6 ms·
Not being a big Twitter user, I didn't understand the whole "blue checkmark verified" scam, which works like this: 1. There are a host of requirements needed t
by hn_throwaway_99 4y ago
Not being a big Twitter user, I didn't understand the whole "blue checkmark verified" scam, which works like this:
1. There are a host of requirements needed to get the blue check: https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twitter-verified-accounts https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twit...
2. However, once an account gets the blue check, the owner is free to change the profile pic and display name, and the blue check doesn't go away.
3. So the scam is that some bad guy buys a previously verified account, changes the profile pic and display name to someone else famous, then uses it to phish.
#2 is colossally stupid, and is trivial to prevent (lots of dating sites require profile changes and pic changes to be reviewed before going live). Apparently this has been going on a long time so is baffling to me.
- godelski 4y agoAbout once a week I get a mass message from a random twitter account with extremely clear spam (they even leave the group message after they send it!). They are often centered around crypto. I don't know how they are this bad because a Naive Bayesian Classifier could block this stuff.
- bombcar 4y agoTwitter users love changing their profile picture/name to support the current cause of the moment so much that it’s become a meme. Changing that would piss off their active posters.
- pawelduda 4y agoPretty simple to solve - change your profile pic/name, lose blue checkmark until you get verified again.
- badwolf 4y agoThis is kind of how Scruff (gay dating app) works. Change your profile pic? Lose your verified status and have to go thru verification again.
- KeepFlying 4y agoThat would kill a lot of Twitter culture though (for better or worse). Changing a name for "spooky season", updating a profile pic to promote a new event, etc. It also would make it risky for a large company to change their logo (if Volvo loses verification for a few days it opens them up to a ton of scams).
- pawelduda 4y agoSeems like a minor inconvenience compared to what's going on right now. Maybe allow changing avatar without losing the badge but not the name.
- KerrAvon 4y agoNo problem: add a second line with the verified name, or put the verified name in hover text if it differs from the display name. The verified name could still be a pseudonym, but it couldn't change without going through the verification process again. Also, anyone willing to go through the verification process should get a blue check. Right now it's dependent on some Twitter insider liking the account holder (the insanely bullshit "Notable" requirement).
- iLoveOncall 4y agoThis is already the case, the verified name is the account name, which is always displayed just below the nickname. What's your plan? Add a 3rd name?
- jacobsenscott 4y agoRemove nicknames.
- JieJie 4y ago“There are 44,935 people named John Smith in the United States.” https://alexaanswers.amazon.com/question/24Ryred578w14fHwRNCAEf https://alexaanswers.amazon.com/question/24Ryred578w14fHwRNC...
- pessimizer 4y agoThis is obviously not true, unless I'm misunderstanding something. I'm not a twitter scientist, but I don't know what an "account name" is, unless it's the twitter handle. The twitter handles of blue checks are verifiably not required to have any relationship to a name that anyone knows them by, so are not a "verified name."
- iLoveOncall 4y ago> I don't know what an "account name" is, unless it's the twitter handle So, you know perfectly well and understood perfectly my point.
- ben_w 4y agoAnnoying such people is probably a price worth paying: https://news.sky.com/story/tories-criticised-for-misleading-public-with-twitter-fact-check-name-change-11865342 https://news.sky.com/story/tories-criticised-for-misleading-...
- fknorangesite 4y ago> the current cause of the moment Doesn't even need to be a cause - it's almost October, which means it's "change it to a spooky pun of your regular name" season.
- pleas4nt0ne 4y ago
- cmelbye 4y agoCould they simply disable the ability to change display names for verified users? It must match the government-issued ID / business documents / etc. that were used to verify in the first place. If you want to change it, send updated verification documents. This takes away an avenue for self-expression (people will often change their display names based on trends, etc.) and might have edge cases (like transgender people whose preferred names may not match government ID cards) but it seems like it would be a step in the right direction...
- tablespoon 4y ago> It must match the government-issued ID / business documents / etc. that were used to verify in the first place. If you want to change it, send updated verification documents. That seems like a bad requirement, because I'd imagine a lot of these legitimately-verified accounts go by professional names (e.g. actors, authors with a pen name, etc.) not legal names.
- zerocrates 4y agoA sane policy would be that there's a process for verified accounts to change their name, and that process is that some human at Twitter sees the account's current name and new name and rejects changes that aren't obviously still "the same person." A policy like this could prevent these kind of "pretend to be Vitalik or Elon or whoever" schemes without actually having to review the verification itself. So you can still allow hashtags and emoji and so on being stuck onto names, still allow "spooky" Halloween names, but preserve some kind of value from the verified checkmark. I don't know how many verified users there are but this doesn't seem like it would necessarily be onerous. Of course, it's still more onerous than just doing nothing about it is.
- michaelt 4y agoYou can be flexible in the initial validation - it's reasonable to allow William Jefferson Clinton to go by Bill Clinton if he wants to. And it's reasonable to allow name changes - it's not unusual for people to get married, or for companies to rebrand. But why let people change names without repeating the validation process? It's not like people are getting married several times a year or anything like that.
- omgomgomgomg 4y agoWow, this is incredible, this would be as if in fintech you let customers change their data of the onboaring information without checking again.
- loeg 4y agoStep 2.5 is probably the bad guy hacks some existing blue-checkmark account, but yeah.
- landr0id 4y ago>2. However, once an account gets the blue check, the owner is free to change the profile pic and display name, and the blue check doesn't go away. afaik twitter will remove your verification status if you do this maliciously. Like trying to impersonate a famous person and make it look like they're saying something stupid.
- datagram 4y agoYeah but as the OP shows, this probably happens much too late to stop harm if it happens at all. Just checked, and the account from the screenshot is still around and still verified.
- ryan29 4y agoIt's not a very good system either because it's called verification, but it's actually indicating popularity or notoriety. People hear "verified" and correlate that with trustworthiness when all that check mark is really indicating is "this person appears to be famous."
- Jerrrry 4y ago4. Repeat steps 1-3 for non-verified users 5. Report targeted user for mimicry/impersonation. 6. Targeted user gets insta-banned.
- summerlight 4y agohttps://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twitter-verified-accounts https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twit... > If changes to your account are misleading or substantially alter the persona present on your account You will lose the badge if you try to do the 2nd. But currently it doesn't proactively apply preventative measures, which is definitely a problem. Twitter obviously doesn't have bandwidth to proactively prevent all those scams, but at least last reviewed profiles should be visible to users for verification.
- at-fates-hands 4y agoBefore I got off of Twitter years ago, friends of mine would make a background image with a blue checkmark and then add it to their profile so it looked like you were verified. Easier than going through all the channels. Not sure if this still works, but a clever hack to get around (at the time) a very long process to get your identity verified.
- waylandsmithers 4y agoI'm an uncool dad but thought the check mark was like, this account really is the famous person the account claims to be, like Brad Pitt or Oprah. Now it's always someone I've never heard of.
- giraffe_lady 4y agoFamous to who though and how famous? I recently clicked through to a profile of someone I had never heard of and they had 5m+ followers. This isn't a "look how out of touch I am with pop culture" humblebrag they were just from a different part of the world, famous in a language I don't speak. And maybe not too similar but the mayor of my city only has a couple tens of thousands of followers but is definitely known by everyone who lives in it and yes has a blue check. How famous is famous enough isn't a question with an obvious, or single answer.
- swid 4y agoMy brother in law has a blue check. He writes comic blogs and wrote a book about them, so he does have a public persona. But he has less than 5000 followers and he is certainly not famous.
- rdl 4y agoAlso a bunch of early Twitter employees or their friends with low-follower Verified accounts. It's not consistent.
- chunkyguy 4y agoA famous person in one region is an unknown in another.
- tanin 4y ago> However, once an account gets the blue check, the owner is free to change the profile pic and display name, and the blue check doesn't go away. I worked at Twitter and built the verification service. I recalled that this was the case back in 2012. You couldn't change your name or username if you were verified (or if you change one of those, you would lose the checkmark).
- dundarious 4y agoI believe around 2015/2016, a verified account I follow changed his name and avatar (but not username) to "Italian Elon Musk", and a Mario mustache and hat superimposed on Musk's then avatar. He made many posts along the lines of "I skippa tha taxes! Mamma mia!". Pretty obviously a joke, and after a while (I think a few days), he lost his tick, which I think was in a way his goal all along. So if you're saying such changes for verified accounts have been disallowed since 2012, and if my dates are somewhat accurate, then I don't think that's right. But maybe you're just saying it used to be disallowed around 2012, not that it became disallowed then.
- dr-detroit 4y ago
- tanin 4y agoYes, I was saying it was like that in 2012. They probably changed it after 2015.
- chimeracoder 4y ago> You couldn't change your name or username if you were verified (or if you change one of those, you would lose the checkmark). You still can't change your username. You can change your display name, however, and I believe that's always been the case.
- numpad0 4y agoI can see why that requirement was dropped, because display name is sometime used as a profile line. e.g.: - “Corporate, Inc. @ tradeShow Hall A” - “DisplayName / A Trusted Brand”, - “Individual (LIVE 09/21 21:00-)”, etc. Profile pics change for similar reasons. screenname(@username) is the only bitwise consistent visual element for a Twitter account so there will have to be either a magical audit algorithms to verify user perceived consistencies for changes, or simply a degraded experiences with impacts on engagements for verified users, to enforce that.
- pentagrama 4y agoOn the Twitter help page it says that your blue check will be removed if you do that. >If changes to your account are misleading or substantially alter the persona present on your account https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twitter-verified-accounts#loss-tab https://help.twitter.com/en/managing-your-account/about-twit...
- bombcar 4y agoBy the time it’s reported and found and handled the damage is done.