3 ms·
Yeah, this is called "bullet voting" (for those that don't know). It is often brought up as a killer strategy to cardinal systems but it really isn't that bad.
by godelski 4y ago
Yeah, this is called "bullet voting" (for those that don't know). It is often brought up as a killer strategy to cardinal systems but it really isn't that bad. No system is immune to strategies and I think people just find one strategy and disregard a system because they found a flaw. Social choice is over constrained. There are trade-offs and local optimizations but no global optimization. We can't talk about voting systems without acknowledging this point.
To be clear, bullet voting in Score is equivalent to Approval Voting. AV still has a lot of advantages over Runoff Voting.
> It's likely that voters just didn't read the directions
This is actually a point (that I don't bring up much because it is minor) that I prefer cardinal over ranked. It is much easier to mess up a ranked ballot than cardinal. Give the same score to multiple candidates? No problem. In a ranked ballot you have issues and no good resolutions (toss ballot, flip a coin on preference and then reorder? Both of which can be called voter manipulation, despite them not really being). These issues arise more as the system scales too.
The big killer to me (besides the information embedding) is the tallying (backend that voters don't see). Cardinal systems are just an argmax reduce-sum (trivially parallelizable). Trivial to calculate and do statistical samples/verification on. This is a lot harder with run-off systems. The multi-elections required actually takes a lot of man power. Just think about how recounts like Arizona would happen under Cardinal vs Ordinal. This is something people really have to consider when accounting for voting systems. There is a front end and back end but most people argue front end + a few cherry picked strategies.