6 ms·
I don't get the hubbub around ordinal voting. It has a serious embedding problem that is solved in cardinal systems. The problem is that by ranking candidates
by godelski 4y ago
I don't get the hubbub around ordinal voting. It has a serious embedding problem that is solved in cardinal systems.
The problem is that by ranking candidates the distance between two candidates is identically spaced. Instead by scoring candidates you are better able to express this distance (even in simple systems like approval). This quickly resolves issues like the favorite betrayer (strong spoiler effect) and resolves some strategy issues (no system is immune to all strategies fwiw). Plus you get a much easier to calculate election (`argmax([candidate.sum() for candidate in candidate_list])`, which also has nice sampling properties for winner estimates and verification). Aren't these the systems we want to be using? I mean could you imagine the Arizona recount with an ordinal system? Or RP or Schultz? What a disaster that would have been.
- JumpCrisscross 4y ago> by scoring candidates you are better able to express this distance We have no cultural context for this distance. Until that can be harmonized, such systems are DOA.
- godelski 4y agoThat distance is voter preference. Which I think we have a pretty clear cultural context of.
- yyyk 4y agoCardinal voting systems ask for information few voters really have, and we get GIGO. We arguably shouldn't want to receive the cardinal info if they did have it because that mainly helps ultra-partisan voters. They allow candidates to improve their position if there's a more extreme candidate to their side, because voters may still want to express the ordinal preference.
- godelski 4y ago> Cardinal voting systems ask for information few voters really have Voters don't know which candidates they prefer? If you really believe this (in the strong sense, not the weak sense) then I think you have to throw out voting all together. Maybe I'm missing your point? > voters may still want to express the ordinal preference. This is a feature, not a bug. Cardinal systems can capture ordinal preference but ordinal systems can't capture cardinal preference. (obviously not exactly)
- yyyk 4y ago>Voters don't know which candidates they prefer? They know which candidates they prefer, they don't have a score for it. One voter may prefer A over B and B over C. There's an argument to give A 10.0 and C 0.0 (it's not the only way to allocate, but I'll grant it for the sake of argument). What is B's score however? Most voters do not have an answer. The only people who will have an answer are ultra-ideological voters who are willing to grade every legislative vote. Not sure this is what we want to encourage. >This is a feature, not a bug. Cardinal systems can capture ordinal preference This isn't entirely true. Let's give an American example. Say the candidates in 2024 are Biden, Romney and Trump. For the sake of argument, your preference is Biden > Romney > Trump. So you give Biden 10.0, Trump 0.0, and for Romney, say 1.0. It's possible your 1.0 vote gives Romney the election. Now, if only Biden and Romney ran, you'd have given 10.0 and 0.0 respectively. So Romney gains by having Trump run despite no change in the ordinal preference.
- godelski 4y ago> So you give Biden 10.0, Trump 0.0, and for Romney, say 1.0. It's possible your 1.0 vote gives Romney the election. Now, if only Biden and Romney ran, you'd have given 10.0 and 0.0 respectively. So Romney gains by having Trump run despite no change in the ordinal preference. In an ordinal perspective Romney would have a larger edge because you've given a higher weight to him. You have to think about the embedding process and how much information is lost through that embedding. You're also only looking from the democratic viewpoint. Flipping this matters too because you have a potential favorite betrayer (Romney v Trump). Something Ordinal systems aren't good at handling. In a plurality voting those three could make an advantage for Biden because Romeny takes votes from Trump (and vise versa). In ordinal we have a similar but less severe problem because people will be placing their order strategically rather than preferentially. Even preferentially you are still embedding a decently high preference for Biden despite the fact you'd give him a 0 in Cardinal. See it this way. You could vote Trump 10, Romney 9, Biden 0. (or any variation). This indicates a strong preference of republicans over democrats. In an ordinal system you'd have to preference Trump > Romney > Biden for the same ballot. This does not express this large preferential difference. You've lost a lot of information through this embedding process. You maintain the order but you lost the degree of preference. There's no reason to drop this information.