5 ms·
Patagonia billionaire who gave up company skirts $700M tax hit
- alephu5 4y agoOn a moral level I think it's fair to give them a tax break on this, since they're effectively donating all future company profits to global society through the foundations.
- eganist 4y agoIt's not even a tax break. The headline is basically shaming them for skipping 700 million in taxes by not selling the company..... .....except since they're not selling the company, they're also likewise not earning a net 2.3bln in income. Hence: ridiculous. It's one of the most absurd articles to ever come out of Bloomberg, and in fact it's so bad that I'd instead rather see meaningful dialog about people with the means exerting long lasting influence beyond death. The tax argument presented here is entirely contrived. I'd likewise prefer seeing a debate around whether a 501c4 is enough to achieve the stated goals around influencing climate change policy and whether the option of political contributions is worthwhile compared to a 501c3, for instance. Any discussion stemming from the current "skirts $700m in taxes" headline is bunk.
- utucuro 4y agoI think this is a very meaningful article. Without knowing anything else about Bloomberg, it allows the reader to see just how bad the quality of their content is.
- koheripbal 4y agoTo be honest, since he's giving the money to a non-profit that he owns, we have no idea what the money will be used for. We take his word that it will be used for Climate Change. If he takes $1MM to donate to Harvard to secure a seat for each his children/grandchildren, then that's legal. If he uses it to host parties for the wealthy to "raise awareness", then that's legal. If he uses it to setup hotels, flights, IT servers, consultants, etc, then that's all legal. If he runs for office and uses the money for his campaign, that's all legal. Moreover, if he gets into office he can now accept donations to his foundation in order to influence policy/laws without much question. ...and for a myriad of other quasi-personal uses, it's basically untraceable as non-profits have low financial reporting requirements. I am very skeptical of these personally owned family "Foundations".
- ethanbond 4y ago> guy does good thing > but look… he could’ve done bad thing We have every reason to believe Yvon and co. will be handling this responsibly and no reason to believe they will not be.
- itsdrewmiller 4y ago>If he runs for office and uses the money for his campaign, that's all legal. This would definitely not be legal.
- eganist 4y agoIt possibly could be given that the nonprofit is structured as a 501c4 (though not primarily or directly), but it's more likely that this was done to enable lobbying as a primary activity. https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/other-non-profits/social-welfare-organizations https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/other-non-profits/...
- karaterobot 4y agohttps://archive.ph/ifEzF https://archive.ph/ifEzF
- refurb 4y agoPretty clear they have an amazing PR department that spun this as nothing more than an altruistic move.
- smt88 4y agoWhat more is it, exactly? He and his family have billions fewer dollars. Avoiding the $700M tax doesn't suddenly net them billions. The money is still gone from their family. It was an altruistic move that was also done in a way that avoided taxes.
- refurb 4y ago"Still, the moves mean Chouinard won’t have to pay the federal capital gains taxes he would have owed had he sold the company, an option he said was under consideration. On a $3 billion sale, that bill could be more than $700 million. It also helps Chouinard avoid the US estate and gift tax, which is a 40% levy on large fortunes when they’re transferred to heirs." Rather than an altruistic play, it was an attempt to avoid taxes and keep the company under control of the family. Seems like others use this channel too.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sixo 4y agoWhy do people keep saying this. They keep some control but they don't keep ownership. It's not like they sold the company and saved 700M on the deal... they still gave away their stake in the company. Why are people trying to spin this as a tax scheme?
- barry-cotter 4y agoSome people hate the idea that other people are both more accomplished than them and morally better than them. Others hate those individually but the combination of accomplishment, moral worth and wealth really drives a lot of people to hatred.
- jelliclesfarm 4y agoHeavy clickbait to generate outrage. The Chouinards are the only ones who actually acted in any real meaningful way towards the Giving Pledge. A better article that is more about the facts: https://www-nytimes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.nytimes.com/2022/09/14/climate/patagonia-climate-philanthropy-chouinard.amp.html https://www-nytimes-com.cdn.ampproject.org/c/s/www.nytimes.c... [..]The Chouinards then donated the other 98 percent of Patagonia, its common shares, to a newly established nonprofit organization called the Holdfast Collective, which will now be the recipient of all the company’s profits and use the funds to combat climate change. Because the Holdfast Collective is a 501(c)(4), which allows it to make unlimited political contributions, the family received no tax benefit for its donation. [..] “There was a meaningful cost to them doing it, but it was a cost they were willing to bear to ensure that this company stays true to their principles,” said Dan Mosley, a partner at BDT & Co., a merchant bank that works with ultrawealthy individuals including Warren Buffett, and who helped Patagonia design the new structure. “And they didn’t get a charitable deduction for it. There is no tax benefit here whatsoever.” [..] “This family is a way outlier when you consider that most billionaires give only a tiny fraction of their net worth away every year,” said David Callahan, founder of the website Inside Philanthropy. “Even those who have signed the Giving Pledge don’t give away that much, and tend to get richer every year,” Mr. Callahan added, referring to the commitment by hundreds of billionaires to give away the bulk of their fortunes.[..]
- i_am_jl 4y agoYvon is a champion. He once talked about discovering that he was in Forbes magazine which had described as a billionaire, something he said "Really, really pissed him off."
- jollybean 4y agoThere's not much of a story here. He's making it a non-profit effectively, so he's not going to be personally getting income, and therefore no tax. That the family controls the non-profit is one thing, but they're not going to financially benefit from it in a significant way. I mean, their airfare and hotels are going to be paid forever though ... This is just taxes in a straight forward way: profit/income = tax, otherwise not. His kids aren't getting the assets, so no generational tax. It's just straightforward as one should expect it to be for the most part.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- throwaway22032 4y agoLol. Yeah, that's how it works. Where would the money come from to pay a tax on something given away? There is no profit, there is only loss.
- yucky 4y agoThis is how the wealthy avoid estate taxes. Move it to a non-profit controlled by your heirs. The non-profit now provides a never ending piggy bank for said heirs.
- missedthecue 4y agoThey'd be better off just eating the tax hit. $250k salaries for sitting on a board of trustees is nice, but it ain't nothing like a $500 million inheritance
- travisporter 4y agoSee also: the more you spend, the more you save!
- peanut_worm 4y agoWhat a dumb article