13 ms·
The thing about privacy is you never know when future politics is going to come into play. Maybe a medical procedure will suddenly become illegal, such that yo
by simonw 4y ago
The thing about privacy is you never know when future politics is going to come into play.
Maybe a medical procedure will suddenly become illegal, such that your location history is now subject to warranted search.
Maybe your country will take a sharp turn towards authoritarianism, electing politicians who are ready and willing to use law enforcement to "punish" their enemies.
Maybe your monarch will die, and a recently passed bill will be used to arrest people who protest the existence of the monarchy.
Having "nothing to hide" isn't necessarily a fixed state.
- bgro 4y agoYeah. Medical procedures, like abortions in the states, are a very real example of how things can dramatically change on a whim to an unbelievable level. Or syncing your cycle data to a smart device and later having a retro-scan to detect cycle anomalies to charge women with probable crimes. We do that with speed cameras, why not just automate health data mining too? Why did you stop updating your cycle data, is it because you knew you were pregnant and wanted an abortion? Sounds like suspicious activity to me, exactly identical to turning around at a DUI checkpoint.
- shabbatt 4y agoWhat I find most ironic is that those people who are now realizing the same privacy platforms they used to defend with "I have nothing to hide" are the ones complying against their interests. It's a poignant example of what others have pointed out. "I have nothing to hide" until political landscape changes to make it something to hide. It's like people pushing for liberal drug laws and legalizing homeless tents and then one day its in their backyard. While I feel for women part of groups that are impacted by Roe vs Wade being overturned, their apathy against privacy concerns have boomeranged, the same of which proportion of men who aren't having to deal with abortion are looking at this issue as "I don't need an abortion so it doesn't concern me". Those women caught up in this struggle also looked on, along with men and everybody else as Uyghur women were sterilized and forced to abort using the very surveillance mechanism that were developed and custom tailored to fit the needs of the abusers. It's almost like the land of CCP is a testing ground for what's in store for Western civilization. Remember what caused Latin America's shift towards tyranny and dictatorship, it was inflation. Nothing about our land that makes it any less susceptible or resilient. Inflation has deep remifications to privacy and this Roe vs Wade situation is only the beginning.
- blep_ 4y ago> men who aren't having to deal with abortion are looking at this issue as "I don't need an abortion so it doesn't concern me". ... maybe we shouldn't have spent years telling them they weren't allowed to have an opinion because it didn't concern them.
- Andrex 4y agoWas there a Pope of Abortion Rights that pronounced such an edict? As a man, I haven't encountered this in an abortion discussion, but it sounds like something an asshole would say and I try not to hang out with assholes.
- blep_ 4y agoI've heard variations on it many times, usually by the people who frame it entirely as "right to choose" (-> "if you're not capable of getting pregnant you have no right to input on this"). I get what they're going for, conceptually, but wow that is not how you get allies. It turns out assholes come in all genders.
- shabbatt 4y ago> ... maybe we shouldn't have spent years telling them they weren't allowed to have an opinion because it didn't concern them. that never stopped women from doing what they want. you are completely brushing past the main issue which is apathy towards privacy which is not remotely related to women's rights portrayed by mainstream media and your language generalizes 100+ years of women, who regardless societal expectations, went on their own because they believed they had same rights as any other human. It's sad that the same spirit is now being used as shields to derail completely unrelated issues that by mere association of gender, calls for a complete review of a certain political lens that we are all familiar with. Save us the grace here honey.
- HWR_14 4y ago> Medical procedures, like abortions in the states, are a very real example of how things can dramatically change on a whim to an unbelievable level. Change, but not retroactively.
- MichaelCollins 4y agoThis assumes the rule of law holds. America has a pretty good track record in this regard, better than most countries I think, but there can be no guarantees for the future.
- 0x457 4y ago> exactly identical to turning around at a DUI checkpoint. Has anyone actually got in trouble for that? I turned around those checkpoints all the time because it's just faster to go around.
- giantg2 4y agoSometimes they pull over people Turing around
- OneLeggedCat 4y agoOh hell yes they do. At least on rural highways in the Southeastern US.
- porknubbins 4y agoYou don’t get in trouble just for turning around, I think its that turning around gets you pulled over and breathalyzed and you get in trouble for DUI. I realize this is kind of a classic “why worry if you have nothing to hide” argument, but everything is a balance and I’m ok with this intrusion to reduce DUI deaths. It is not equivalent to other privacy invasions.
- GuB-42 4y agoThere is a risk to using "not private" services. And like all risks, it has to be measured and balanced against what you gain from taking that risk. For instance, if you go hiking, you my get attacked by a bear, is it a risk worth taking? Usually yes, bear attacks are rare, unless you do stupid things like going where you know there is a bear. Same thing for privacy, you can take some risks, for example by letting Facebook follow you doing mundane things for targeted advertising, but not be so stupid as to post picture of yourself doing stupid things for everyone to see. The concrete example in the article is in the second category: some guy gets fired because he posts a picture of doing stupid things at his job. Personally, I consider the political risks you cited low for the US or EU. Not zero, it is never zero, but low enough to be negligible compared to what Google, Amazon or Facebook offer me. Maybe it is not your case. There are some privacy high risks, and that's, I think, mostly about things you publish online. Police doesn't need a warrant to look at your public profile, neither does your boss or the spouse you are cheating. Others include doing stupid things on your employer's corporate network, or doing things that are seriously illegal right now in your country without necessary precautions.
- missedthecue 4y agoIf my government wants to know something about me, they will be able to find out and that's whether I use DuckDuckGo or Google, Chrome or Firefox, Facebook or no Facebook, Gmail or my own private server, and whether or not I use a VPN service. Some people (especially here on HN) are so into privacy for the sake of privacy, more like a hobby than a practical exercise in improving their quality of life. And that's completely fine. But I'm more interested in convenience. I'm at the point where I would legitimately prefer my Social Security Number to be leaked on the dark web than have to deal with the proposed three-factor authentication for my banking and brokerage accounts.
- livueta 4y ago> If my government wants to know something about me, they will be able to find out and that's whether I use DuckDuckGo or Google, Chrome or Firefox, Facebook or no Facebook, Gmail or my own private server, and whether or not I use a VPN service. In the case of a targeted investigation, yeah, you're probably right. Thing is, that's not the only (or even most likely) threat unless you're some kind of wannabe DPR. Dragnet/geofence-style investigations are getting more common and while not using Google likely won't save you from the CIA, it may very well avoid your technically-incompetent local LEOs accidentally framing you for a bank robbery or something when you win the location-data lottery. But that's an individual-level argument, which imo isn't the main point - privacy is a societal-level good. > But I'm more interested in convenience. This is basically the "I have nothing to say, so I have no need for freedom of expression" argument transplanted into the privacy sphere. The effectiveness of privacy methods scale both technically and socially: an example on the technical front is how tor is more useful the more "normal" traffic ends up on it, and an example on the social front is how encrypted messaging capabilities aren't suspicious if they're integrated by default into widely used apps. So, I see privacy as less about me and more about participating in creating an environment where those who truly require it can have it, and that's something that's way harder if privacy is only conceived as being "for" dissidents or fetishists or whatever. Is it inconvenient sometimes? Sure, but it's also a civic duty. I'd honestly call it analogous to jury selection: quite possibly nothing but a burden to you personally, but an important part of maintaining a healthy society.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- bloomingeek 4y agoI don't consider myself a paranoid person, but I realized 20 years ago that we were all losing our privacy to online entities. When I first read about "the cloud", I knew that what I put on it was no longer mine. Government regulators don't care at all about our privacy, so what makes anyone really think they have nothing to hide? Honestly though, I can't imagine my life without these entities stealing my data, that's how bad it has become!
- godelski 4y agoI always try to break privacy concerns down because when everything is lumped together I think people that aren't into privacy get confused. There's concerns about: hackers, surveillance capitalism, foreign state actors, and domestic state actors. People that say they have nothing to hide are usually unconcerned about one or two of these (surveillance capitalism and domestic state actors) but often are actually concerned with at least one. The truth of the matter is, though, that if you're concerned about one, you need to be concerned about all of them. There is no door that only good guys can use and bad guys can't. Breaking it down has often led to more successful conversations for me. Even in a group of highly tech literate people (CS graduate students) I often see the "I don't care" or "what can I do" sentiments. So I suggest when talking about all this, break it down into these categories. Maybe if more of us did this then we'd have more success as a community.
- c0mptonFP 4y agoYou're reframing the desire for privacy as a dystopian paranoia. That doesn't do much good tbh
- _carbyau_ 4y agoMy take on this is, even if you trust [insert data holding brand name], do you: - (access) trust every individual employee who has immediate access. Forever? And every individual employee of the government agencies that could compel access? Forever? - (policy from above) trust every executive who could change policy on where your data goes and how it is held. Forever? Trust the relevant national government regarding laws about your data. Forever? - (security) trust the Security set up is at least great. Forever? Forever, because data can last that long. And auditing data handling is hard. Edit: tried to make it clearer.
- elzbardico 4y agoYou also don't know what future you will be doing. Lots of activists where people with pretty boring lives until someone happened with them that triggered their indignation and revolt. Or maybe some relative of yours, or a friend. It doesn't matter, you don't know future you.
- smcn 4y agoThis is my favourite take. Seeing the arrests in Edinburgh this past week has been heart wrenching. It's just... I thought we were better than that?
- pclmulqdq 4y agoThe people getting arrested in the streets of Edinburgh were the same people who have been arguing to take away free speech and privacy rights from others. They got very little sympathy from the pro-free-speech crowd because they are decidedly anti-free-speech. They are now reaping what they have sowed. The sad part is that they, and all of their supporters, will probably go back to agitating against free speech after this whole thing blows over.
- Matl 4y ago> They got very little sympathy from the pro-free-speech crowd because Every officially designated 'pro free speech warrior' I've seen in recent times has been strongly for authoritarianism if it suits their agenda. Just ask many of them for their opinion on say Palestine or Yemen and you'll lots of ugly things come out, none of which are consistent with the image of 'freedom' these types like to portray themselves as. In fact, many of them seem to support anti-BDS laws and such. I do not endorse censorship attempts, but also let's not kid ourselves about the nature of many of the people who market themselves free speech advocates, please.
- tharne 4y ago> Every officially designated 'pro free speech warrior' I've seen in recent times has been strongly for authoritarianism if it suits their agenda. Huge sweeping claim, with exactly nothing to back it up.
- Matl 4y ago> In fact, many of them seem to support anti-BDS laws and such. This is a fairly easily to verify claim. Now of course it's not going to be all of them, but a large chunk from what I've seen. It's certainly more concrete than OP saying: > The people getting arrested in the streets of Edinburgh were the same people who have been arguing to take away free speech and privacy rights from others. Then providing nothing to back up the claim.
- codethief 4y agoExactly, that's my usual response to "I have nothing to hide: You don't decide what's worth hiding.
- IX-103 4y agoI like "then why are you wearing clothes?"
- marlowe221 4y agoMine is "Do you close the door when you go to the bathroom?"
- philipov 4y agoMine is: "I will be expecting your credit card and bank information on my table in the morning"
- yibg 4y agoOr "describe all your past sexual encounters". Granted, some might be ok with it, but most won't feel comfortable.
- jll29 4y agoIn any case, your phone provider knows - co-occurring presence of the same two phones in the same grid cell at the same time (esp. night). By implication, what your provider knows, governments also know - they have a direct line.
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- sjaak 4y agoCanonical example here are the records (that included religion) kept by the Dutch that enabled the nazis to easily round up all the jews in The Netherlands during WWII
- hinkley 4y agoMcCarthyism was how this played out in the states. Not as brutal and bloody, but lives were still ruined. In theory it’s unconstitutional here to prosecute someone for an act they committed before there was a law against it. But there are other ways to convict someone, for better or worse. Corporations leverage this all the time, so they go unpunished unless it’s in the court of public opinion. The toolset is necessary but the power dynamics are important.
- dredmorbius 4y agoI'd include the Jim Crow / opposition to civil rights movements. Which were bloody and brutal. Today is the 59th anniversary of the 16th Street Baptist Church bombing, in which four girls aged 11--14 were killed, and another 14--22 injured. <https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/16th_Street_Baptist_Church_bombing https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/16th_Street_Baptist_Church_bom...>
- SeqDesign 4y agoexcuse me, could you clarify if your statement about marks and blocks here (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12118609 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=12118609) was about WordStar or Emacs? thank you PS I'm sorry for digressing; there was no reply button on that post.
- dredmorbius 4y agoNeither. vi / vim. See: <https://vim.fandom.com/wiki/Using_marks https://vim.fandom.com/wiki/Using_marks> <https://www.marksanborn.net/software/using-markers-in-vim/ https://www.marksanborn.net/software/using-markers-in-vim/> (Six year old comment comes back to haunt me ... Could've been worse ;-)
- 2OEH8eoCRo0 4y agoRight. The Jewish before the Holocaust had nothing to hide either. Their ethnicity was outed by things like census data that people divulged and the state collected. Nothing to hide after all. It's not a crime to be Jewish. Mountains of personal data is too juicy and is inevitably misused.
- andsoitis 4y ago> The Jewish before the Holocaust had nothing to hide either. Actually it started much earlier than that. Christian started going after Jews since at least the fourth century, inspired by the hatred written in the Gospel of John. In particular, it was a Christian ritual to physically attack Jews around Easter in the Middle Ages. More detail: https://theconversation.com/why-good-friday-was-dangerous-for-jews-in-the-middle-ages-and-how-that-changed-114896 https://theconversation.com/why-good-friday-was-dangerous-fo...
- JimmieMcnulty 4y agoEh, you may not “know” something like this, but considering it’s never happened in my country in my lifetime at any appreciable scale, it’s probably not very likely, and doesn’t realistically factor into my threat model. If you want to “worst case” scenario something, that’s your choice, but it’s not very predictive.
- simonw 4y agoLucky you. I've lived in the UK and the US and seen examples of this happening in both.
- JimmieMcnulty 4y agoNo you haven’t, not to any meaningful degree.
- Woeps 4y agoWho are you to decide what is "to any meaningful degree" for others?
- JimmieMcnulty 4y agoA guy who cares about evaluating the likelihood and significance of an event taking place. I'm not value judging this, I'm just trying to determine if it's worth reacting to, and based on the number of folks effected, the severity of the impact, and the frequency, privacy violations seem pretty minor overall as a threat, not worth considering within my personal attack surface.
- Woeps 4y ago"I'm not value judging this, I'm just trying to determine if it's worth reacting to" Sorry... but some nice contradiction you have there. I think your "algorithm" might be a bit off ;)
- ho_schi 4y agoThe way to hell is paved with good intentions. I'm looking at the European Union and at Apple and Google. Good intentions? That doesn't mean that you're the good guys! History has shown that the bad guys always believe strongly that they were the good guys. Privacy and security is not only about protection from criminals and companies but especially about protection from our governments. It doesn't matter wether you voted for your government or not or you like them or not or they like you or not.
- chaxor 4y agoI'm not sure why it's especially governments. I find this propensity for privacy focused people to overlap with more conservative thinking individuals very perplexing. Especially since typically the more prominent feature of conservatism is support towards large corporations - which are the largest entities removing our privacy. It's not especially governments for which you need to keep the integrity of your privacy - it's everyone. And I would imagine if we're trying to estimate the entities that pry the most, it's corporations. Sure, they may feed it to governments, but there's an energy barrier there (in at least some circumstances) - but the trust of corporations is one of the bigger issues here.
- sdrinf 4y agoA steelman of that perspective (full disclosure: I'm leaning more libertarian, but my stance is complicated, and nuanced), is that you can just not use facebook, but government's laws are full liability -they enforce (rather than describe) norms, and stances which can suffocate non-represented minorities, and you can not opt out in ways other than moving. People are many, and weird, and different; the attention of lawmakers & govs are limited, and this can (and have repeatedly made) roadkill of you, with no recourse other than privacy. In security, to make an assessment of overall risk of a potential vulnerability, we take into account both the probability, and the impact of exploiting such vulnerability. Facebook, and corporations in general, ultimately want to move merch, and, at worst, make you vote for candidates of their choice: probability of being successful is medium, but impact for the individual is relatively low. Goverment laws can roadkill you: probability of this ranges from low to medium, but impact is super high. This advises for being especially vigilant for gov interventions, especially where freedom, and liberties are concerned.
- tomkaos 4y agoThe future politic of other country to. I love to travel, so I try not critic other country online just because I scared that can be use against me when visiting a country with a authoritarian regime.
- koheripbal 4y agoI work with prosecutors, and some of them will straight up misrepresent innocent facts to paint them as evidence of malicious intent and pressure parties to plead guilty. I have seen stuff like "defendant had TOR installed - a popular program for criminals" in court filings. ...and judges and juries accept that as fact because they just don't understand the technology. For example, having a bookmark for "Hacker News" would absolutely show up in court. Crazy stuff meant to bias judges and juries that don't know tech. The point is that the situation is 100x worse in tech where prosecutors, judges, and juries simply do not understand the evidence. ANYTHING can be painted as incriminating evidence. I have seen saved credentials on automation jobs being used to incorrectly establish people's network activity. I have seen routine maintenance being used to establish obstruction charges just to intimidate possible witnesses... Like stuff you would not believe happens, happens. It's even worse in civil suits, where opposing counsel will subpoena as much as possible (mountains of data) just to give you more work and fish for trade secrets or anything they can twist in court. When I was junior, I proudly told my legal team "good news, I added space to keep our transaction records for 20 years!" and was aghast when they said they wanted files deleted THE DAY the legal requirement to hold it expired because it increased legal liability. Now I totally get it. Today we only store the bare minimum - everything else is deleted immediately. ... and I have to re-explain this to junior employees each year to their disgust.
- Buttons840 4y ago> having a bookmark for "Hacker News" would absolutely show up in court And would the defense be allowed to show the legal and harmless conversations we have here? Or ask the prosecutors which HN posts they believe influenced the accused to commit a crime?
- deleted 4y ago[deleted]
- Zuider 4y agoYour Honor, we were horrified to discover the largest collection of "PDF files" we have ever seen on the defendant's hard drive!
- snarf21 4y agoI think you can even attack this position immediately. When a person (or politician) say they have nothing to hide, ask them to hand you their unlocked phone. You will promise to not tell anyone about anything that you learn or see. I've found that this triggers people desire for privacy even if they haven't committed any "crimes" or what not.
- recursivedoubts 4y agoExactly. You have nothing to hide... yet.
- wooque 4y agoI have nothing to hide. If government wants to lock me up for viewing interracial porn, so be it.