15 ms·
the ant thing. So.. I get "close to the nest so it infects other ants" but .. is this not just statistics doing what darwinism does? if the fungus infects an an
by ggm 4y ago
the ant thing. So.. I get "close to the nest so it infects other ants" but .. is this not just statistics doing what darwinism does? if the fungus infects an ant far away, it has less outcome on the infection rate. the statistics of random chance infection ultimately favour the variances in the fungus, which produces more infection "close" to the hive. It has specific infectability, periodicity, plays to the ants day/night patterns, because its "more fit" statistically it skews to higher reproduction.
I much prefer a statistical model and skew, to intentionality language. maybe its me.
- 4mitkumar 4y agoYou're right. In fact, most write-ups on Darwinism (and evolution in general) incorporate too much intentionality in their tone when there might be none.
- 9dev 4y agoHave you ever tried writing about this topic? It’s surprisingly hard to keep intentionality out if you’re trying to give meaningful explanations.
- ggm 4y agoI think about this a bit. I had the temerity to try and write to Dawkins about this some time ago. I think I got a sense of "yes, given the chance, I think use of more statistical language would have been beneficial, but none of us realized how strongly the intentionality would be misunderstood" in reply, but I can't find the emails so I suspect I may have mis-remembered. Really I'd like to ask it face to face. For the experience.
- scatters 4y agoAnd yet you use intentional language when talking about yourself, but humans are just another set of biological machines subject to Darwinian evolution. Where do you draw the line?