4 ms·
Not all jurisdictions have sales taxes. And sales taxes aren't anywhere close to covering 100% of the budget for a city/state/country. That foreign money mostl
by paxys 4y ago
Not all jurisdictions have sales taxes. And sales taxes aren't anywhere close to covering 100% of the budget for a city/state/country.
That foreign money mostly goes to a handful of landlords/Airbnbs and tourist-friendly businesses (which are often foreign owned themselves). That in turn drives up prices of everything for locals – who are seeing no increase in income and moreover have to pay income tax and a ton of other taxes on it, something that digital nomads conveniently skip.
An influx of foreigners and foreign money isn't automatically welcome in a local economy.
- kelnos 4y agoMaybe it's time for governments to stop relying on income taxes so much, and instead really on land/property taxes for the bulk of their revenue. Sales taxes are regressive, but there are ways to keep them from hurting lower income folks as much.
- maerF0x0 4y agoand even then, a digital nomad's expenditure inside their country _is income_ to the next hop. They're simply losing on a single hop in an infinite chain of taxation.
- themanmaran 4y agoHow is property tax a good substitute for income tax? Property is not a 1:1 to value creation.
- hahaxdxd123 4y agoWhy punish value creation when you can punish rent-seeking? It is a strictly better substitute.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- zdragnar 4y agoUsing taxes as punishment makes for a very unreliable revenue stream. Rent seekers move on, and you're left with everyone else holding the bag.
- hahaxdxd123 4y agoThat's the beauty of it. Land can't move.
- zdragnar 4y agoIt won't move, but the utilization will change to be minimize the cost. I suspect that will be a net negative for anyone who needs to rent because they cannot afford a mortgage, maintenance cost, insurance, contribution to shared infrastructure like plumbing and electrical, and taxes together. I considered renting an apartment in two different commune-owned buildings (I was a student, not looking to own). Both were just as expensive and in significantly worse condition than all of the neighboring housing options. I found w nice place, but would have been better off with a slumlord rent-seeker than either of those places.
- hahaxdxd123 4y ago> It won't move, but the utilization will change to be minimize the cost. Yes people will build more medium density housing instead of having zucchini gardens in one of the most expensive regions of the world. Higher density would be good for renters in the local area. This, taken to it's "extreme": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Land_value_tax Pretty well studied, and has a lot of support across ideological viewpoints.
- prottog 4y agoMaybe it's time for governments to stop relying on taxes so much, period. Maybe they can reduce their scope a little bit. I do wish that land value tax would replace other forms of taxation in many jurisdictions.
- jimmaswell 4y agoMoved to New Hampshire lately and I love it. No state income tax, no sales tax. Property tax is a little bit higher than where I used to live but on the whole I worked out that I still save $10k in a typical year in tax burden compared to the same value property there, not even considering the lower COL in other areas. Working from home in a quiet peaceful hobby farm in a cheap state is living the life.
- liuliu 4y agoNot many countries rely on income taxes. For example, Thailand has about 11% tax revenue from personal income tax: https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-asia-and-pacific-thailand.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-asia-... Mexico is 20%: https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-latin-america-and-caribbean-mexico.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-latin... Vietnam is 8%: https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-asia-and-pacific-vietnam.pdf https://www.oecd.org/tax/tax-policy/revenue-statistics-asia-... It is very hard to collect personal income tax in developing countries. OP's tax revenue claim just doesn't match the data. On the other hand, corporate tax and VAT are very easy to collect. Digital nomads are very good for these revenue streams. It is true these digital nomads don't contribute to social security benefits. But they also rarely take from it. So it is a mixed bag.
- Test0129 4y agoProperty taxes are extremely regressive. Probably the first or second most regressive tax you can conceive. I, a lowly middle class worker buy a house in Cheapville. I can afford it, and the property tax, so I am happy. 20 years later I own my house and hundreds of thousands of immigrants from TechVille come buy up all the property. Great! There's no houses really on the market so the value sky rockets! Problem... my house value goes up, but so does my property tax. In fact, it's so expensive now I can no longer afford to live in the house. I have to sell MY PROPERTY because the STATE has imposed a tax specifically designed to destroy the idea of property as an owned right. In some circles this would be considered theft-by-taxation which is probably the only correct interpretation of this scenario. My house has to be sold because I can't afford it, it's bought (read: stolen) by some rich tech bozo with more money than sense, and I have to move. Probably to a different state where then I contribute to the very same problem there. The problem is the regressive property tax enabled this. The only solution is to not have them for residential non-commercial property. If property is not producing tangible value it should not be taxed. Taxes are collected at the sale of the home - this is enough. If it isn't, congress needs to tighten the purse strings. Property taxes are regressive, prevent you from ever truly owning your own plot, and disproportionately reduce the wealth of the people who spend most of their lives creating it for other people. They are probably the most distilled form of evil the financiers of a state or country can create because they are totally unavoidable and because of the way percentages and property value are calculated can very quickly go way out of hand. The only people that benefit are the rich house flippers and people with so much money their property taxes are a rounding error. It puts property in only the hands of the wealthiest. How is this a good thing?
- junofan 4y agoSounds unfair, but why does that make it bad policy? Perfect fairness isn’t always a great policy goal.
- tdeck 4y ago> Property taxes are regressive, prevent you from ever truly owning your own plot, and disproportionately reduce the wealth of the people who spend most of their lives creating it for other people. Property taxes are a form of wealth tax. The more wealth you own in the form of property, the more you pay in tax. Many people who work for a living don't own any property at all - about 35% of households in the US are renters. They don't have this problem of "wow my house is worth $1.2 million so I've got to sell it and move" - they've got bigger problems.
- smallerfish 4y agoI cannot get behind a property tax - if you own and have paid off a house, the idea that the state could seize it is abhorrent. Tax transport, wealth, sales - almost anything else in preference to property. Housing is a primary need.
- mikem170 4y agoWhat about land? Is it ok for someone to own a communal resource? Are property taxes a way of paying the community back for the exclusive use of a piece of land?
- smallerfish 4y ago> Is it ok for someone to own a communal resource? If there is zoning (and well managed conservation), I don't have a problem with it. I've lived near areas with no zooning at all, and that's a race to the bottom. You could have 99 year leases or similar instead of ownership (Japan does this?), but that is unfair to e.g. grandchildren who inherit a farm which they've worked hard at all their lives (where land is essentially their means of income.) Yes there is less land to go around, but that problem is ultimately overpopulation, and that's an _entirely_ different topic.
- datacruncher01 4y agoThe reality is that to own property you need a means to enforce that ownership. That places a constant forever cost burden on the community at large. You need police to enforce against trespassing, you need a legal system to process and transfer titles of ownership, you need infrastructure that is in part supported by public funds, you need an army to defend against hostile takeovers from foreign powers. This notion that you can own a property and end all ties to your community is ludicrous. Taxes are completely justifiable to allow you to have these means to enforce your ownership rights.
- smallerfish 4y agoI'm not anti-tax, I'm anti-property-tax. You could cover community burdens through infrastructure tax, transport tax, real estate sales tax, etc, and even ultimately a wealth tax.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- viscanti 4y agoWould income taxes from digital nomads make housing prices go down? There would be more money going to those governments but it's unclear that those governments could help offset most of the increase in costs.
- azinman2 4y agoNo because they increase demand for housing while supply is fixed, and then have much more money than locals to get whatever housing they want. This is what happened in SF for example as techies invaded and displaced the non-tech middle and lower classes.
- hibikir 4y agoFor most purposes, a foreign tech worker is a lot like having an extra tourist on any given week. They are giving money to your local businesses, but aren't competing with locals on anything but housing. The locals are going to see an increase in income in the very same way that they do in tourist towns: Extra demand for goods and services will provide more jobs and quite possibly marginally higher wages. Take a random tourist town: Say, in the southern coast of Spain. Then tell them that finally, they had managed to get rid of all the tourists, forever. Is that good or bad for the town? It's not as if there are no externalities, but in general, tourism is going to be good for your economy, and the amount of extra taxes the tourist pays on lodging is pretty low. Which Caribbean islands do better, those that have a lot of tourists, or those that don't take any external money? Also consider what happens in the opposite side of the remote worker, where what you get is the equivalent of a foreign worker who comes in, pays taxes, but spends basically nothing, and spends all their salary in remittances, to be spent abroad by their family. The worker is competing with you for the job, but then doesn't spend it locally! You will not find many municipalities that are all that happy of having a lot of jobs formerly done by locals in offices suddenly done by someone that is far away.
- gherkinnn 4y ago> They are giving money to your local businesses, but aren't competing with locals on anything but housing. Competing over housing i quite significant if you ask me.
- deepsun 4y agoEven that is a good thing for local developers and homeowners.
- pastacacioepepe 4y agoStill blatlantly ignoring the majority of people who are not wealthy enough to profit from tourism, but only get the downsides of it, which I'm not going to list here as they are many and proven. Edit: No, more potential careers as an underpaid waiter or touristic guide is not an upside.
- White_Wolf 4y agosoo... you want those that ammount to tourists to pay taxes in the country they visit? By your logic I should pay taxes to the country I go on holiday on the paycheck I get while being there. You are forgetting the tax income from the money all those "tourists" spend in that country. Who do you think benefits from those taxes? I do agree with you that it can befome a problem if those "tourists" start buying properties in those places. That should not be alowed without permanent residence (of, at least, a few years). "That in turn drives up prices of everything for locals "===> Are you serious? Do you realise how many of these "tourists" (% wise) are needed to affect the market in a city? Even 1% is nothing more than a blip(IMHO).
- jonp888 4y ago> By your logic I should pay taxes to the country I go on holiday on the paycheck I get while being there. No, because when your are on holiday it is not your place of employment. All they want is if you are using somewhere as your place of employment, that you pay taxes that are due on earning that money in the country, the same as if your are employed locally. It's not unreasonable. > Who do you think benefits from those taxes? You can't pick and choose which taxes you want to pay and then say there is some 'benefit' for deigning to pay any at all. Next time you stay in a hotel, try saying "I've shouldn't have to pay my bill, you should be grateful enough for the 'benefit' of the money I spent in the bar because I was staying here", and see how that works out.
- np- 4y agoThis isn't about being a legitimate tourist though. That has always been allowed. There are not many jurisdictions around the world where you are allowed to work and not pay any taxes though. Just because there is a loophole where you _can_ work remotely and it's extremely hard to detect or enforce doesn't suddenly make it legal, you are simply violating the terms of your Visitor's visa.
- namlem 4y agoTechnically true, but most countries make much greater use of VAT than the US does of sales tax.