3 ms·
It's not meant to be more concensus oriented. It's meant to give third parties/candidates a chance while preventing the spoiler effect. With the current US pol
by giantg2 4y ago
It's not meant to be more concensus oriented. It's meant to give third parties/candidates a chance while preventing the spoiler effect.
With the current US political climate, a third party would likely win a lot of the time if we were simply doing pair preferences like you laid out, because people are essentially voting by party for the lesser evil in most elections these days.
- panick21_ 4y agoRCV isn't actually that great at avoiding spoiler effects. You would do better with approval or range/score/star voting.
- giantg2 4y agoIn the IRV version, what spoiler effects are left? Since they're eliminating the lowest voted candidates in each round, you're essentially left with a two candidate election where it's possible to have 100% of voters voting for one or the other.
- fdsjgfklsfd 4y agoPalin is the spoiler in this election, taking away first-preference votes from Begich until Begich is eliminated, and then losing to Peltola. If Palin had strategically dropped out, or if Palin voters had dishonestly voted for the "lesser of two evils", then the outcome would have been better from their perspective.