3 ms·
I largely agree with what you said, but that 80% capacity factor is rather nuanced. Nuclear’s capacity factor varies quite a bit depending on the local grid.
by Retric 4y ago
I largely agree with what you said, but that 80% capacity factor is rather nuanced.
Nuclear’s capacity factor varies quite a bit depending on the local grid. France’s averaged below 70% while US nuclear reactor’s where generally over 90% largely due to the local energy mix. Solar is running into similar issues as it scales, but they both can greatly benefit from energy storage. The issue is nuclear power is so expensive it makes energy storage less appealing.
So, if we are talking about a potential grid with 30% nuclear 10% hydro and the rest solar and wind then nuclear could have a 90+% capacity factor and mostly be offline in the spring and fall when seasonal demand is low. Unfortunately that means Nuclear isn’t going to scale and help with global warming. On the other hand if you want a 90% nuclear 10% hydro grid then nuclear is going to have something like a 40% capacity factor without a great deal of energy storage.
- Schroedingersat 4y agoIn the context of "turn the most gas and coal plants off per dollar ASAP", I think 80% is pretty reasonable. Especially when you include things like plants that were paid for but never opened and various safety shutdowns. Similarly 25-30% for solar and 60% for wind with them being anticorrelated enough that you can call an equal mix ~40% over all. The other benefit is solar+wind incentivises storage development in a way that nuclear does not. Cost-wise, for many applications it's optimal to overbuild by a factor of 2 or 3 just to get energy in the sides of the energy curve. This results in energy that has been paid for, and can be turned on or off in milliseconds but has no value at 11am. Many storage technologies become viable at $10-20/MWh that need further development to be viable at higher price.
- Retric 4y agoThat’s a reasonable point, but I think it’s still overestimating the value of adding new nuclear power plants when you already have significant nuclear capacity. It’s clear the average capacity factor falls when you add more nuclear power. In other words rather than looking at the average capacity factor as being X%, you need to consider how much the average capacity factor falls with each additional reactor and then calculate what the effective capacity factor of that reactor must have been to hit the new average. To illiterate if 10GW averages to 80% and 11GW averages to 79% then the 11th GW must have effectively been 69%, because (80 * 10 + 69) / 11 = 79.