4 ms·
They've been feeding people crap food for decades. It is easy to google research into how diet is interlinked with things like crime [1]. Shutting down these pl
by latchkey 4y ago
They've been feeding people crap food for decades. It is easy to google research into how diet is interlinked with things like crime [1]. Shutting down these places is likely a net positive.
[1] https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/diet-crime-and-delinquency https://www.ojp.gov/ncjrs/virtual-library/abstracts/diet-cri...
- kortilla 4y agoThere are McDonald's in rich places too.
- serf 4y agoi'm not one to defend mega-corporations, but pretending a company that originated from belting out hamburgers as fast as possible is supposed to be doing social-positive humanitarian work is ridiculous. also, just to entertain this notion, fast food is interlinked with poverty and substandard living conditions, too -- most folks tend to think that rather than being the cause of these conditions that fast food is simply the available option. It's a special kind of privileged to be able to yell "Shut these places down that serve unhealthy food." without first securing healthy food for those in need. Let's first think about what happens when the only food source available to certain groups gets regulated out of existence. I'm not saying that they don't hold a level of responsibility -- what I AM saying is that no food is worse than bad food.
- blowski 4y agoThese two positions seem a bit extreme. 1. Shut down McDonalds! 2. But then poor people will starve to death! I imagine there’s a solution somewhere in the middle. Perhaps McDonalds is taxed higher, banned from advertising. Subsidies are pushed for healthier lifestyles in those neighbourhoods.
- drekk 4y agoOr, and I'm just entirely spitballing here, we cut out all the middlemen and provide food at dispensaries for people at no cost? The US produces enough food to feed 10 billion people. Most of it is animal feed or gets landfilled. 1 in 5 children are food insecure on the wealthiest nation in the history of this planet. It's an absolute disgrace and the children getting permanent learning disabilities due to malnutrition don't have decades for the free market to humanely allocate resources (something it's entirely incapable of doing unforced). McDonalds has employees qualifying for food stamps. On top of that we give them tax incentives for "creating jobs" as they spend all their R&D trying to maximize their food's "craveability" (addictiveness). More to the point we've made it illegal for food companies to not optimize for that because they've have a fiduciary responsibility to the shareholders. It's not a money problem. Heck, we could solve global poverty with <5% of "first world" GDP. It's an incentives problem. There's no incentive to feed Americans healthy food. There's not even an incentive to feed Americans. Which is why you get headlines like: https://apnews.com/article/portland-storms-oregon-4eebd2cd2f1b9f798667994bc871a647 https://apnews.com/article/portland-storms-oregon-4eebd2cd2f...
- hackerlight 4y agoThe GP is right about the problem, but wrong about the solution. Part of the reason healthy foods are more expensive is indirectly due to the junk foods industry, which has caused our supply chains to be tightly optimized around provision of unhealthy foods. It also likely causes crime. Metabolic syndrome -> psychiatric conditions && debt to pay for insulin && lost productivity --> crime. What the GP is wrong about is the solution. We're trapped in a bad local optima here. Just immediately shutting down fast food isn't an exhaustive solution, because you suck jobs out of the local areas and it takes time for the supply chains to reoptimize around healthy food. Some kind of gradual systemic change over multiple decades is needed.
- latchkey 4y ago> Just immediately shutting down fast food isn't an exhaustive solution, because you suck jobs out of the local areas and it takes time for the supply chains to reoptimize around healthy food. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie%27s_School_Dinners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie%27s_School_Dinners https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Oliver%27s_Food_Revolution https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jamie_Oliver%27s_Food_Revoluti...
- latchkey 4y ago> It's a special kind of privileged to be able to yell "Shut these places down that serve unhealthy food." without first securing healthy food for those in need. Special kind of privileged? I moved from the Bay Area to Vietnam. I've lived and traveled all around SE Asia for many years. I've seen the poorest of the poor, in the most remote places possible. I've eaten the same food. One thing they have going for them is that food is inexpensive and food is available. It is also not fast food. It is possible to feed people food that isn't crap McDonalds. The concept that it is the only thing available, is completely manufactured. The fact that people give up production of good food, for this crap, because it is cheap and easy, is a big part of the problem.
- barrysteve 4y agoRegulate the cheapest food. Violent crime and food quality rules can be grasped by the gov.
- junofan 4y agoHaven’t we clamped down on the little people enough?
- hackerlight 4y agoIs stopping Purdue Pharma from selling life-destroying opiates "clamping down on little people"? I'd say no. Is alcohol and marijuana prohibition "clamping down on little people"? I'd say yes. Clearly there are shades of grey here that need to be worked out and there's no substitute for a first principles analysis of each case on its own merits. If you are worried about the unintended consequences of prohibition, then there are many other avenues without that downside, such as taxing fast food and using that revenue to subsidize healthy food, or mandatory packaging labels, or public health education efforts.
- barrysteve 4y agoI would hope removing food that is causing violent crime, is a net positive enough that the little people would prefer it. Of course there is no incentive to hurt the poor, the debate is over what is the correct way of helping them. Saving a few bucks on a big mac meal, in exchange for their health and crime, may not be the best way forward. From a non-us perspective it's a bit odd that a CEO has to point out that violent crime is happening too much, that it's bad and that something should be done about it. That's the gov's job?
- odessacubbage 4y agowhen you are very poor, meals are uncertain and every dollar counts, saving a few bucks on a big mac is actually a pretty big deal. not to mention mcdonalds are open much later than homeless shelters or soup kitchens, safer too. being able to get warm and be fed for low cost is something easy to take for granted but when you have nothing it really means a lot.