6 ms·
YouTube ads appear to be ramping up, with as many as 10 unskippable ads
- president 4y agoI still remember YouTube ramping up ads starting at the beginning of lockdowns in 2020. It was the first time I was seeing double unskippable ads and 14 second ads.
- db48x 4y agoWhy does anyone put up with ads? Install uBlock Origin → no ads. Also, if you install SponsorBlock then at least for popular videos you will probably never see an ad from a video creator either. You can even have it skip self–promotional segments (Subscribe Now!), repetitive animations and intro sequences, credits, previews, etc.
- Nas808 4y agoThat works well on a desktop browser, but the YouTube ads are still a problem on iOS and other platforms like smart TVS, Roku or Chromecast/Google TV.
- Snuupy 4y agosmarttubenext for Google TV
- db48x 4y agoI don’t have much sympathy. When you bought those you gave up your ability to run your own software on them. That’s really why they sell them.
- impulser_ 4y agoYou could just buy YouTube premium. Cancel Spotify, buy YouTube premium. Get both ad free videos and music on the same platform.
- UpstandingUser 4y agoOr I could rip my legally purchased* CDs and give the finger to the leeches and rent seekers that fuck us almost as hard as they do the artists. Yes I support corporate genocide. * lol
- colinmhayes 4y agoyoutube premium is not a spotify replacement. Youtube is in no way built to be a music playback app.
- themelodyfarm 4y ago“music playback app”? YouTube is at least as good as the vinyl record player. It is also the sole location for countless live audio/video recordings of musical performance. It works fine as a “music playback app” and is, to emphasize, an _awesome_ and convenient resource of live music performance.
- Crash0v3rid3 4y agoThat's why every YouTube premium subscription includes YouTube music which is a decent Spotify replacement.
- vgeek 4y agoPihole with ad blocking or an OpenWRT (or really any router) router with ad blocking DNS is an alternative.
- Nas808 4y agoThe YouTube ads defeat DNS sinkholes because the ads are served from the same domain(s) as the content.
- vgeek 4y agoCan they evade uBo, too? I had a stretch where I was getting them in FF with uBo & Privacy badger, even after updating all rules, but then they started being blocked again on their own.
- colinmhayes 4y agoiOS can do DNS adblocking natively. https://adguard.com/en/blog/encrypted-dns-ios-14.html https://adguard.com/en/blog/encrypted-dns-ios-14.html Doesn't work for youtube because they're serving the ads first party.
- christophilus 4y ago> YouTube ads are still a problem on iOS Not for me. (Typed from iOS + Brave.)
- AdamJacobMuller 4y agohttps://smarttubenext.com/ https://smarttubenext.com/ on Android TV (I use an nvidia shield) works great. In-video youtube sponsors were some of the last advertising I was exposed to. Glad to be rid of them.
- timbit42 4y agoOn Android you can use Firefox with Ublock Origin. I wish SponsorBlock was available though. The NewPipe Android app is another option and there is a fork that includes SponsorBlock: https://github.com/polymorphicshade/NewPipe/releases https://github.com/polymorphicshade/NewPipe/releases
- silvertaza 4y agoIt's probably apt to ask yourself what sort of revenue model you prefer to support for the value provided. YouTube is a rare case where they offer multiple options.
- db48x 4y agoMeh. Most videos on the web are crap. Having advertising makes some kinds of crap worse. And even if all advertising revenue went away, enthusiasts will always post videos for fun. In fact most videos don’t earn any significant advertising revenue. Personally advertising is a high cost to myself that I am not willing to pay. I even avoid restaurants that have televisions, or that play a radio station instead of buying music that has no advertising in it. (I also frequent a couple of places that are willing to leave the music off for me, at least early in the day before the lunch rush, and one that doesn’t play music at all. That’s a different story though.)
- space_fountain 4y agoThe videos that don’t make money are the unpopular ones. Are they the ones you watch? Have you listened to the content creators you do consume and what they have to say about doing it for the joy of it all
- db48x 4y ago> The videos that don’t make money are the unpopular ones. I disagree with that. A selection of channels that I watch regularly enough: The Spiffing Brit doesn’t do sponsorships, and his videos are quite popular (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRHXUZ0BxbkU2MYZgsuFgkQ/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCRHXUZ0BxbkU2MYZgsuFgkQ/vid...). This Old Tony (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9rlWu9KWe8 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W9rlWu9KWe8) is not quite as popular, if you count popularity by video views, but still very popular and no sponsorships. What about Ben Eater? (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_koa00MBLg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=g_koa00MBLg) He is exactly the kind of enthusiast who would make amazing videos even if all advertising disappeared. Ross Whatshisname of Accursed Farms (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJ6KZTTnkE-s2XFJJmoTAkw/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCJ6KZTTnkE-s2XFJJmoTAkw/vid...) does an extremely in–depth review of a video game about once a month, and doesn’t do sponsorships. He gets 200k–500k views on every review, which is very popular by any measure. Posy (https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmEmX_jw_pRp5UbAdzkZq-g/videos https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCmEmX_jw_pRp5UbAdzkZq-g/vid...) is another enthusiast who makes videos for the sheer delight of it and whose videos are quite popular. If you haven’t watched his videos about LCD displays then you haven’t lived. I agree that truly unpopular videos with a dozen views will never make money, by advertising or otherwise. But the converse is not true; as I have demonstrated, there are plenty of popular videos that don’t bother to try to make money by sponsorships. You know every single one of those is turning down a VPN company every week of the year though.
- wildrhythms 4y agoYears ago I got my not-so-tech-savvy parents using an ad blocker on their laptop, and recently when I upgraded them to a new device they briefly experienced the internet without an ad blocker and thought something was wrong with their brand new computer. Once you experience the digital landscape with ads blocked, you quickly realize the mindblowing amount of advertising people are subjected to thru traditional media. I always wonder how much energy we're collectively wasting by sending people ads that they don't want to see, or will be blocked and never seen at all. What a waste
- freediver 4y agoMost of internet users are not tech savvy. And they overwhelmingly end up paying the "ad tax" imposed on the web.
- emsy 4y agoI already spend much less time on YT since they butchered their recommendations. Now I‘ll think twice before clicking on a video, so I very much welcome this change. Just as you can watch incredible videos about every topic on YouTube, you can waste hours watching junk. To me, this change is a great incentive not to do the latter.
- wildrhythms 4y agoI don't have this problem with my suggestions, but that's because I deliberately and constantly prune bad suggestions with the "Not interested" option. Maybe it's a placebo, but since starting that crusade I've found my recommendations to be very topical and relevant for me. I also make sure I open any videos that might 'pollute' my suggestions in a private browsing window.
- bombcar 4y agoThe private window is very important part of the tactic.
- kelnos 4y agoThen pay for YT Premium so you don't have ads. Look, I hate ads. I really do. You can pry uBlock Origin from my cold, dead fingers. But the thing is, sites and creators and whatnot still often choose ads as a way to fund the things they create. If they're pushing ads at you over a medium where you have control (there's a reason why a web browser is a "user agent"), then I think you totally have the right to choose what your user agent does and does not fetch from the remote server. (And I believe uBO does work for YouTube ads?) But if you're consuming something through a medium where you don't have full control -- such as the YouTube mobile app -- then you get what you get. If the ads are onerously bad enough, and people don't want to pay to remove ads, then fewer people will use YT and Google will dial it back. But there's always the paid option. I get that many of us don't like ads -- again, I don't either -- and don't like a choice being made for us as to how we're going to "pay" for content online. But this isn't the case here: Google offers an ad-free paid experience. If you get enough value out of YouTube, maybe you should just pay for it. If you don't want to (or can't), then ads (or blocking) it is. Or just don't use it... vote with your feet.
- throw_a_grenade 4y agoMay I introduce you to NewPipe, an excellent client for Android, and https://piped.kavin.rocks/ https://piped.kavin.rocks/ on desktop/web? I disagree with the statement that this is " a medium where you don't have full control" — after all those are my devices and I like them to be my (user) agents, not some thurd (sic) party.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- codegladiator 4y ago> But there's always the paid option. I am sure ads will come to paid option too soon so enjoy while it lasts with truly ad free paid option.
- rtpg 4y agoYou’re “sure”? I mean it’s kinda the whole point of the product, and from what has been said in trade articles the revenue from premium is much higher than the ad revenue it’s replacing. People of course do stupid things, but the information I saw made it sound like there’s no question, premium is better for Youtube
- goalieca 4y agoWhat bothers me is that YouTube kids is now showing ads.
- blaiseofglory 4y agoAdult ads... My 4yo doesn't need to see a 50 Shades trailer.
- MonkeyMalarky 4y agoSomehow I think that's less bad than the ads for mobile games..
- postalrat 4y agoAll that work youtube did to get content creators to create ad friendly content then google goes ahead and pumps out content unfriendly ads.
- pram 4y agoYes I ended up paying for a YouTube sub because of my kids. I just use the app built into my LG tv and it doesn’t have an ad blocker. It’s pretty much a necessity if you’re playing one of those 60 minute loops of peppa pig or whatever.
- brokenmachine 4y agoRootmytv - Homebrew Channel - Youtube Adfree.
- rekabis 4y ago…Ads? On YouTube? _confused look_ I haven’t seen an ad on the Internet in nearly 20 years, ever since the first adblocker got released for Phoenix in 2003 (what became Firebird, then Firefox).
- nostromo 4y agoYouTube is mostly consumed on mobile and in their app where adblocking is more difficult.
- bdw5204 4y agoBrave for both iOS and Android automatically blocks YouTube ads.
- timbit42 4y agoOn Android you can also use Firefox with Ublock Origin or the NewPipe app which removes the ads. If you want SponsorBlock, there is a fork of NewPipe with SponsorBlock included: https://github.com/polymorphicshade/NewPipe/releases https://github.com/polymorphicshade/NewPipe/releases
- antonymy 4y agoSame. I honestly forget it has ads since installing firefox followed by ublock origin are the first two things I do on any computer I'm going to be using extensively. Over the years with different adblockers and browsers, some ads have squeaked through, but on the whole I've lived ad-free on the internet for almost two decades as well.
- sitzkrieg 4y agoyea sure, we'll all play along with this :)
- probably_wrong 4y agoI'm sure there are ads you've seen on YouTube, they just look slightly different to what you have in mind. But first, this comment wouldn't be possible without Deutsche Bahn, the n°1 train provider in Germany. If you go to their website right now with promo code "probably_wrong" you get extra delay on your next trip. If you're going to be late, be late with Deutsche Bahn. Remember: promo code, free delay. Now, back to our comment. YouTube is full of ads, the only difference being who gets the money from them. Is one of the reasons why some people here don't want to pay for it - you get less ads, but not ad-free.
- Aachen 4y agoI've been using YouTube less because of ads. Partially consciously after a set of two long ads to send the message that this harms engagement, partially I just get annoyed and stay away naturally. If they're ramping it up.... crap. It's not like there's an alternative and I'm not that fond of making the monopolist more entrenched by giving google, of all companies, more money in a subscription and tying the account to a real-world identity, also when considering all the other stuff google already collect on me. (I've tried Nebula and CuriosityStream which many creators I watch constantly promote(d). Was done with the interesting content in one week and its size means there's very little fresh material, and also it doesn't run on the tv which I could work around with extra hardware if it were amazing but...)
- nomel 4y agoAn alternative is, of course, YouTube Premium. Their pricing always seemed very high to me, but now I wonder if it was meant to be in the context of this number of ads.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Aachen 4y agoYeah I realized that I should add why that seems even worse to me, so I edited that in. To elaborate a little, I pay for Spotify, Netflix, F-Droid, OsmAnd, Simple Mobile Tools, FairEmail, K9, Internet Archive, and other software and services I use.... independent companies and creators that don't already track me to hell. Giving money to google would be out of necessity, not to help them strengthen their position if I can avoid it. If YouTube spins off as an independent firm where you can have an account that has independent guidelines and everything, I'd sign up in a heartbeat. They make a good product and have good content, the only downside is that there's zero competition but that's not a deal breaker by itself.
- christophilus 4y agoI’m in the same boat. I watch YouTube via Brave or uBlock + Firefox. If YouTube spun out of Google, I’d pay for premium. I get a lot of value out of it. I just can’t bring myself to pay Google for anything. I know it’s not really rational, and in a way, ad-blockers feel a little like piracy. But it’s where I am.
- nostromo 4y agoIf you want to watch YouTube without ads on your phone, go to the website using the Brave browser -- it works perfectly.
- christophilus 4y agoNot only that, but you can download the videos for offline viewing / listening.
- Scottn1 4y agoOrion Browser on iOS as well blocks YT ads for me. The problem though with ad-tech is while browsers/uBO may work currently, it is a cat/mouse game and the big boys will win with their huge budgets and genius developers. Niche browsers like Brave/Orion and uBO extension are already probably getting to the point of being overwhelmed by constant breakage of YT/Twitch/Etc ad blocking.
- binkHN 4y agoI pay for YouTube Premium, and happily so. There’s A LOT of great content there—probably even better content than Netflix. And you want to know what else? While it’s just okay, it includes ad-free music from YouTube Music. So, win, win? Until someone comes out with a better offer, I’ll continue to give more money to Google.
- CAPSLOCKSSTUCK 4y agoEvery time this subject comes up, the comments are filled with people who feel entitled to watch YouTube for free (not willing to pay in attention or in hard currency). "If you don't watch to pay for it or watch ads, don't use the service" just gets ignored, and people post ridiculous replies like "lol I just block all ads" . . . it's as if YouTube is as necessary to their survival as water. It's also great because it demonstrates how full of BS many of the "if I had a choice to pay for the <ad-supported thing> I would" crowd are . . . not all, of course, but I bet there's a sizeable intersection between the two categories.
- 8note 4y agoYouTube is a monopoly, and either needs to be regulated as a utility or broken up. Nit: YouTube offers no such service. You will still see ads if you pay for YouTube premium, because YouTube policgies incentivize creators to put ads and sponsorships in the video
- PenguinCoder 4y agoLoL. Not in any way, shape, or form. INTERNET ACCESS can be seen as and drastically needs regulation as a public utility. One specific site via that access; no.
- ssharp 4y agoThe solution to this is $11.99 a month. The way consumers value things is insane to me. People will fork over $12 on DoorDash delivery fees, an overpriced drink, a coffee, etc. but to remove ads for access to an enormous vault of content that provides endless value, NEVER!!!
- alberth 4y agoCable TV started that way. No ads because you paid $x/month.
- plebianRube 4y agoSo did Netflix and Amazon Prime.
- lesuorac 4y ago> Cable TV started that way. No ads because you paid $x/month [Citation Needed] https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-invaded-by-commercials.html#:~:text=Although%20cable%20television%20was%20never,by%20viewers'%20monthly%20subscription%20fees https://www.nytimes.com/1981/07/26/arts/will-cable-tv-be-inv....
- postalrat 4y agoEveryone starts paying them 11.99 or whatever and they will still start adding ads. Gotta keep the revenue charts pointing up for the investors.
- throw_a_grenade 4y agoWhere does it say paying actually will remove ads, and if it is, how long it will be until google will change their mind?
- jonas21 4y agoIt says so right on the landing page, https://www.youtube.com/premium https://www.youtube.com/premium. > YouTube and YouTube Music ad-free, offline, and in the background It amazes me that when it's pointed out that you can easily buy an ad-free experience, people immediately double down on some hypothetical situation where you can't.
- sul_tasto 4y agoIf google would agree to stop tracking me and selling my data, I would be willing to stop blocking ads. As it is, I don’t see why I should pay twice.
- jsnell 4y agoThey already don't sell your data. The other economic value that "tracking" data could have is to show you better targeted ads. But when you block the ads, that potential value is irrelevant. So you're choosing to not pay at all, "paying twice" has nothing to do with it. Not that there is anything wrong with that. You have the opportunity to take something for nothing, and seized it. But at least be honest about your motivations.
- goodSteveramos 4y agoMosquitos dont sell your blood
- sul_tasto 4y agoTechnically you’re right. They collect data on me and my behavior and then sell access to my screen real estate in an abstracted way. I am more than willing to pay for services in exchange for being exempted from adsense, and from being tracked and profiled across the net. But I’m going to fight back when I’m the product. Youtube premium doesn’t offer that option- they will continue to collect data on my behavior even if they don’t show me advertising, because they don’t want to make public the true nature of the exchange.
- jsnell 4y agoDiscussed yesterday: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32835071 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32835071
- tristor 4y agoThere's a lot of people here who act like the only ones annoyed by this are people who refuse to pay for YouTube premium. But here's the thing... /I/ do pay for YouTube premium, and I still find this annoying. Here's why: I'm not always logged into my personal Google account on a device, and I don't necessarily want to log in on some devices to my personal Google account, but I still need or want to use YouTube. YouTube /is/ a wealth of information, and it's worth paying for, but that wealth of information often extends into topics which are, for instance, relevant in the workplace, but I am not going to login to my personal account on a work device. Increased ads affect everyone, not just people who don't pay, paying only limits how it affects you in /some/ ways, but not completely.
- alxmrs 4y agoIn cases like these, I use multiple personas in Chrome (I think Firefox has user profiles) so I can log into my personal accounts on my work computer while still keeping everything compartmentalized.
- tristor 4y agoI'm glad that works for you, but I follow a strict policy of separation between work and personal accounts and technology in order to support a defense of my open source work against any claims from current/past employers regarding IP assignment. I have a completely physically separated space, network, and internet connection specifically for work usage and there is no account or physical crossover between work and personal computing. I /never/ login to personal accounts from a work device, and I never will, browser personas is not a sufficient protection.
- hamiltonians 4y ago3rd world country proxy, linux... get creative
- MiguelX413 4y agoYouTube won't do this. They're only trying it.
- bombcar 4y agoYouTube won’t do this. They’re only trying doing it. For fun.
- MiguelX413 4y agoNot everything that is a/b tested sticks around.
- tssva 4y agoIt has been so long since I've seen a YouTube ad I forget it has them. I pay my $7.99 a month and never see an ad.
- wetpaws 4y agoI pay $0.00 and have not seen them in decades.
- Markoff 4y agoI use ublock origin on desktop/mobile (Vivaldi and Kiwi) and don't see any ads, I use SmartTubeNext on my Android TV and don't see any ads, so not sure how are they unskippable, if I don't even see them
- rcarmo 4y agoWell, that’s just great news after they completely botched HDR handling on the AppleTV client (it now flickers back and forth several times between display modes on my TV, so I miss the first queen seconds of everything).
- incomingpain 4y agoI have been noticing I haven't been watching youtube much lately. This will certainly be a final nail in the coffin to get me to stop watching youtube. Which I figure is a great thing. So bring this on!
- leobg 4y agoYouTube in 2006: “Hey everybody, upload your videos, so everyone can watch them for free!” YouTube in 2022: “Hey everybody, if you want to watch everyone’s videos, you gotta watch 10 ads first or pay us money!”
- rdsnsca 4y agoOrion, on macOS, blocks all YouTube ads with just the builtin ad blocked.