5 ms·
>It's arguably unethical to mention solidcoin and link to their PR material without at least a little word of warning: True, my bad. I know of the scam accusa
by SkyMarshal 15y ago
>It's arguably unethical to mention solidcoin and link to their PR material without at least a little word of warning:
True, my bad. I know of the scam accusations, just assumed anyone reading a Bitcoin thread in HN would have as well and that I didn't need to. But in case not...
https://www.google.com/search?q=solidcoin+scam https://www.google.com/search?q=solidcoin+scam
I still think their FAQ page that explains their criticisms of Bitcoin is instructive, though.
- makomk 15y agoTheir site isn't an accurate description of Solidcoin or Bitcoin, though. There's actually a worse concentration of Solidcoins in the hands of its early adopters than Bitcoins and Solidcoin is far easier for the Government or a hacker to shutdown - all they have to do is get control of its creator's PCs. The amount given to the CPF account controlled by its creator has always been twice that stated: 10% of the value of an ordinary block, not 5%. The base reward for a block was reduced from the stated 32 Solidcoins to 5 by central fiat a month ago, which is why so many are in the hands of early adopters. The "10 trusted accounts of 1.2 million each" can actually be spent because the creator of Solidcoin designed it so he could transfer their entire contents to the CPF account he controls at will. I've already mentioned the 51% protection is deeply flawed and probably ineffective. It goes on. Some of the criticisms of Bitcoin are valid, but they've already been fixed by other less problematic clones that still never became that popular. In practice they don't actually matter that much; for example, even 2 minutes to confirm a transaction is too long for many things anyway.