2 ms·

OT but are any ingress/gateway systems using uring yet? Really enjoyed reading CloudFlare's justification for wrtiting Pingora gateway recently[1], a similar-i

OT but are any ingress/gateway systems using uring yet? Really enjoyed reading CloudFlare's justification for wrtiting Pingora gateway recently[1], a similar-ish system. Im interested to see what systems tech (what system calls) it ends up using. There's a ton of really great ingress/gateway tech out there. Kubernetes has a sublist that's pretty long[2]. There's a good comparison matrix[3] I ran into & it immediately made me very interested in APISIX (lots of box ticking). I think at one point I'd also run into a benchmark somewhere & they were quite performant, top tier. Would be interested to know more about tbeir chosen architecture & what if any performance optimizations they have planned/roadmapped/are-thinking-about. [1] https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-we-built-pingora-the-proxy-that-connects-cloudflare-to-the-internet/ https://blog.cloudflare.com/how-we-built-pingora-the-proxy-t... https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32836661 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32836661 (362points, 1d ago, 92comments) [2] https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/services-networking/ingress-controllers/ https://kubernetes.io/docs/concepts/services-networking/ingr... [3] https://kubedex.com/ingress/ https://kubedex.com/ingress/

colonelpopcorn 4y ago
I was trying to find a simple API gateway I could run as a single docker container on a single host. I ended up using a node-red workflow instead, because I was unable to get any of the options available to me working behind Traefik as my proxy. I tried APIMan first, then APISIX, then API Umbrella (used and developed by US government agency, apparently), and finally Kong. I got the closest with Kong, but decided to just give node-red a try and it worked like a charm as a proxy for another API.
- zcmack 4y ago
  doesn't traefik provide much of the functionality you'd want from an api gateway?
- nijave 4y ago
  You can run envoy pretty easily like that but the config can be a bit heavy (imo) unless you really want to read through the docs Here's an example (top Google result) https://amalaruja.medium.com/basic-http-routing-strategies-with-envoy-376be42559eb https://amalaruja.medium.com/basic-http-routing-strategies-w...

colonelpopcorn 4y ago

I was trying to find a simple API gateway I could run as a single docker container on a single host. I ended up using a node-red workflow instead, because I was unable to get any of the options available to me working behind Traefik as my proxy. I tried APIMan first, then APISIX, then API Umbrella (used and developed by US government agency, apparently), and finally Kong. I got the closest with Kong, but decided to just give node-red a try and it worked like a charm as a proxy for another API.

zcmack 4y ago
doesn't traefik provide much of the functionality you'd want from an api gateway?
nijave 4y ago
You can run envoy pretty easily like that but the config can be a bit heavy (imo) unless you really want to read through the docs Here's an example (top Google result) https://amalaruja.medium.com/basic-http-routing-strategies-with-envoy-376be42559eb https://amalaruja.medium.com/basic-http-routing-strategies-w...