3 ms·
The odd thing about Solidcoin is that I'm fairly sure that its centralization doesn't actually provide the claimed security benefits. For those not familiar wi
by makomk 15y ago
The odd thing about Solidcoin is that I'm fairly sure that its centralization doesn't actually provide the claimed security benefits.
For those not familiar with Solidcoin, it has two alternating types of blocks. The odd-numbered blocks are mined through a computationally-expensive process similar to that in Bitcoin, though the Solidcoin one doesn't run as well on GPUs. The even blocks are created either by someone with more than a million Solidcoins (which no-one has) or by a node its creator controls that has a special 1.2-million-coin account.
The claim is that this prevents an attacker with 51% of the compute power rewriting history and spending the same coins twice because they can't create the modified even blocks required. The trouble is that I can't see anything stopping them. The even blocks are approved by including a special transaction showing ownership of over a million coins, but there's nothing tying that transaction to the contents of that block, or the previous block, or anything except the previous transaction using that account. An attacker should just be able to copy the block-approving transactions from the original even blocks to their malicious replacements.
Basically, its creator failed to grasp that if you want to validate something using a digital signature (the one proving ownership of the million coins) you need to make sure modifying that something invalidates the signature. Most of the Bitcoin clones have turned out to be inferior to Bitcoin in some way, actually.
(There's some subtle issues around timestamps that'd make this attack a bit harder but I'm not intending to provide a howto guide here.)