2 ms·
I swear, Lisp fandom is the Amiga fandom of programming languages. You have these dedicated supporters who are willing to go to extreme, Herculean lengths to pr
by bitwize 4y ago
I swear, Lisp fandom is the Amiga fandom of programming languages. You have these dedicated supporters who are willing to go to extreme, Herculean lengths to prove that their chosen thing can not only keep up, but in some sense surpass what is popular, combined with nostalgia about the past and "what could have been". In the distant past, Ph.D.s have been awarded based on such feats, like "Look, we can compile Lisp code to run half as fast as Fortran" and "Look, we designed a chip that runs Lisp as a native instruction set". Simultaneously ridiculous and cool, the very picture of hack value. But you're still engineering around the drawbacks of a slow, dynamically typed language.
The Lisp machines were amazing in 1979. But no one is seriously building a Lisp machine today, because modern languages with modern IDEs on ordinary hardware have nearly all the features that Lisp machines had -- including hot-reloading code inside a live, running system -- and get you so, so much farther in the same amount of time than Lisp machines ever could.
Use a modern language inside a modern IDE, and you'll be fine.
- tartoran 4y agoIs there anything wrong with Amiga fandom? Amigas were cool as hell. They deserve their cult following. As far as LISPS, they’re cool as hell too. Just because they’re not up to par with corporate backed modern languages doesn’t mean you should use them for the same purposes. Be a bit open minded for a change and you’ll learn a thing or two.
- bitwize 4y agoI own an Amiga and use Lisp all the time. But the Amiga's coolness peaked around 1990; Lisp's coolness peaked in the late 70s or so. Lisp still feels great to use, but it doesn't really have an advantage over modern programming languages the way it did over languages from the 70s/80s, or even stone-knives-and-bearskins Unix development without an IDE. Many of the killer features of Lisp machines could be found in 90s Visual Basic. It kind of parallels the Amiga situation: by 1994 PCs had closed the gap, offering more CPU power and even a better gaming experience than the Amiga but diehards still keep comparing their boxes to the 5150 PC with CGA to feel superior. So if you want to use Lisp because it feels good to use -- it's fun to drive like an MGA is -- that's fine, but in the end you're no better off with Lisp than you would be with C# or TypeScript and in some ways you're worse off.
- cutler 4y agoLike Clojure with VS Code or Cursive/IntelliJ, you mean? NuBank also seem to be doing OK with Clojure.
- bitwize 4y agoSure, why not. Clojure seems to be the only Lisp that's willing to learn from modern languages anyway.
- kazinator 4y agoYou are simply trolling. People working with Lisp today are not doing tinkering in a retrocomputing context in order to recreate past experiences --- though there will always be a few of those hobbyists too, to be sure. It is not comparable to Amiga because you can deliver a solution in Lisp on the users' current platform, and they don't even know or care what you used. You can't put an Amiga solution into production such that the users don't know you're deploying Amigas (unless it's some emulated Amiga VM hidden under a hood or something and not actual hardware).