4 ms·
My favorite part of Hacker News is when commenters just lazily make the same comments again a couple months later, without taking into account what people’s rep
by saagarjha 4y ago
My favorite part of Hacker News is when commenters just lazily make the same comments again a couple months later, without taking into account what people’s replies to them, and hope nobody will notice: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32007917 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=32007917. Seriously though, this is pretty much the textbook definition of bad faith, so don’t do it.
- cmeacham98 4y agoIs my browser broken and not displaying some comments I should see? The only response I see there is basically "let's wait and see for Apple to provide more details and/or involve third party researchers", which Apple seems to have not done at all in the last 70 days?
- saagarjha 4y agoThe comment has been downvoted so it might be invisible to you unless you have showdead enabled.
- Veserv 4y agoTheir lack of any independent audits of their claims continues to be relevant. Please point to a single third party who is competent to evaluate if they can actually protect against the “most sophisticated digital threats” that has actually supported Apple’s claims. Valid third parties include, but are not limited to, any national security agency or premier hacking organization with hundreds of members (i.e. actual “most sophisticated digital threats”) declaring it can protect against them, any individual or organization who has designed and implemented such a system in the past agreeing Apple has created such a system, or any certification body who has reliably certified such systems with low rates of false positives such as the Common Criteria. Invalid support includes, but is not limited to, certification bodies that give Windows their highest security rating, marketing articles, individual hackers of no particular renown, and claims of it being “better” or “harder” without even being able to quantify where in a multiple order of magnitude range it lies.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoWho says an auditor is to be trusted?
- karottenreibe 4y agoTrust in this context is obviously not 1 or 0 but a sliding scale and some organizations are higher on that scale than others based on past conduct, as the previous poster pointed out at length. If you don't trust anyone but yourself, you'll have to do the audit yourself. How do you suggest to do that? An auditor with a good track record seems like the most trustworthy practically feasible alternative to me.
- pyinstallwoes 4y agoI don’t think your feasible alternative is assessing the massively skewed information asymmetry at play. Given you are the most successful computer company on the planet, and the entire planet is connected by your products within two degrees of separation in a network; then the only thing you gain is a loss as any auditor is in a position of being unmatched in every category at best and at worst is an active agent who will dissipate information increasing vulnerability and attack surface. Bug bounties work well to solve this, and that’s how it’s done.
- saagarjha 4y agoMy problem is that I can pretty much paste my response word-for-word and it still applies just as well here, which really means you haven't updated your take to account for it at all. That's just not interesting. That said, it's still a new feature. I'm sorry I don't have the NSA spokesperson here to say that they are going to pack it up and go home now because iPhones are unhackable, since that's the only thing you are willing to accept. To be entirely honest I am not even willing to hide my disdain for the certification you've repeatedly brought up at this point beyond it being a set of good practices. Like, the Titan M2 chip was assessed at AVA_VAN.5 it got exploited last month because it was written in a bunch of C and deployed without layout randomization or attempts at CFI. I trust the words of hackers (of particular renown, mind you!) and their analysis of how strong the mitigations actually are over some certification person just looking at the system and trying to take a guess as to how it'd hold out.