2 ms·
> At best, you're made RCV/IRV with extra steps I'd argue that every single word in this small claim is wrong. Scoring isn't equivalent to ranking unless the
by godelski 4y ago
> At best, you're made RCV/IRV with extra steps
I'd argue that every single word in this small claim is wrong.
Scoring isn't equivalent to ranking unless the conditions are that you cannot score two candidates the same and that you must fill in every possible score vale (i.e. rank). Neither of these conditions are true for any cardinal system. You can score candidates the same and you can score candidates with variable distances (e.g. 5,3,2,1. Note there is no 4). This has different embedding properties. You actually can express more information in cardinal this way.
Second, run-off voting is much more complicated. Cardinal systems are determined by argmax of a reduce-sum. Which is trivially parallelizable and only requires a singular election. Run-offs require multi-elections. Even in simple cases like this one, there were 2 elections (and that's with 3 candidates!). This doesn't scale well either.