3 ms·
It’s quite obnoxious that billionaires are given such deference in our society to make policy decisions about topics entirely unrelated to their area of compete
by jacobolus 15y ago
It’s quite obnoxious that billionaires are given such deference in our society to make policy decisions about topics entirely unrelated to their area of competence. There is little reason to believe that tech billionaires should be experts on education, for instance (as compared to say teachers or child psychologists), but because as a society we’ve made it difficult to raise money through taxes, we’re now uncritically embracing their educational reforms because they come with money attached.
The problem with forming public policy around the whims of the super wealthy, beyond their lack of special expertise, is that they are not accountable to everyone else in anything like the same way government is, and we can’t expect them to have interests closely aligned with the general social interest. Which means that as inequality continues to increase and the rich more and more attempt to provide public services as private enterprises, the ability for the rest of us to influence and “buy in to” these systems is steadily eroded.
The cash can be quite helpful in particular areas, but ultimately this form of policymaking undercuts democracy.
- cpr 15y agoOh, do you think our government is truly accountable to everyone? I think just the opposite. The control we have over what happens at all levels of government (most specially federal and state) is so tenuous as to be essentially nil.
- jacobolus 15y agoMy local, state, and federal governments (e.g. my local school board, my state senator, the federal appeals court) are dramatically more accessible and accountable to me than, say, Google, the Saudi royal family, or Bill Gates. I have the right to petition when I have grievances, I can organize voters to apply pressure, I can sue in courts when government policies don’t live up to the constitution or higher-level laws, I can run for office. When politicians are corrupt, it is (at least sometimes) a scandal. When corporate actors are corrupt, there’s only a problem if the shareholders are negatively impacted or when the bad outcomes are so overwhelming that government takes action. I agree with you that our current politics has many problems, perhaps chief among them the incredible influence of political donations, revolving corporate doors, and so on.
- cpr 15y agoAnd you think you can personally make a serious difference with one vote and some organizing? Whew. I agree that Google, Gates and Saudis are completely out of reach.
- jacobolus 15y agoI think smart and dedicated activists can make an enormous difference, yes. There’s no “some” about the organizing part though. Effecting political change takes huge amounts of (smart, carefully focused) effort, because we live in a complex society where lots of different people have different ideas about how things should work, and persuasion on such a scale is damn hard.
- philwelch 15y agoYour local school board, for instance, is also more accessible and accountable to jingoes, creationists, abstinence activists, and teachers' unions.
- philwelch 15y agoAny culture is fundamentally ruled by powerful people who aren't necessarily the best experts. Do you want those people to be billionaires (who get powerful by getting a lot of money somehow) or politicians (who get powerful by getting a lot of popularity somehow)? Doesn't sound like a good solution either way when you put it that way. There's nothing guaranteeing that a billionaire won't listen to genuine experts, just as there's nothing guaranteeing that a politician won't make decisions based on ideology or uninformed popular opinion.