11 ms·
You Guys Are Millionaires Right?
- jodrellblank 15y ago"In which I try to convince myself that my decisions are fine, despite strong evidence to the contrary".
- pagliara 15y ago"Then you see an app like ’101 sex positions’ or ’301 Fart Noises’ reach the lofty heights of App Store Success. They spent a week on a gimmick and made bank, you spent 6 months building an app of utility and are struggling." So why not go make your own fart or sex app? There's a reason why these apps make it to the top; it's what people really want. Sadly or not, there's always going to be a bigger potential market for dumb, entertaining apps than your average practical app. I'd even go so far to say there's an art to producing the kind of apps that satisfy this segment of the market.
- tlrobinson 15y agoIndeed. I spent ~6 hours writing a gun "simulator" app that's made something like $50,000. Some of it was luck, but if you're willing to sell your soul and you can crank out a few of these a week your chances of success are probably higher than spending 6 months perfecting a single app you don't even know anyone wants.
- pavel_lishin 15y agoWhy sell your soul and make that decision? Why not do both, and try spending half your time creating trivial fart apps - shouldn't take more than a few hours, right? which you need to get away from your main project that's going to change the way I use my smartphone, etc., etc.
- patrickyeon 15y agoIf we're offering advice from the peanut gallery (and I'm no smartphone developer, so I'm way up in the peanut gallery), why not spend that time on a program that can generate trivial apps. Extract data [legally, now!] from some source (eg wikipedia), and skin it with some boilerplate and some generated UI elements. I think it'd be a more interesting project to implement the more general version, and once it's nailed down it's probably a better source of revenue too.
- Mizza 15y agoThis happens all the time.
- jarin 15y agoThis is a lot like the 37signals model of consulting: "sell your soul" to clients until you can afford to take a leap on your own product.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- Aqua_Geek 15y ago> This comment looks casual, but with $50,000 you don't have to work anymore until the end of life. Sadly, $50,000 doesn't go far here in the US. Don't get me wrong - it's definitely a nice chunk of change, but it's far from "don't have to work anymore" land. It's more in the "pay off one's student loans/credit card debt" area of things. Where I live, average home prices seem to be around $320k, so this would barely cover a down-payment.
- waqf 15y ago> There's a reason why these apps make it to the top; it's what people really want. I think Apple as a monopolist intermediary (assuming we are talking about the iPhone market) has more of a role here than this invisible-hand argument implies. It's Apple's choice to promote a top-N listing, which means that the already most popular apps get even more downloads. Fair enough, you might think, but it's Apple's choice how they count the top N. If they count number of purchases, then throwaway $1 apps will be favored over more substantial, more expensive apps; whereas if they count highest grossing, the more expensive apps will fare better.
- Radim 15y agoIn related news, a script called "spark: ▁▂▃▅▂▇ in your shell" has over 1,200 watchers and 79 forks on github at the moment. Scipy is a monumental and long-running effort of creating a scientific library for Python. It's an incredibly advanced piece of software that quite possibly saves lives (literally), and has 207 watchers and 78 forks. It's just what people really want. I'd even go so far to say there's an art to producing the kind of apps that satisfy this segment of HN.
- rat87 15y agoI believe the Numpy/Scipy official repositories are on sourcefourge and it has its own website. The github page appears to be the main web presence of Spark. I think of Numpy/Scipy as more conservative library not exactly the best github match. I know that Numpy/Scipy are vastly more important/discussed/used then Spark.
- Kliment 15y agoIt's not just that. Spark is smaller, easy to understand, easy to modify, and grabbing someone's modified version is unlikely to make your data invalid. Complex codebases with a lot of functionality are less approachable, and having to verify that each change does not compromise its functionality discourages the use of as many forks.
- kmfrk 15y agoI think this is related to why images and memes are, by far, the most popular submissions on reddit: they are simply easier and faster to understand. It doesn't mean that they are necessarily better, but the time spent on understanding them are at a complete minimum. You don't even need to be a technical person to get a grasp of why the spark graphs do. The challenge of a private business is having to strike a balance between "important" and "intelligible".
- extension 15y agoIt took a certain kind of genius to realize that people wanted their phones to fart. I would make a gimmick app if I could think up a successful gimmick, but all I can seem to come up with is deeply interesting games.
- tikhonj 15y agoThe whole rant against "free" software is just a straw man--the movement he decries as a cult against charging for software isn't about that at all. The whole idea lies in freedom: the "free as in beer" "free" is the Java to the movements JavaScript. The name is an unfortunate artifact of the English language. Additionally, it's pretty clearly not an outright lie: you only have to look at the successful ecosystem of free/open source software, and the companies which live on it, to see that it does work. Perhaps it is an exaggeration, but it is no lie.
- kiba 15y agoI'll buy freedom. I buy an arudino and android, and a thing-o-matic though I couldn't afford a thing-o-matic on my earning right now. When push come to shove, I'll probably stays on android even if the world around me all use iphone just like I use archlinux everyday. Granted, I am in the minority.
- Kliment 15y agoGo for a reprap instead. We're much more open-dev and organic (organic is the nicer way of saying chaotic and disorganized I guess). Which continent are you on?
- uiri 15y agoI think it is just because the rant is in response to a strawman who is asking the question. They haven't really looked into free software as an alternative to proprietary software and it really is a shift in thinking about software. It is exactly the kind of response I'd expect from someone who makes their living off of proprietary software and gets ``attacked'' by the RMSes of the world. It certainly seems like a lie if you use Microsoft Windows and iOS day-in and day-out and account for the free software which does exist by pointing out companies with alternative business models (Red Hat's support business, Google's search/advertising, etc). Then the only unexplained pieces left are those which are run by community (Debian, Apache, etc) and that can be handwaved away by people who donate to those projects or the developers have full-time ``real'' jobs which involves proprietary software. If one explains the existence of free software to themselves in this manner, than all free software requires the proprietary software side to pay developers and thus it is a myth in the sense that one can't have software without some level of proprietary software in the world. These are [likely] inaccurate explanations, but somewhat similar to the author's POV as far as I can tell. If English didn't have this silly artifact, then the response would be about ridiculing how essentially zero people who use their apps would have any use for the source code so it is ok to keep it from them. Regardless, the point of free software is lost and the developer just doesn't want to be pestered by the RMSes of the world. Similar to how the developer doesn't want to be pestered by people who like to share software and think it does no harm. And not to be pestered by people who assume that s/he is rolling around in money.
- kiba 15y agoDespite briefly working in the software field, I got no sympathy because of the way he communicates. Yes, I know how tough software development is. Yes, free software commoditize and runs people out of business. However, they enable the company I used to work for, develops solution that help their client. (I got laid off a few weeks ago) No, I don't care much about software devs not making enough money in the banks. No, I am not rich, though I have more saving than most people my age. In fact, they're probably in debt. I don't feel particularly bad for writing open source software for free or scratching my itch for free, even though I am a horrible competitor. They probably can beat me in sales technique and make more money than I ever will. I recognize being in the software field is an honor, a blessing. It's not something that we have a right to be in. We die or live by solving people's problem and then making money off of them. I don't recognize piracy as a moral issue, but simply a business model problem, no matter how big of a problem it is.
- ChuckMcM 15y agoI found the comment fascinating "People will spend hours researching a $2 purchase, browsing reviews, emailing the developer, checking online forums. Then they will go to a coffee shop they’ve never been before and buy a $4 coffee." It is so true, and so weird at the same time. Why the investment in research time for the app and the disdain for the coffee which will pass through your system roughly 45 minutes later? Makes me wonder if they should charge $19.99 for the app and offer a 'trial version' for $4.99 which lets you see if you want to buy it with no expiration date.
- wr1472 15y agoIsn't one, in consumer terms, a fungible commodity? ie. a latte in one coffee shop is almost identical to another - especially if it's the same franchise?
- bdr 15y agoI wonder if, psychologically, it's because the game is perceived as something you will permanently own, while the coffee is temporary. People seem to weigh the first kind of decision much more heavily.
- d_r 15y agoI'll throw out a random personal theory here. I think this is because buying apps is a solitary activity. As humans we are more comfortable fitting in or following. When you go to a coffee shop or a crowded store, you're buying something because you actually see others buying it. The decision-making aspect is "taken away" from you, as it was already done by people at large. There is also the element of human interaction with the barista. It's much easier to spend $4 this way. Yes, at the coffee shop you also might have an immediate purpose -- like chat with a friend. But even when I am alone, spending $4 doesn't seem like a big investment. It feels and seems normal. And note that this doesn't have to do with the quality of the product. In the meantime, when you're at alone and are browsing an app store, the burden of decision making is on you. In essence, the thought process is "am I making a good decision? is it normal to buy something like this? do I really need this?" With that, $1 can seem like quite a bit when you have time and solitude to decide.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- billpatrianakos 15y agoI'm so glad they wrote about piracy and made the points about how Not all software should be free. Honestly, I'll never understand that sense of entitlement people have. I was once in the same boat as the author, pirating everything under the sun. Then I got a job writing code too and I haven't pirated a single thing since. I don't sell software but I appreciate the work that goes into it and understand that these guys lose out even if I didn't have money to pay to begin with. The no money argument and the free marketing arguments are bunk. The poor will save to buy if there's no pirate copy and the majority of marketing you get from a pirated app is marketing that links to the pirate download, not the legit one! Excellent post!
- wuster 15y agoI've been wondering if independent software vendors might benefit from some humanizing of the sales effort. Instead of charging $2 for an app, how about framing it as "buy the developer a taco", or for $4 "buy the developer a grande latte". The amazing $10 app could be "buy the developer a roll of sushi". You get the idea. Psychologically, I find it much more satisfying to be rewarding friends & associates with more tangible things than some dollar amount. Does anyone know if this model has been attempted before?
- roel_v 15y agoPersonally, I find it quite humiliating to have to (almost literally) beg for food just to be paid for work done, which in every single other aspect of life is considered perfectly normal. Plus, how much does it really help? There are so many people with 'donate' buttons on their website who don't get enough 'donations' each year to even eat a single meal.
- patio11 15y agoThis is exactly the opposite of the pricing psychology ISVs benefit from. Good anchors for pricing are not cheap, disposable items but rather expensive, valuable economic inputs like "your fully loaded cost for $TIME." I know a dev or two with "buy me a beer" buttons. Anecdotally, one of those buttons plus $5 will buy you a beer.
- swah 15y agoAnother theory: because there is no line of folks buying the same app in front of you.
- bmunro 15y agoA few interesting comments from the author: - Piracy of Pocket Casts on iOS is about 30% - Piracy of Pocket Casts on Android is about 20% moving into Android development was a very smart (some might say lucky) move which has enabled us to stay profitable We definitely need to focus more, but moving into Android was the smartest thing we ever did. We now earn more money there (consistently) than iOS.
- jasonlotito 15y ago"Very few bits of software ever written were not funded by someone." I found this comment to be quite insightful. An interesting way to look at it.
- mnutt 15y agoInteresting, but demonstrably false. Take a look through Github or Sourceforge. Many, many of the projects are people scratching an itch or just building something for fun. We can argue about the exact percentage, but it's definitely more than "very few bits".
- jasonlotito 15y agoGithub and Sourceforge are supported via paying customers or advertising. =) The point isn't that all software isn't paid for. Rather, that somewhere, it's costing someone money. And I think that was the point (or at least, that's what I got from it, which is the important part).
- mnutt 15y agoI was referring to the software on Github and Sourceforge, not Github and Sourceforge themselves. Some software costs someone money. Lots of it is built for the sake of building it though. You could argue that time people spend building software could have been billable hours, but I think the author totally misunderstands the spirit of building software for the enjoyment of it.
- jasonlotito 15y ago> I was referring to the software on Github and Sourceforge, not Github and Sourceforge themselves. So was I. And this software is being supported by SF and Github. > I think the author totally misunderstands the spirit of building software for the enjoyment of it. Which means nothing. Consider Linus and Linux. Linux wasn't paid for directly, but don't for a minute think it wasn't supported by someone's cash. In fact, I challenge you to find me software that didn't use someone's real money (not this billable hours thing you brought to the table for some reason) to get developed at some point.
- rkalla 15y agoJiggy's comment[1] about why Coffee != Apps to be spot on. Your app is an unknown quantity, getting someone to spend anything on an unknown quantity is really really hard. When you go to McDonald's (or anyone for that matter) do you get something different every time, or do you get your favorite thing? Same goes for Olive Garden or Cheesecake Factory, did you get the burger last time and the fresh fish catch this time? Probably not. To some degree, those fart apps are a known quantity; they make fart noises, so they have the advantage over your app of having their foot in the door for everyone interested. It seems unfair, but there has to be a strategy there for riding that wave. Hollywood has always done it, did you enjoy Superman 7 or Harry Potter 14? It doesn't matter, it was a known quantity and eleventeen million people went and saw it. It seems like SJ is being forced to learn this lesson over-and-over again[2] and I've already shared my thoughts with you about that[3]. Your expectations of what you want SJ to do and exactly how you want it to do it may be too tight. You guys are clearly talented and I wonder if you need some step-back-and-get-a-better-perspective time. Tom's comment[4] is a great example of what I mean. Does ShiftyJelly want to get into the gun or fart-app business? Probably not... does SJ want $50k? Probably yes. It feels to me like there is some unexpected pivot in here for you guys to extract; one that you didn't see coming, but one that works out surprisingly well for you. NOTE: Make the two app references at the end of the article links to the appstore. [1] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3285771 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3285771 [2] http://shiftyjelly.wordpress.com/2011/08/02/amazon-app-store-rotten-to-the-core/ http://shiftyjelly.wordpress.com/2011/08/02/amazon-app-store... [3] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2837439 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=2837439 [4] http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3284450 http://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=3284450
- erkin_unlu 15y agoa very good post, but he seemed a little confused with the open source / free software paradigm. He must have known that open source software can be charged, the point is that you have to share the source code you are selling!!