3 ms·
Easily the most annoying part of flying for me, particularly when doing a quick flight from SFO to LAX is the insistence that I turn off my Kindle while we are
by ghshephard 15y ago
Easily the most annoying part of flying for me, particularly when doing a quick flight from SFO to LAX is the insistence that I turn off my Kindle while we are lining up for the runway.
* People reading newspapers, and books - both of which are larger, heavier, and just as distracting, and in the case of newspapers, a greater obstacle - are not told to put away their reading material - so the argument that "people need to pay attention on takeoff/landing" is not consistent.
* RF engineers haven't been able to prove that a kindle in airplane mode has a negligible likelihood of impacting the flight systems of an airplane. Really?
One solution, albeit a slightly annoying one, is to have a distinctively colored LED or indicator that is visible from the walkway of the airplane to a stewardess, but not annoying to the reader, which indicates whether a device has been placed in airplane mode.
The new motto then would be "Everyone please place their FAA certified equipment into airplane safety mode. All other electronics, iPads, kindles, laptops, gameboys, iPhones, iPods, must now be put away"
People, being people, would likely start putting the fake LEDs on their electronics to simulate the FAA approved one, unfortunately, not sure what to do about that.
- mikeash 15y agoI wouldn't worry about people putting fake LEDs on their devices. It's not like a handful of devices being improperly turned on will do anything bad anyway. Do you think all 200+ people on a plane remember to turn off your cell phones? Fat chance. If consumer RF equipment could bring down a plane when used in small numbers, airliners would be raining from the skies.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoHow do we know there isn't a bug in a device's airplane mode?
- mikeash 15y agoHow do we know there isn't a bug in a device's off switch? Most of them are software-based these days.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoMost of them allow you to take the battery out if it comes to that.
- nknight 15y agoLike all the iPhones, iPads, and unibody MacBook Pros?
- mikeash 15y agoBut nobody actually does, so clearly we're content to trust the software on that matter.
- MatthewPhillips 15y agoThey do if the power button malfunctions. Are you aware of any devices that cannot be turned off because of a software error?
- mikeash 15y agoHow could you even tell if you had one?
- pavel_lishin 15y agonknight mentioned iphones, ipads, and unibody macbooks.
- ericd 15y agoThe off switch is almost certainly much more thoroughly tested, and most of its failure modes are much easier to detect.