants on real estate parcels; those families were concentrated in specific neighborhoods. At the same time, the Home Owners Loan Corporation drew maps grading areas from "desirable" to "hazardous" --- the "hazardous" neighborhoods were demarcated with a red line, hence the name. Lenders refused financial services to any family in the redlined neighborhood.
- ALittleLight 4y agoSo - your theory is that a loan practice which has been illegal since the late 1960's is responsible for the current high and growing crime in Chicago? What's the mechanism for that?
- tptacek 4y agoDo I think 50 years of overt, de jure housing segregation that locked Black families into neighborhoods where they were explicitly not allowed to get home loans had any long term impact on the communities of people that lived there? A little, yeah, yeah I guess I do. I don't think "the late 60s" is the mic drop you think it is; some of us were alive in the late 1960s.
- ALittleLight 4y agoSo what do you think the mechanism is?
- ajl666 4y agoExplain why so much of the rest of the world passed redlined communities. Korea, Israel, Czech, Hungary, Poland, etc etc. The data strongly contradicts your implied thesis. But you think people born in what is one of the wealthiest cities in the world shouldn't be compared to urban Indians or people (like my dad) born in a mud hut.
- rufus_foreman 4y ago>> the Home Owners Loan Corporation drew maps grading areas from "desirable" to "hazardous" --- the "hazardous" neighborhoods were demarcated with a red line, hence the name. Lenders refused financial services to any family in the redlined neighborhood. The HOLC did not use the redlined maps to deny loans. For one thing, they couldn't have, the HOLC was a temporary program intended to deal with the Great Depression and the maps weren't completed until the HOLC had made 90% of the loans it ever made. And second, it did make loans in the redlined areas, and it made a higher percentage of loans to black borrowers than other lenders. The HOLC did share the maps with the explicitly racist FHA, but the FHA didn't use the maps to deny loans. It couldn't have, the FHA insured loans, it didn't make them. It also focused on financing new construction, the redlined areas were already built up. And when it did refuse to finance black borrowers, it appears to have used block by block census data, not the HOLC maps. Outside of the FHA, it doesn't appear that the HOLC shared their maps with private lenders. If you're using the HOLC maps to measure the effect of something, you're measuring something other than the effect of lending decisions. If the HOLC map of Chicago is a map of Chicago violent crime that is correlation rather than causation. There must be other factors that explain the correlation.
- tptacek 4y agoAre you seriously attempting a first-principles argument that redlining didn't actually happen (or, "it happened, but it was just some lines on a map that didn't mean anything")? Because that's the only way I can find to read this comment.
- rufus_foreman 4y agoDepends on what you mean by redlining. Did the HOLC draw maps with red lines on them around neighborhoods where they thought mortgage loans were going to go bad? Yes. Were those maps used to deny loans in the areas with red lines around them? Certainly not by the HOLC, and almost certainly not by the FHA or private lenders. Was there racial discrimination by the HOLC? Maybe. Less than with other mortgage lenders of the day. Was there racial discrimination by the FHA? Yes. Mostly block by block based on census data and New Deal projects that collected data. They did make their own maps, but that's hard to research since those maps were mostly destroyed in the 1960's. The ones that survive don't match the HOLC maps. There's some overlap. Were there racial covenants? Until 1948, yes, that's not redlining though. Do the maps made by the HOLC in the 1930's explain violent crime in Chicago in the 2020's? No. Not at all.
- buggeryorkshire 4y agoNever knew that, thank you - it's horrifying. Mind you here in the UK it wasn't much different in the 70s where I remember signs outside houses for rent stating "no blacks, dogs or Irishmen"
- ajl666 4y agoCorrelation is not causation. And I wouldn't ask you to explain why equally poor zips don't have the same murder rate, since it's obvious you've never considered controlling the data that way.