3 ms·
I think you meant this to be silly, but we do actually do this. Cult leaders are held responsible for the actions of their adherents, given the degree of contro
by woodruffw 4y ago
I think you meant this to be silly, but we do actually do this. Cult leaders are held responsible for the actions of their adherents, given the degree of control necessary to compel someone to kill on their behalf.
- realce 4y agoOnly if they instruct their followers to actually commit violence though.
- woodruffw 4y agoRight. That's the "incontrovertible evidence" part. The analogy requires each step to actually be true.
- mc32 4y ago…yes?… but it’s more than you were a cult leader and your follower did something bad. You have to have psychologically manipulated them as well -ala Manson.
- woodruffw 4y agoYes, hence "incontrovertible evidence." I think the GP was trying to introduce some ambiguity with "inspired" instead of "manipulated."
- throwaway98797 4y agothis helps the point reasoning by analogy across different criminality is filled with risks i’m hopeful society and eventual the law will catch up with what is reasonable. sadly, i suspect what is reasonable to the majority won’t be reasonable to me. or worse yet the flaw of reasoning will be borne by future generations like the blood letting cures of prior centuries i offer no solution only the occasional comment bordering on full blown troll.